Abstract
We present analytical calculations and numerical simulations for the synchronization of oscillators interacting via a long-range power law interaction on a one-dimensional lattice. We have identified the critical value of the power law exponent $\alpha_c$ across which a transition from a synchronized to an unsynchronized state takes place for a sufficiently strong but finite coupling strength in the large system limit. We find $\alpha_c = 3/2$. Frequency entrainment and phase ordering are discussed as a function of $\alpha \ge 1$. The calculations are performed using an expansion about the aligned phase state (spin-wave approximation) and a coarse graining approach. We also generalize the spin-wave results to the $d$-dimensional problem.
Introduction
Synchronization is a fundamental phenomenon observed in diverse systems, from biological rhythms to physical oscillators. In one-dimensional systems, the Mermin-Wagner theorem traditionally suggests that macroscopic synchronization cannot be sustained with short-range interactions in the thermodynamic limit. However, many physical systems, such as nanoelectromechanical systems (NEMS) or cold atoms, exhibit long-range interactions that decay as a power law, $1/r^\alpha$. This paper investigates the threshold of this decay exponent, $\alpha$, required to overcome the disruptive effects of 1D geometry and achieve global synchronization.
Theoretical Framework: The Spin-Wave Approximation
To analyze the stability of the synchronized state, the authors employ a spin-wave approximation, linearizing the equations of motion by assuming oscillators are nearly aligned. This approach allows for the calculation of the phase order parameter, $|\Psi_{ph}|$, which measures the degree of alignment in the system.
Analytically, the study identifies a critical exponent $\alpha_c = 1.5$. For $\alpha < 1.5$, the system can maintain long-range phase order and frequency entrainment. As $\alpha$ approaches this tipping point from below, the order parameter drops sharply toward zero, signaling the breakdown of the synchronized state into finite, disconnected clusters.
Numerical Verification and Finite-Size Effects
To validate the theoretical predictions, the authors conducted numerical simulations of up to 16,384 oscillators. To manage the $O(N^2)$ complexity of long-range interactions, a Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) method was implemented, treating the interaction as a convolution and reducing computational cost to $O(N \log N)$.
The simulations confirm that for $\alpha \le 1.3$, the spin-wave theory matches numerical results with high precision. However, as $\alpha$ increases toward 2.0, the system exhibits significant finite-size effects. Previous studies had conjectured a critical limit of $\alpha_c \simeq 2$ based on numerical data; this paper corrects that finding, demonstrating that the true thermodynamic limit is $\alpha_c = 1.5$. The discrepancy in earlier work is attributed to the extremely large system sizes ($N > 10^{47}$) required to observe the true asymptotic behavior near the critical point.
Conclusion
This work establishes $\alpha_c = 1.5$ as the critical threshold for synchronization in 1D power-law coupled systems. The results generalize to $d$-dimensional lattices with a predicted critical exponent of $\alpha_c = 3d/2$. These findings provide a rigorous theoretical basis for understanding how long-range interactions facilitate collective behavior in low-dimensional systems, correcting previous numerical misconceptions and highlighting the profound impact of finite-size effects in long-range coupled networks.
Summary updated