A simple accretion model of a rotating gas sphere onto a Schwarzschild black hole

E. A. Huerta, S. MendozaarXiv 2006 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This study presents a simple accretion model for a rotating, pressureless gas sphere falling onto a Schwarzschild black hole. By constructing analytic solutions using Jacobi elliptic functions, the authors provide a general relativistic generalization of the classic Newtonian accretion model proposed by Ulrich (1976). While the flow naturally predicts the formation of an equatorial rotating accretion disc, the model reveals a striking relativistic departure: the disc radius increases monotonically without limit as the flow reaches its maximum allowed angular momentum.

Introduction

Accretion—the gravitational capture of matter by a massive object—is the fundamental power source for the universe's most energetic phenomena, including quasars, active galactic nuclei, and X-ray binaries. Historically, models have often been bifurcated: they were either purely spherical (such as Bondi accretion) or relied on Newtonian physics. In 1976, Ulrich developed a seminal model for a rotating gas sphere falling onto a central star, which successfully predicted the formation of equatorial accretion discs.

However, near the event horizon of a black hole, Newtonian gravity is no longer a valid approximation. While previous researchers attempted to "relativize" Ulrich’s work using pseudo-Newtonian potentials (like the Paczynsky-Wiita potential), these methods often miss the full geometric nuances of curved spacetime. This paper, published by E. A. Huerta and S. Mendoza, bridges this gap by providing the first exact, analytical general relativistic (GR) solution for this rotating flow.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The authors utilize a ballistic approximation, assuming the gas is pressureless. This simplification is particularly effective for supersonic flows where gravitational forces significantly outweigh internal gas pressure and radiation.

To solve the equations of motion within a Schwarzschild spacetime, the authors focused on the geodesic equations of individual gas particles. The mathematical breakthrough of this work lies in the use of Jacobi elliptic functions. Unlike numerical simulations that provide discrete data points, these functions allowed the authors to derive exact, closed-form equations for the velocity fields ($v_r, v_\theta, v_\phi$) and the particle number density ($n$).

To quantify the deviation from Newtonian physics, the authors introduced a dimensionless parameter: $$\alpha = 2(M/h)^2$$ where $M$ is the mass of the black hole and $h$ is the specific angular momentum of the gas. This parameter serves as a gauge for the intensity of relativistic effects within the flow.

Key Insights: The Expanding Disc Paradox

The most significant finding of this research is the behavior of the accretion disc in the relativistic limit. In Newtonian physics, the radius of an accretion disc is proportional to the square of the angular momentum ($r_d \propto h^2$); thus, as angular momentum decreases, the disc shrinks.

In the GR model, however, there is a physical "floor" to angular momentum. The authors identified a critical limit where the specific angular momentum $h = 2r_g$ (where $r_g$ is the Schwarzschild radius). As the flow approaches this relativistic limit, the model predicts that the disc radius does not shrink, but actually increases monotonically without limit. In this extreme state, the disc effectively expands to occupy the entire equatorial plane.

Furthermore, the GR solution resolves a common issue in Newtonian models: the density singularity. Newtonian models often predict an infinite density spike at the edge of the disc. The relativistic solution "softens" this profile; as the disc radius grows, the matter redistributes itself, resulting in a smoother, more physically realistic density gradient.

Comparison with Pseudo-Newtonian Models

The study also highlights the limitations of the popular Paczynsky-Wiita potential. While pseudo-Newtonian models are easier to calculate, they fail to capture the precise trajectories of particles near the horizon. The authors found that while pseudo-Newtonian models incorrectly predict that certain particles fall directly into the black hole, the full GR solution demonstrates that these particles are actually "injected" into the accretion disc, significantly altering the predicted structure of the inner flow.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This model serves as a robust mathematical bridge, converging perfectly with the 1976 Ulrich Newtonian model when relativistic effects are removed ($\alpha \to 0$) and with the 1972 Michel relativistic spherical model when rotation is removed ($h \to 0$).

While the ballistic assumption provides a clear analytical path, it ignores the complexities of magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) and pressure gradients found in real astrophysical plasmas. Future extensions of this work could incorporate these factors or apply the methodology to a Kerr black hole. A rotating black hole would introduce frame-dragging effects, adding another layer of complexity to the interaction between the rotating gas and the curved geometry of spacetime.

Summary updated

Abstract

We construct a simple accretion model of a rotating pressureless gas sphere onto a Schwarzschild black hole. We show how to build analytic solutions in terms of Jacobi elliptic functions. This construction represents a general relativistic generalisation of the Newtonian accretion model first proposed by Ulrich (1976). In exactly the same form as it occurs for the Newtonian case, the flow naturally predicts the existence of an equatorial rotating accretion disc about the hole. However, the radius of the disc increases monotonically without limit as the flow reaches its maximum allowed angular momentum.
BibTeX
@misc{huerta2006simple,
  author = {E. A. Huerta and S. Mendoza},
  title = {{A simple accretion model of a rotating gas sphere onto a Schwarzschild black hole}},
  year = {2006},
  eprint = {gr-qc/0603039},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0603039},
}
Figure