Emission Modeling in the EHT–ngEHT Age

Richard Anantua, Joaquín Dúran, Nathan Ngata, Lani Oramas, Jan Röder, Razieh Emami, Angelo Ricarte, Brandon Curd, Avery E. Broderick, Jeremy Wayland, George N. Wong, Sean M. Ressler, Nitya Nigam, Emmanuel Durodola

Abstract

This work proposes a methodology to test phenomenologically-motivated emission processes that account for the flux and polarization distribution and global structure of the 230 GHz sources imaged by the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT): Messier (M)87 and Sagittarius (Sgr) A. We introduce to general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations some novel models to bridge the largely uncertain mechanisms by which high-energy particles in jet/accretion flow/black hole (JAB) system plasmas attain billion degree temperatures and emit synchrotron radiation. The "Observing" JAB Systems methodology then partitions the simulation to apply different parametric models to regions governed by different plasma physics -- an advance over methods where one parametrization is used over simulation regions spanning thousands of gravitational radii from the central supermassive black hole. We present several classes of viewing-angle dependent morphologies, and highlight signatures of piecewise modeling and positron effects -- including a MAD/SANE dichotomy in which polarized maps appear dominated by intrinsic polarization in the MAD case and by Faraday effects in the SANE case. The library of images thus produced spans a wide range of morphologies awaiting discovery by the groundbreaking EHT instrument and its yet more sensitive, higher resolution next-generation counterpart ngEHT.

Introduction

The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) has provided groundbreaking images of M87 and Sgr A, yet interpreting these observations remains a significant challenge. Current models primarily rely on General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations, which track heavy ions. However, the observed light is synchrotron radiation from electrons and potentially positrons. A critical "gap" exists in our understanding of thermodynamics: how energy transfers from turbulent magnetic fields and ions to these radiating particles. Historically, "one-size-fits-all" parameters were applied across entire simulations, failing to account for the distinct physics of high-speed jets versus dense accretion disks.

Methodology: The "Observing JAB Systems" Framework

To address these limitations, this research introduces the "Observing" JAB (Jet/Accretion flow/Black hole) Systems pipeline. This framework partitions simulations based on magnetization ($\sigma$)—the ratio of magnetic energy density to mass density—allowing for region-specific plasma physics.

The pipeline utilizes state-of-the-art GRMHD codes (e.g., HARM, kharma) and applies various parametric prescriptions for electron heating:

  • $R-\beta$ Model: Relates ion-to-electron temperature ratios to plasma $\beta$ (gas-to-magnetic pressure).
  • Critical $\beta$ Model: Employs an exponential transition to control electron heating efficiency.
  • Sub-Equipartition Models: Relates electron pressure directly to magnetic pressure (e.g., "Constant $\beta_e$").
Comparison of electron-to-proton temperature ratios ($T_e/T_p$) as a function of plasma $\beta$ for the $R-\beta$ and Critical $\beta$ models.

Relativistic radiative transfer is then used to generate synthetic images, spectra, and polarization (Stokes) maps. The study explores two primary targets: M87 (modeled as SANE or MAD with spin $a = -0.5$) and Sgr A (spin $a = 0.5$).

Key Insights and Results

The framework reveals several critical astrophysical signatures:

The MAD/SANE Dichotomy

A striking finding is the behavior of polarization. In Magnetically Arrested Disk (MAD) models, where strong magnetic fields stall accretion, polarization maps reflect the intrinsic magnetic field orientation. Conversely, in Standard and Normal Evolution (SANE) models, maps are dominated by Faraday effects, which scramble polarization patterns as light traverses dense plasma.

Positron Signatures and Morphology

The inclusion of positrons significantly impacts circular polarization. In MAD systems, they suppress it; in SANE systems, they "scramble" the linear polarization pattern (EVPA) due to high Faraday depth. Furthermore, the research categorizes edge-on morphologies into four types, ranging from thin photon rings to extended outflows with flat spectra.

The "Compactness Dial"

The "Critical $\beta$" parameter ($\beta_c$) serves as a dial for image compactness. Increasing $\beta_c$ shifts emission from the outflowing jet to the inflowing gas near the event horizon, increasing image asymmetry.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The next-generation EHT (ngEHT), with its enhanced sensitivity (~5 mJy) and higher frequency range (up to 345 GHz), will be vital for resolving low-flux regions and breaking degeneracies between models. While computational costs currently limit full radiative GRMHD, this post-processing approach provides a robust library of morphologies. Multi-frequency observations will eventually allow researchers to determine the precise "recipe" for electron heating in these extreme environments, distinguishing between effects caused by General Relativity and those driven by specific plasma physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

This work proposes a methodology for testing phenomenologically motivated emission processes that account for the flux and polarization distribution and global structure of the 230 GHz sources imaged by the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT): Messier (M)87* and Sagittarius (Sgr) A*. We introduce into general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations some novel models to bridge the largely uncertain mechanisms by which high-energy particles in jet/accretion flow/black hole (JAB) system plasmas attain billion-degree temperatures and emit synchrotron radiation. The “Observing” JAB Systems methodology then partitions the simulation to apply different parametric models to regions governed by different plasma physics—an advance over methods in which one parametrization is used over simulation regions spanning thousands of gravitational radii from the central supermassive black hole. We present several classes of viewing-angle-dependent morphologies and highlight signatures of piecewise modeling and positron effects, including a MAD/SANE dichotomy in which polarized maps appear dominated by intrinsic polarization in the MAD case and by Faraday effects in the SANE case. The library of images thus produced spans a wide range of morphologies awaiting discovery by the groundbreaking EHT instrument and its yet more sensitive, higher-resolution next-generation counterpart, ngEHT.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{anantua2022emission,
  author = {Richard Anantua and Joaquín Dúran and Nathan Ngata and Lani Oramas and Jan Röder and Razieh Emami and Angelo Ricarte and Brandon Curd and Avery E. Broderick and Jeremy Wayland and George N. Wong and Sean M. Ressler and Nitya Nigam and Emmanuel Durodola},
  title = {{Emission Modeling in the EHT–ngEHT Age}},
  booktitle = {Galaxies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/galaxies11010004},
}
Figure