Synchronization of oscillators with long-range power law interactions

Debanjan Chowdhury, M. C. CrossPhysical 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We present analytical calculations and numerical simulations for the synchronization of oscillators interacting via a long-range power law interaction on a one-dimensional lattice. We have identified the critical value of the power law exponent $\alpha_c$ across which a transition from a synchronized to an unsynchronized state takes place for a sufficiently strong but finite coupling strength in the large system limit. We find $\alpha_c = 3/2$. Frequency entrainment and phase ordering are discussed as a function of $\alpha \ge 1$. The calculations are performed using an expansion about the aligned phase state (spin-wave approximation) and a coarse graining approach. We also generalize the spin-wave results to the $d$-dimensional problem.

Introduction

Synchronization is a fundamental phenomenon observed in diverse systems, from biological rhythms to physical oscillators. In one-dimensional systems, the Mermin-Wagner theorem traditionally suggests that macroscopic synchronization cannot be sustained with short-range interactions in the thermodynamic limit. However, many physical systems, such as nanoelectromechanical systems (NEMS) or cold atoms, exhibit long-range interactions that decay as a power law, $1/r^\alpha$. This paper investigates the threshold of this decay exponent, $\alpha$, required to overcome the disruptive effects of 1D geometry and achieve global synchronization.

Theoretical Framework: The Spin-Wave Approximation

To analyze the stability of the synchronized state, the authors employ a spin-wave approximation, linearizing the equations of motion by assuming oscillators are nearly aligned. This approach allows for the calculation of the phase order parameter, $|\Psi_{ph}|$, which measures the degree of alignment in the system.

Analytically, the study identifies a critical exponent $\alpha_c = 1.5$. For $\alpha < 1.5$, the system can maintain long-range phase order and frequency entrainment. As $\alpha$ approaches this tipping point from below, the order parameter drops sharply toward zero, signaling the breakdown of the synchronized state into finite, disconnected clusters.

Theoretical prediction of the phase order parameter |Ψ_ph| showing the sharp transition at the critical exponent α_c = 1.5.

Numerical Verification and Finite-Size Effects

To validate the theoretical predictions, the authors conducted numerical simulations of up to 16,384 oscillators. To manage the $O(N^2)$ complexity of long-range interactions, a Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) method was implemented, treating the interaction as a convolution and reducing computational cost to $O(N \log N)$.

The simulations confirm that for $\alpha \le 1.3$, the spin-wave theory matches numerical results with high precision. However, as $\alpha$ increases toward 2.0, the system exhibits significant finite-size effects. Previous studies had conjectured a critical limit of $\alpha_c \simeq 2$ based on numerical data; this paper corrects that finding, demonstrating that the true thermodynamic limit is $\alpha_c = 1.5$. The discrepancy in earlier work is attributed to the extremely large system sizes ($N > 10^{47}$) required to observe the true asymptotic behavior near the critical point.

Numerical results for the phase order parameter |Ψ_ph| as a function of α for different system configurations, demonstrating the transition from synchronized to unsynchronized states.

Conclusion

This work establishes $\alpha_c = 1.5$ as the critical threshold for synchronization in 1D power-law coupled systems. The results generalize to $d$-dimensional lattices with a predicted critical exponent of $\alpha_c = 3d/2$. These findings provide a rigorous theoretical basis for understanding how long-range interactions facilitate collective behavior in low-dimensional systems, correcting previous numerical misconceptions and highlighting the profound impact of finite-size effects in long-range coupled networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present analytical calculations and numerical simulations for the synchronization of oscillators interacting via a long-range power law interaction on a one-dimensional lattice. We have identified the critical value of the power law exponent α(c) across which a transition from a synchronized to an unsynchronized state takes place for a sufficiently strong but finite coupling strength in the large system limit. We find α(c)=3/2. Frequency entrainment and phase ordering are discussed as a function of α≥1 . The calculations are performed using an expansion about the aligned phase state (spin-wave approximation) and a coarse graining approach. We also generalize the spin-wave results to the d -dimensional problem.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chowdhury2010synchronization,
  author = {Debanjan Chowdhury and M. C. Cross},
  title = {{Synchronization of oscillators with long-range power law interactions}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.82.016205},
}
Figure