The study of topological phases of matter has long relied on one-dimensional "playgrounds" to establish fundamental principles. In 1D, researchers can precisely control quantum states, often finding exact solutions for complex phenomena like the Haldane phase or Majorana bound states. However, a massive effort is currently underway to bridge the gap between these well-understood 1D models and the more complex, higher-dimensional architectures required for fault-tolerant quantum computing and exotic materials.
The 1D Success Story as a Foundation
One-dimensional systems have provided the "mathematical DNA" for topological physics. For instance, Takuya Kitagawa, Mark S. Rudner, and Eugene Demler demonstrated in Exploring topological phases with quantum walks that discrete-time quantum walks can simulate every symmetry class of topological phases in 1D. Similarly, the work of Frank Pollmann, Ari M. Turner, and Masaki Oshikawa in Entanglement spectrum of a topological phase in one dimension showed that the entanglement spectrum provides a robust way to classify these phases.
These 1D models work because they simplify the relationship between symmetry and geometry. In a 1D chain, the "boundary" is just two points, making the identification of "topologically protected" edge states straightforward. But as we move to 2D and 3D, the boundaries become lines and surfaces, and the interactions become significantly more complex.
Building Higher Dimensions from Wires
One of the most intuitive ways to understand the transition to higher dimensions is "wire deconstructionism." As proposed by Claudio Chamon, Christopher Mudry, and Ronny Thomale in Wire deconstructionism and classification of topological phases, we can think of a 2D topological phase as an array of 1D quantum wires coupled together. By tuning the interactions between these wires, researchers can "sew" together 1D physics to create 2D topological insulators or even fractional phases.
However, this approach hits a wall in 3D. While 2D systems are well-characterized by invariants like the Chern number, 3D systems introduce unavoidable band crossings and more intricate topological textures. Gang Xu and colleagues explored this in Chern Semimetal and the Quantized Anomalous Hall Effect in HgCr2Se4, showing how stacking layers leads to the emergence of Weyl semimetals—a state that has no direct 1D analog.
The Challenge of Dimensional Complexity
The move to higher dimensions isn't just a matter of adding more particles; it fundamentally changes how systems respond to disorder and driving.
- Topological Pumping: In 1D, "Thouless pumping" allows for the quantized transport of particles across a chain. Michael Levin and Ehud Altman showed in Quantized Pumping and Topology of the Phase Diagram for a System of Interacting Bosons that this is a robust property of the phase diagram. Yet, as Yu Liu and others noted in Interplay between disorder and topology in Thouless pumping on a superconducting quantum processor, scaling this to 2D or 3D lattices remains a significant hardware and theoretical challenge.
- Non-Hermitian Braiding: In systems where energy is not conserved (non-Hermitian), energy bands can "braid" around each other. Qicheng Zhang recently observed these Acoustic Non-Hermitian Bloch Braids in 1D synthetic momentum space. Extending this to higher dimensions is necessary to uncover more complex "knots" in energy structures that could lead to new types of sensors.
- Cooling and Defects: Even cooling a system into a topological state becomes harder in higher dimensions. Anne Matthies, Mark S. Rudner, and Achim Rosch pointed out in Programmable adiabatic demagnetization for systems with trivial and topological excitations that while 1D chains can be cooled by trapping and annihilating excitations, higher-dimensional manifolds make defect removal significantly more complex.
Why It Matters: Impossible Physics
The ultimate goal of this research direction is to realize physics that is mathematically impossible in lower dimensions. For example, Kevin Slagle and Cenke Xu have investigated how the boundary of a 4D topological state can host a stable version of Quantum Electrodynamics (QED) that cannot exist in a standalone 3D universe.
By treating 1D and 2D systems as building blocks, researchers are not just scaling up; they are searching for the point where increased dimensionality allows for the emergence of "string-net excitations" and other phenomena that B. Andrei Bernevig notes in Topological Superconductors and Category Theory are still missing physical counterparts in solid-state materials. The transition from 1D to 3D is the transition from toy models to the next generation of quantum technology.