Thermodynamics of Barrow Einstein-power-Yang-Mills AdS black hole in the restricted phase space

Yun-Zhi Du, Hui-Hua Zhao, Yang Zhang, Qiang GuChinese 2024 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper explores the thermodynamics of Einstein-Power-Yang-Mills (EPYM) black holes in anti-de Sitter (AdS) space, incorporating a "fractal" black hole horizon structure. They find that this fractal nature breaks the standard Smarr relation and leads to unique phase transition behaviors, including a supercritical phase transition, offering new insights into quantum gravity effects on black hole thermodynamics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Black hole thermodynamics has been a crucial tool for understanding quantum gravity, particularly through the lens of AdS/CFT correspondence. While the "extended phase space" approach, where the cosmological constant is treated as a thermodynamic pressure, has revealed rich phase structures (like Van der Waals-like transitions), it also presents theoretical challenges, such as inconsistencies with the dual field theory and a non-homogeneous Smarr relation. This paper tackles these issues by investigating black hole thermodynamics in the "restricted phase space" and, importantly, by incorporating a novel concept: the fractal nature of the black hole horizon, proposed by Barrow. This fractal structure is hypothesized to arise from quantum gravitational effects and could offer a new perspective on how these effects manifest in thermodynamic properties. The authors aim to understand how this fractal horizon, combined with the EPYM gravity model and the restricted phase space, influences the phase structure and stability of these black holes.

Methods

The study employs standard thermodynamic techniques applied to black hole solutions. They start with the metric for a four-dimensional spherically symmetric static EPYM AdS black hole. The key novelties lie in:

  • Barrow Entropy: Instead of the standard Bekenstein-Hawking entropy, they use the Barrow entropy formula, which introduces a fractal parameter ($\Delta$) to account for the fractal horizon structure. $\Delta=0$ recovers the standard entropy, while $\Delta \in [0,1]$ represents increasing fractal complexity.
  • Restricted Phase Space: They work within the restricted phase space, where the cosmological constant and Newton's constant are fixed. This contrasts with the extended phase space where they are treated as thermodynamic variables.
  • Thermodynamic Laws and Relations: They derive the first law of thermodynamics and the Smarr relation for this system. A significant finding is that the fractal structure breaks the homogeneity of the Smarr relation in the restricted phase space, a departure from standard black hole thermodynamics.
  • Phase Transition Analysis: They analyze phase transitions by examining the behavior of thermodynamic quantities like temperature and entropy, and by calculating the heat capacity. The presence of supercritical phase transitions and the role of the fractal parameter and non-linear Yang-Mills parameter ($\gamma$) in determining stability are investigated.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a theoretical physics study based on mathematical models and derivations, not empirical data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fractal Horizon as a Thermodynamic Probe: The fractal structure of the black hole horizon, introduced via Barrow entropy, acts as a sensitive probe for phase transitions. Its presence significantly alters thermodynamic behavior.
  • Smarr Relation Breakdown: The fractal horizon structure fundamentally breaks the homogeneity of the Smarr relation in the restricted phase space. This is a direct consequence of quantum gravity effects and highlights the limitations of standard thermodynamic relations when such effects are considered.
  • Supercritical Phase Transitions: The EPYM AdS black hole with a fractal horizon exhibits a supercritical phase transition, a phenomenon distinct from the first-order transitions seen in simpler models. This transition's behavior is linked to the central charge and the degree of freedom in the dual conformal field theory.
  • Fractal Structure and Phase Transition Suppression: At the maximum fractal structure ($\Delta=1$), physical phase transitions are suppressed. This suggests that extreme fractalization can lead to a more uniform thermodynamic state.
  • Restricted vs. Extended Phase Space Equivalence (without fractalization): When the fractal parameter $\Delta=0$ (i.e., no fractal structure), the thermodynamic properties in the restricted phase space become identical to those in the extended phase space. This implies that the fractal nature is the key differentiator.

Key Results

  • The mass parameter of the black hole is interpreted as internal energy in the restricted phase space.
  • The Smarr relation in the restricted phase space is found to be non-homogeneous due to the fractal structure.
  • A supercritical phase transition is observed for the EPYM AdS black hole with a fractal horizon.
  • The fractal parameter $\Delta$ and the non-linear Yang-Mills parameter $\gamma$ significantly influence the stability of the black hole, with larger $\Delta$ and $\gamma$ potentially expanding the region of unstable phases.
  • For $c > 1$ (normalized center charge), the system exhibits a first-order phase transition with stable large/small black hole phases and an unstable intermediate phase. For $c \le 1$, the system is stable.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Analytical vs. Numerical Analysis: While some analytical results are presented, the analysis of phase diagrams and the behavior of certain quantities often relies on numerical calculations, especially when considering various values of $\Delta$ and $\gamma$.
  • Specific Gravity Model: The study focuses on EPYM gravity. Extending this analysis to other gravity models or higher dimensions could reveal broader implications.
  • Holographic Interpretation: While the paper touches upon holographic interpretations, a more in-depth exploration of how the fractal horizon and restricted phase space thermodynamics map to the dual field theory would be valuable.
  • Experimental Verification: As with most theoretical black hole thermodynamics studies, direct experimental verification is currently impossible.

The authors suggest that the fractal structure of the black hole horizon can be viewed as a probe for phase transitions, and their work provides a foundation for further investigations into the interplay between quantum gravity effects, fractal geometry, and black hole thermodynamics in different phase spaces and gravity models.

Summary updated

Abstract

As we know that due to the quantum gravitational effects black hole horizons are ``fractalized'' into a sphereflake by Barrow. Based on this issue, in this work we investigate the phase structure and stability of the Einstein-Power-Yang-Mills AdS black holes with the fractal structure on the black hole horizon in the restricted phase space. Through the thermodynamics first law and the Smarr relation in the restricted phase space, we observe that the mass parameter is understood as the inter energy and the Smarr relation is not a homogeneous function of order one for all quantities due to the fractal structure. And the fractal structure can be regarded as a phase transition probe. When this system with the fixed central charge there exists a novel phenomena: the supercritical phase transition. Furthermore the effects of the fractal parameter and non-linear Yang-Mills parameter on the thermodynamics stability of this system are also investigated.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{du2024thermodynamics,
  author = {Yun-Zhi Du and Hui-Hua Zhao and Yang Zhang and Qiang Gu},
  title = {{Thermodynamics of Barrow Einstein-power-Yang-Mills AdS black hole in the restricted phase space}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure