Abstract
We investigate the accretion disk for a sort of regular black holes which are characterized by sub-Planckian curvature and Minkowskian core. We derive null geodesics outside the horizon of such regular black holes and analyze the feature of the light rays from the accretion disk which can be classified into direct emission, lensed rings, and photon rings. We find that the observed brightness under different emission models is mainly determined by direct emission, while the contribution from the flux of the lensed and photon rings is limited. By comparing with Bardeen black hole with a dS core, it is found that the black hole with a Minkowskian core exhibits distinct astronomical optical features when surrounded by accretion disk, which potentially provides a way to distinguish these two sorts of black holes by astronomical observation.
Introduction
In classical General Relativity, black holes are predicted to contain singularities—points of infinite density where the laws of physics break down. To address this, "regular" black holes (RBHs) have been proposed, utilizing quantum gravity corrections to avoid such singularities. While traditional RBHs like the Bardeen model feature a de-Sitter (dS) core, a newer class of models proposes a Minkowskian core, where spacetime near the center is flat. This study explores whether these theoretical models produce observable differences in the light emitted from surrounding accretion disks, particularly in light of recent imaging from the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT).
Methodology and Ray Tracing
The researchers analyzed a spherically symmetric metric where gravitational potential is exponentially suppressed near the center, ensuring sub-Planckian curvature. By deriving the equations of motion for photons (null geodesics), they simulated light rays traveling from an accretion disk to a distant observer.
Light rays are classified based on their interaction with the accretion disk, defined by the number of orbits $n = \phi/2\pi$:
- Direct emission ($n < 3/4$): Light intersects the disk once.
- Lensed rings ($3/4 < n < 5/4$): Light intersects the disk twice.
- Photon rings ($n > 5/4$): Light intersects the disk three or more times.
The study tested three emission models: radiation starting at the Innermost Stable Circular Orbit (ISCO), the photon sphere, and the event horizon.
Key Insights: The Minkowskian Fingerprint
A primary finding is that black holes with a Minkowskian core exert a stronger gravitational pull on photons near the horizon compared to those with a dS core. This leads to wider photon and lensed rings, which could be easier to resolve with future high-resolution telescopes.
Furthermore, as the deviation parameter ($\alpha_0$)—representing quantum gravity effects—increases, the radius of the black hole shadow and the photon sphere both decrease. This "shadow shrinkage" is a key metric for distinguishing these objects from standard Schwarzschild black holes.
Results and Comparative Analysis
The simulations reveal that observed brightness is dominated by direct emission across all models. However, the specific structure of the core (Minkowskian vs. de-Sitter) leaves a distinct "fingerprint" on the external light paths.
Key results include:
- Shadow Size: Schwarzschild black holes possess the largest shadows. RBHs with Minkowskian cores have smaller shadows than Bardeen black holes (dS core) for the same mass.
- Intensity Peaks: In the ISCO model, the peak intensity for a Minkowskian-core black hole is lower and occurs closer to the center than in the Bardeen model.
- Transfer Functions: The photon rings of Minkowskian-core models account for a higher proportion of the total flux, potentially making them more detectable.
Limitations and Future Outlook
While these results provide a theoretical framework for distinguishing black hole cores, several limitations remain. The current study assumes static, non-rotating black holes and uses simplified thin-disk models. Real astrophysical black holes typically rotate, which would distort the shadow and rings. Future research will focus on extending these models to rotating (Kerr-like) black holes and employing General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD) to better simulate complex accretion flows. Additionally, while these differences are theoretically distinct, current telescope technology like the EHT may require further advancements in angular resolution to confirm these findings.
Summary updated