Geodesics in Carrollian Reissner-Nordström black holes

Bin Chen, Hui Sun, Jie XuarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

In the world of theoretical physics, we often explore the "Newtonian limit" where the speed of light ($c$) is effectively infinite. But what happens at the opposite extreme, where the speed of light approaches zero? This is the Carrollian limit, an ultra-relativistic regime that reveals a strange, "squeezed" version of reality.

A recent paper by Bin Chen, Haowei Sun, and Jie Xu dives into this frontier, specifically examining how particles move—their geodesics—around charged (Reissner-Nordström) black holes in Carrollian spacetime.

TL;DR

This paper derives the paths of neutral and charged particles around Carrollian Reissner-Nordström (RN) black holes, showing that the ultra-relativistic limit "squeezes" the global structure of spacetime. The authors find that these black holes can act as "mirrors" for incoming particles and that adding charge to a particle can restrict its motion entirely to fixed circular orbits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While Einstein’s General Relativity is our gold standard for gravity, physicists often study its limits to gain deeper insights into holography, black hole horizons, and condensed matter systems like fractons. The Carrollian limit ($c \to 0$) is particularly interesting because it introduces the concept of absolute space, where time becomes a secondary, fiber-like dimension.

Previous research has explored Carrollian versions of neutral (Schwarzschild) black holes. However, real-world physics involves electromagnetism. This paper addresses the gap by introducing charge into the mix, studying the Reissner-Nordström (RN) black hole. The challenge lies in the math: in Carrollian geometry, the metric is "degenerate" (it can't be inverted like a standard matrix), making the traditional equations for particle motion much harder to define and solve.

Methods

The authors utilize a weak Carrollian structure, defined by a triplet: a manifold, a degenerate metric ($h_{\mu\nu}$), and a temporal vector ($n^\mu$). Crucially, they avoid using "ruled" structures, which are easier to calculate but break a fundamental gauge symmetry called local boost invariance.

To find the particle paths, they:

  1. Derive Geodesic Equations: They use a specific action principle designed for degenerate metrics to find the equations of motion for massive particles.
  2. Classify Limits: They examine two distinct Carrollian limits of the RN black hole: the "electric-electric" limit and the "magnetic-electric" limit.
  3. Project onto Absolute Space: Because coordinate time becomes ambiguous in this limit, they project the trajectories onto the "absolute space" to ensure the results are unique and well-defined.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a theoretical physics paper, it relies on mathematical derivation and analytical solutions rather than experimental datasets or simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spacetime Squeezing: In standard General Relativity, a charged black hole has an infinite number of asymptotic regions. In the Carrollian limit, these regions get "squeezed." A non-extreme black hole is reduced to just two flat patches, while an extreme one (where charge and mass are perfectly balanced) has only one.
  • The Mirror Effect: For non-extreme black holes, the authors discovered that the Carrollian Extremal Surfaces (CES)—the Carrollian version of an event horizon—act like a perfect mirror. A particle falling from infinity hits the CES and is reflected back into another asymptotic region in finite "proper time."
  • Instantons: In the electric-electric limit, neutral particles don't move through space in the traditional sense. Instead, they exist at discrete radial values, behaving like "instantons" that wind around the black hole.
  • Charge-Induced Circularity: Perhaps the most striking finding is that for charged particles in a magnetic-electric background, the interaction with the electromagnetic field is so restrictive that the only allowed motion is a circular orbit at a fixed radius.

Key Results

  • Deflection Angles: The authors calculated the deflection of massive particles (since massless "null" particles don't move in this limit). They found that the leading-order deflection matches the Schwarzschild case, but the charge introduces unique higher-order corrections.
  • Stability Analysis: They proved that circular orbits at the outer CES are unstable (a small nudge sends the particle flying away or falling in), while orbits at the inner CES are stable.
  • Geodesic Completeness: The CES divides the spacetime into regions that are "geodesically complete," meaning a particle starting in one region can never cross into another within a finite amount of its own internal clock.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the physical interpretation of Carrollian "proper time" ($\tau$) is still a subject of debate; it may represent an intrinsic space-like distance rather than a time interval. Furthermore, the "null" (massless) case in this framework is trivial because particles simply do not move, which limits the study's applicability to light-like phenomena.

Future research could extend this work to rotating (Kerr) black holes or investigate how quantum fields behave in these "squeezed" Carrollian environments, potentially opening new doors in the study of quantum gravity and holography.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this work, we study the geodesics in different types of Carrollian RN (Reissner-Nordström) black holes, considering the motions of both neutral and charged particles. We use the geodesic equations in the weak Carrollian structure and analyze the corresponding trajectories projected onto the absolute space, and find that the geodesics are well-defined. In particular, we examine the electric-electric and magnetic-electric limit of the RN black hole, focusing on their geodesic structures. We find that the global structures of the usual RN black holes get squeezed under the ultra-relativistic limit. More precisely, the nonextreme magnetic-electric RN spacetime has two different asymptotic flat patches while the extreme black hole spacetime consists of only one patch. For the magnetic-electric RN spacetime, the Carrollian extremal surfaces (CESs) divide the spacetime into several geodesically complete regions, and the geodesics can only travel in one of these regions. For the charged particles, we extend the analysis by considering their interactions with the electromagnetic field in the Carrollian RN spacetimes and find that their trajectories are significantly different from the neutral geodesics.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2024geodesics,
  author = {Bin Chen and Hui Sun and Jie Xu},
  title = {{Geodesics in Carrollian Reissner-Nordström black holes}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2410.20420},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.20420},
}
Figure