Appearance of an Infalling Star in Black Holes with Multiple Photon Spheres

Yiqian Chen, Guangzhou Guo, Peng Wang, Houwen Wu, Haitang YangarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Photon spheres play a pivotal role in the imaging of luminous objects near black holes. In this paper, we examine observational appearances of a star freely falling in hairy black holes, which can possess one or two photon spheres outside the event horizon. When there exists a single photon sphere, the total luminosity measured by distant observers decreases exponentially with time at late times. Due to successive arrivals of photons orbiting around the photon sphere different times, a specific observer would see a series of light flashes with decreasing intensity, which share a similar frequency content. Whereas in the case with two photon spheres, photons temporarily trapped between the photon spheres can cause a peak of the total luminosity, which is followed by a slow exponential decay, at late times. In addition, these photons lead to one more series of light flashes seen by the specific observer.

Introduction

Recent achievements by the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) have made black hole imaging a reality. The defining features of these images—the dark "shadow" and the bright ring—are dictated by the black hole's photon sphere, a region where gravity is so intense that light travels in unstable circular orbits. Standard black holes in General Relativity, such as Schwarzschild or Kerr black holes, possess a single photon sphere. However, certain modified theories of gravity, including Einstein-Maxwell-scalar (EMS) models, predict the existence of "hairy" black holes that can possess multiple photon spheres outside their event horizon. This paper investigates how the presence of an extra photon sphere alters the dynamic, time-dependent visual appearance of a luminous object, such as a star, falling into the black hole.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The authors conduct numerical simulations of a point-like star falling radially from rest into a static, spherically symmetric hairy black hole. They utilize a 4-dimensional EMS model where a scalar field non-minimally couples to an electromagnetic field. By tuning the black hole's charge, they generate effective potentials with either a single peak (one photon sphere) or a double peak (two photon spheres).

The effective potential $V_{eff}$ as a function of radius $r$ and impact parameter $b$. The peak of the potential defines the location of the photon sphere, separating regions of capture (gray) and reflection (green).

As the star falls, it isotropically emits photons in its rest frame. The authors trace the null geodesics of these photons through the curved spacetime to a distant "celestial sphere" where observers are located. They calculate the normalized frequency of the received light, accounting for both gravitational redshift and Doppler shifts, and the total normalized luminosity over time.

Key Insights: Photon Trapping and Blueshift

A significant finding is the "Doppler Blueshift Surprise." While light escaping a black hole is typically redshifted, photons emitted inward that slingshot around the photon sphere can experience a Doppler effect (due to the star's high infalling velocity) that overpowers the gravitational redshift, resulting in blueshifted flashes.

Furthermore, light rays with an impact parameter very close to the critical value of the photon sphere can orbit the black hole multiple times before escaping. This creates a "hall of mirrors" effect, where a single emission event results in a cascade of delayed light flashes reaching the observer.

Photon trajectories for impact parameters $b=3.564$ (left) and $b=3.900$ (right). The dashed blue line represents the photon sphere, around which light can orbit multiple times before escaping.

In a black hole with two photon spheres, light can get temporarily trapped in the gravitational "valley" between the inner and outer spheres. This causes a significant delay in when those photons finally leak out, fundamentally altering the late-time visual signature.

Numerical Results

For a black hole with a single photon sphere, the total observed luminosity eventually decays exponentially ($L \propto e^{-\lambda t}$). A specific observer sees a series of distinct flashes, each corresponding to light that orbited the black hole $n=1, 2, 3...$ times.

In the double photon sphere case, the outer sphere initially dictates the behavior. However, at late times, photons trapped between the inner and outer spheres begin to leak out. This leads to a surprising peak in total luminosity long after the initial decay, followed by a much slower exponential decay. An observer will also see an additional series of light flashes caused specifically by this trapped light.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that the presence of multiple photon spheres creates unique observational signatures, including delayed luminosity peaks and extra cascades of light flashes. While the current model uses idealized conditions—such as a point-like source and a static black hole—it provides a theoretical foundation for detecting exotic black hole geometries. Future research will generalize these findings to rotating black holes and more astrophysically realistic stellar models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Photon spheres play a pivotal role in the imaging of luminous objects near black holes. In this paper, we examine observational appearances of a star freely falling in hairy black holes, which can possess one or two photon spheres outside the event horizon. When there exists a single photon sphere, the total luminosity measured by distant observers decreases exponentially with time at late times. Due to successive arrivals of photons orbiting around the photon sphere different times, a specific observer would see a series of light flashes with decreasing intensity, which share a similar frequency content. Whereas in the case with two photon spheres, photons temporarily trapped between the photon spheres can cause a peak of the total luminosity, which is followed by a slow exponential decay, at late times. In addition, these photons lead to one more series of light flashes seen by the specific observer.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2022appearance,
  author = {Yiqian Chen and Guangzhou Guo and Peng Wang and Houwen Wu and Haitang Yang},
  title = {{Appearance of an Infalling Star in Black Holes with Multiple Photon Spheres}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2206.13705},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.13705},
}
Figure