Abstract
In this paper, we investigate the topological numbers for singly rotating Kerr black holes in arbitrary dimensions and four-dimensional Kerr-Newman black hole. We show that for uncharged black holes, the rotation parameter has a significant effect on the topological number, and for rotating black holes, the dimension of spacetime has a remarkable effect on the topological number too. In addition, we find that the topological numbers of the four-dimensional Kerr and Kerr-Newman black holes are the same, which seems to indicate that the electric charge parameter has no effect on the topological number of rotating black holes. Our current research provides more evidence that the conjecture put forward in Wei et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 191101 (2022)], according to which all black hole solutions should be separated into three different topological classes, is accurate, at least in the pure Einstein-Maxwell gravity theory.
Introduction: Classifying Black Holes via Topology
Traditionally, black holes are characterized by their "hair"—mass, charge, and angular momentum. Recent theoretical developments have introduced a more fundamental classification scheme based on topology. By viewing black holes as topological defects within a thermodynamic landscape, researchers can assign a "topological number" ($W$) to each solution. This number serves as a robust identifier, grouping seemingly disparate black hole types into universal classes.
While previous studies focused on static black holes, this research extends the topological framework to rotating black holes—the most physically relevant class in our universe. Specifically, the study examines singly rotating Kerr black holes across various dimensions and the four-dimensional Kerr-Newman (charged and rotating) black hole.
Methodology: The Thermodynamic Landscape
The analysis employs the generalized off-shell free energy framework. An "off-shell" free energy ($\mathcal{F}$) is constructed as a function of the horizon radius ($r_h$) and an auxiliary temperature variable $\tau$.
From this, a vector field $\phi$ is derived. The "zero points" of this field—where the vector vanishes—represent physical black hole solutions. By applying Duan’s $\phi$-mapping topological current theory, a "winding number" ($w$) is calculated for each zero point. The total topological number $W$ is the sum of these winding numbers, defining the black hole's topological class.
Key Insights: Rotation and Dimension
The study reveals that both rotation and the number of spacetime dimensions significantly influence a black hole's topological signature.
Rotation as a Topological Driver
For uncharged black holes, the introduction of spin fundamentally alters the topology. A static Schwarzschild black hole belongs to Class I ($W = -1$). However, adding rotation to create a 4D Kerr black hole shifts it to Class II ($W = 0$). This shift is due to the emergence of a "generation point" where two distinct branches of black hole solutions (one stable, one unstable) appear.
The "Dimension Divide"
Spacetime dimensionality ($d$) plays a critical role. While 4D and 5D rotating black holes share $W = 0$, a transition occurs at $d = 6$. For six dimensions and higher, the topological number reverts to $W = -1$. This suggests that higher-dimensional gravity imposes different topological constraints on rotating solutions compared to their lower-dimensional counterparts.
Charge Invariance
A surprising finding is that electric charge appears to be topologically "passive" for rotating black holes. The 4D Kerr-Newman black hole retains $W = 0$, identical to the uncharged 4D Kerr black hole. This indicates that rotation is a more dominant factor than charge in determining thermodynamic topology.
Conclusion and Universal Classification
The results provide strong evidence for the conjecture that all black hole solutions fall into three distinct topological classes:
- Class I ($W = -1$): Includes Schwarzschild and $d \ge 6$ rotating Kerr black holes.
- Class II ($W = 0$): Includes 4D Kerr, Kerr-Newman, and Reissner-Nordström black holes.
- Class III ($W = 1$): Includes Reissner-Nordström-AdS black holes.
Future research will explore multi-axis rotation in higher dimensions and the impact of a non-zero cosmological constant to further test the universality of this topological classification.
Summary updated