Topological eigenvalues braiding and quantum state transfer near a third-order exceptional point

He Zhang, Tong Liu, Zhongcheng Xiang, Kai Xu, Heng Fan, Dongning ZhengarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

This paper, recently published by researchers at the Chinese Academy of Sciences and Chalmers University, explores the exotic topological landscape of non-Hermitian quantum systems. By using a superconducting circuit to simulate a three-level system, the team successfully observed the "braiding" of energy eigenvalues and unique state transfer behaviors associated with a third-order exceptional point (EP3).

TL;DR

Researchers experimentally demonstrated eigenvalue braiding and chiral state transfer in a three-dimensional non-Hermitian quantum system using superconducting circuits. By leveraging system symmetries to simplify the control of a third-order exceptional point, they mapped out the complex $B_3$ braid group and discovered counterintuitive state transfer rules that differ from simpler two-level systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In standard (Hermitian) quantum mechanics, energy eigenvalues are real, and the system's state evolves predictably. However, in "non-Hermitian" systems—which account for gain and loss—eigenvalues can become complex. The most interesting features of these systems are Exceptional Points (EPs): singularities where multiple eigenvalues and their corresponding eigenstates merge (coalesce).

While second-order EPs (EP2s) are well-studied, higher-order EPs like EP3s (where three states merge) offer a much richer topological structure. However, EP3s are notoriously difficult to study experimentally because they typically require the simultaneous control of four independent parameters. This paper addresses the challenge of observing and manipulating the complex topology of an EP3 using a manageable number of control variables.

Methods

The authors utilized a superconducting quantum processor featuring a transmon qubit coupled to a microwave resonator.

  • The System: They treated the transmon as a three-level "qutrit" ($|g\rangle, |e\rangle, |f\rangle$). By using a cavity-assisted Raman process, they created a controllable coupling between these states and the resonator.
  • Non-Hermiticity: The resonator has a much higher decay rate than the transmon, providing the "loss" necessary to make the Hamiltonian non-Hermitian.
  • Symmetry as a Tool: To overcome the four-parameter requirement for an EP3, the team exploited pseudo-chirality and anti-PT symmetry. By operating at a specific frequency detuning ($\delta_{ef} = 0$), they reduced the required parameters to just three ($\delta_{ef}, \Omega, G$), allowing them to isolate and encircle an EP3 in a 3D parameter space.
  • Measurement: They performed two types of experiments:
  • Quasistatic Encirclement: Slowly changing parameters and measuring the eigenvalues at each step to map out "braids."
    1. Dynamic Encirclement: Rapidly driving the system along a loop to observe how the quantum state transfers between levels.

Datasets

As an experimental physics paper, it does not use standard ML datasets. The "data" consists of:

  • State population measurements from a 10-qubit superconducting processor (specifically qubit $Q_{10}$).
  • Extracted complex eigenvalues derived from fitting the population dynamics of the three qutrit states.
  • Numerical simulations used to validate the experimental state transfer results.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Eigenvalue Braiding: When you move parameters in a loop around an EP, the eigenvalues don't just return to their starting points; they swap positions. In a 3-level system, these trajectories resemble intertwined strands of a braid. The authors successfully mapped the Artin braid group $B_3$, demonstrating that the order in which you encircle different EPs matters (non-Abelian behavior).
  • The Yang-Baxter Relation: They experimentally verified the braid identity $\sigma_1\sigma_2\sigma_1 = \sigma_2\sigma_1\sigma_2$, a fundamental concept in topological physics and string theory.
  • Anisotropy of EP3: The researchers found that the topological structure near an EP3 is highly directional (anisotropic). This means the "knot" formed by the eigenvalues depends heavily on the specific path taken through the 3D parameter space.
  • Counterintuitive State Transfer: In 2D systems, encircling an EP usually causes "chiral" (direction-dependent) state transfer. Surprisingly, in this 3D system, they observed chiral transfer when no EPs were enclosed and time-symmetric behavior when EPs were enclosed. This highlights how higher-dimensional topologies break the "rules" we learned from simpler systems.

Key Results

  • EP Identification: The team successfully located EP2s and an EP3 by observing the coalescence of eigenvalues in the complex plane.
  • Braid Mapping: They reproduced the fundamental elements of the $B_3$ braid group ($\sigma_1$ and $\sigma_2$) through quasistatic loops.
  • State Transfer Efficiency: Under a fast driving scheme, they demonstrated that a clockwise loop could transfer a state from $|\psi_2\rangle$ to $|\psi_3\rangle$, while a counter-clockwise loop transferred it to $|\psi_1\rangle$, provided no EPs were inside the loop.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Decoherence: While superconducting circuits have long coherence times, the "fast driving" required to observe these effects is a race against natural system decay.
  • Adiabaticity: The transition between quasistatic (slow) and dynamic (fast) regimes is complex; the authors note that oscillations in state overlaps suggest the system isn't perfectly adiabatic.
  • Scaling Up: The authors suggest that future work could involve coupling multiple transmons to explore entanglement near high-order EPs, which could lead to new ways of generating Bell states or performing topological quantum gates.

Reference: Zhang, H., et al. (2024). Topological eigenvalues braiding and quantum state transfer near a third-order exceptional point. arXiv:2412.14733v1 [quant-ph].

Summary updated

Abstract

Non-Hermitian systems exhibit a variety of unique features rooted in the presence of exceptional points (EP). The distinct topological structure in the proximity of an EP gives rise to counterintuitive behaviors absent in Hermitian systems, which emerge after encircling the EP either quasistatically or dynamically. However, experimental exploration of EP encirclement in quantum systems, particularly those involving high-order EPs, remains challenging due to the difficulty of coherently controlling more degrees of freedom. In this work, we experimentally investigate the eigenvalues braiding and state transfer arising from the encirclement of EP in a three-dimensional non-Hermitian quantum system using superconducting circuits. We characterize the second- and third-order EPs through the coalescence of eigenvalues. Then we reveal the topological structure near the EP3 by quasistatically encircling it along various paths with three independent parameters, which yields the eigenvalues braiding described by the braid group $B_3$. Additionally, we observe chiral state transfer between three eigenstates under a fast driving scheme when no EPs are enclosed, while time-symmetric behavior occurs when at least one EP is encircled. Our findings offer insights into understanding non-Hermitian topological structures and the manipulation of quantum states through dynamic operations.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2024topological,
  author = {He Zhang and Tong Liu and Zhongcheng Xiang and Kai Xu and Heng Fan and Dongning Zheng},
  title = {{Topological eigenvalues braiding and quantum state transfer near a third-order exceptional point}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2412.14733},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.14733},
}
Figure