Abstract
In this paper, via employing the uniformly modified form of the generalized off-shell Helmholtz free energy, we investigate the topological numbers for the four-dimensional neutral Lorentzian Taub-NUT, Taub-NUT-AdS and Kerr-NUT spacetimes, and find that these solutions can also be classified into one of three types of those well-known black hole solutions, which implies that these spacetimes should be viewed as generic black holes from the viewpoint of the thermodynamic topological approach.
Introduction
In General Relativity, Lorentzian NUT-charged spacetimes (named after Newman, Unti, and Tamburino) have historically been viewed as problematic due to "wire singularities" known as Misner strings along their polar axes. These features led many early physicists to dismiss them as unphysical. However, recent developments in black hole thermodynamics have prompted a re-evaluation of these solutions. This study addresses whether NUT-charged spacetimes are fundamentally distinct from standard black holes or if they belong to the same thermodynamic family. By examining their "thermodynamic topology," the research classifies these spacetimes based on the stability and winding numbers of their thermodynamic states.
Methodology: Thermodynamic Topological Approach
The study utilizes the thermodynamic topological approach, rooted in Duan’s $\phi$-mapping theory. The core of this method involves the generalized "off-shell" Helmholtz free energy ($\mathcal{F}$), which introduces an auxiliary variable $\tau$ representing the inverse temperature of a hypothetical cavity surrounding the black hole.
A vector field $\phi$ is constructed from the derivatives of this free energy. The zero points (ZP) of this field correspond to the physical black hole solutions. By analyzing the "winding" of this vector field around its zero points, a winding number ($w$) is assigned to each solution, and a total topological number ($W$) is calculated for the spacetime.
The analysis was applied to three specific cases: the static Taub-NUT (asymptotically flat), the rotating Kerr-NUT, and the static Taub-NUT-AdS (with a negative cosmological constant).
Key Insights and Results
The most significant finding is that the NUT charge parameter ($n$), despite its geometric complexity, does not alter the final topological classification. The study confirms that NUT-charged spacetimes fit into the three existing topological classes previously identified for standard black holes.
For the static Taub-NUT case, the zero point of the vector field follows a linear trajectory as the inverse temperature $\tau$ varies, as shown in Figure 1. This trajectory represents the set of physical solutions for the spacetime.
The results are summarized in the following classification:
| Solution | Topological Number ($W$) | Winding Number ($w$) | Comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taub-NUT | $-1$ | $-1$ | Matches Schwarzschild black holes. |
| Kerr-NUT | $0$ | $-1, +1$ | Matches rotating Kerr black holes ($d \geq 6$). |
| Taub-NUT-AdS | $0$ | $-1, +1$ | Matches Schwarzschild-AdS black holes. |
A winding number of $-1$ indicates an unstable solution (like a small black hole that wants to evaporate), while $+1$ indicates a stable one. The Taub-NUT behaves like an unstable Schwarzschild black hole at any given temperature. In contrast, Kerr-NUT and Taub-NUT-AdS exhibit "generation" or "annihilation" points where stable and unstable branches meet, resulting in a total topological charge of zero.
Conclusion
This research demonstrates that NUT-charged spacetimes should be viewed as "generic" black holes from a thermodynamic perspective, regardless of their axial singularities. Their topological numbers align perfectly with those of Schwarzschild and Kerr black holes. Future work will extend this analysis to charged (RN-NUT) cases and explore the relationship between geometric singularities and thermodynamic topology in greater depth.
Summary updated