Abstract: Throughout the study of the geodesics of some popular spherically symmetric regular black holes, we hereby prove that the analytically extended Hayward black hole is geodetically incomplete. The simplest extension of the Culetu-Simpson-Visser's non-analytic smooth black hole is also geodetically incomplete, with the exception of the antipodal continuation of the radial geodesics. However, the huge ambiguity in the extension of non analytic spacetimes is tantamount of geodesic incompleteness and such spacetimes do not solve the singularity issue unless at least all the extensions turn out to be complete. Hence, we provide several mere modifications of such spacetimes in order to make them geodetically complete in all possible extensions beyond $r=0$.
Introduction
In standard General Relativity, the center of a black hole is typically a singularity—a point of infinite curvature where physical laws fail. "Regular" black holes were proposed to resolve this by replacing the singularity with a smooth core. However, finite curvature alone does not guarantee a physically sound spacetime. A fundamental requirement is geodesic completeness: the ability to track the path of any particle or light ray indefinitely into the past and future. If a geodesic terminates at a boundary in finite proper time, the spacetime is incomplete and physically problematic. This study evaluates whether popular regular models, specifically the Hayward and Culetu-Simpson-Visser (CSV) black holes, satisfy this criterion.
Methodology
The analysis employs standard general relativistic tools to examine the motion of test particles:
- Metric Analysis: Examining the mathematical structure of the Hayward and CSV metrics.
- Geodesic Equations: Deriving equations of motion for radially infalling massive particles.
- Proper Time Integration: Calculating the time experienced by a particle to reach the center ($r=0$).
- Analytic Extension: Attempting to extend the coordinate system to negative radial values ($r < 0$) to determine if paths can continue or if they encounter hidden singularities (poles).
Key Results and Insights
The Incompleteness of the Hayward Model
A major finding is that the Hayward black hole, despite its regular appearance at $r=0$, is geodetically incomplete. While curvature remains finite at the center, particles crossing into the analytically extended $r < 0$ region encounter a physical singularity at $r = -L$ within finite proper time. This "hidden" singularity renders the spacetime incomplete.
Ambiguity in Non-Analytic Extensions
For non-analytic models like the CSV black hole, the transition at $r=0$ is not uniquely defined. The authors argue that this "huge ambiguity" in how to extend the spacetime is as detrimental as a singularity because it destroys predictability—physics cannot uniquely determine a particle's trajectory beyond the center.
Proposed Solutions for Completeness
The authors demonstrate that geodesic completeness in these models can be achieved by ensuring the metric functions involve even powers of the radial coordinate $r$. This symmetry prevents the formation of poles in the negative-$r$ region. They propose a modified CSV-like metric: $$f(r) = 1 - \frac{2M}{r} e^{-a^2/r^2}$$ This function is continuous at $r=0$ and allows for a smooth, complete extension to $r = -\infty$, effectively resolving the incompleteness issue.
Conclusion
The study concludes that "regularity" (finite curvature) is not a substitute for geodesic completeness. Popular models like the Hayward black hole fail to provide a truly continuous spacetime. By utilizing analytic extensions and symmetric metric functions, it is possible to construct truly complete regular black holes. Future research is needed to explore the thermodynamic properties and stability of these modified spacetimes, particularly regarding Hawking radiation and gravitational collapse.
Summary updated