Higher condensation theory

Liang Kong, Zhi-Hao Zhang, Jiaheng Zhao, Hao ZhengarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Higher Condensation Theory: A Unified Framework for Topological Phases

TL;DR

This paper introduces a unified mathematical framework, "higher condensation theory," to describe phase transitions in topological orders across all dimensions. It achieves this by leveraging advanced concepts from higher category theory, higher algebra, and higher representations to precisely define how topological defects can condense, leading to new topological phases. This work provides a powerful tool for understanding and classifying a wide range of phenomena in condensed matter physics and high-energy physics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern physics has uncovered exotic phases of matter beyond traditional symmetry-breaking orders, such as topological orders and symmetry-protected/enriched topological (SPT/SET) orders. Understanding the transitions between these phases, and indeed unifying them under a single paradigm, remains a significant challenge. The paper identifies defect condensation as a universal mechanism driving many of these phase transitions. While some aspects of defect condensation have been studied in specific dimensions (e.g., anyon condensation in 2+1D), a comprehensive, model-independent theory for arbitrary dimensions and defect codimensions was lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by developing a unified mathematical theory of defect condensations.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in its development of a unified mathematical framework for defect condensations. This framework is built upon:

  • Higher Categories: The paper utilizes higher categorical structures to describe the relationships and compositions of topological defects, which are themselves viewed as objects within these categories.
  • Higher Algebras: Topological defects are characterized as "condensable $E_k$-algebras," where $E_k$ refers to a specific type of higher algebraic structure. The condensation process is then described as a k-step procedure of condensing these higher algebras.
  • Higher Representations: The paper explores the concept of higher representations to understand the structure of topological defects and their interactions.

The condensation process itself is described as a k-step procedure. A k-codimensional defect is condensed sequentially along its transversal directions, each step reducing the codimension of the defect and naturally equipping it with a lower-order algebraic structure. This process ultimately leads to a new topological phase and a gapped domain wall. The paper also introduces a geometric approach to defect condensations, complementing the algebraic one.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Defect Condensation as a Universal Mechanism: The paper posits that defect condensation is a fundamental and universal mechanism driving phase transitions between topological orders, applicable across all dimensions and defect codimensions.
  • Higher Algebra as the Language of Defects: The theory establishes that higher algebras (specifically $E_k$-algebras) are the natural mathematical objects describing condensable topological defects.
  • A Unified Framework: By employing higher categories and algebras, the authors provide a single, coherent framework to describe phenomena previously studied in isolation, such as anyon condensation and gauging symmetries.
  • Geometric Intuition for Algebraic Structures: The paper emphasizes the power of geometric intuition in understanding and deriving complex algebraic structures related to defect condensations.
  • Connection to Gauging Symmetries: The theory reveals deep connections between defect condensations and various notions of "gauging" symmetries, suggesting a unified perspective on these concepts.

Key Results

The paper presents a comprehensive mathematical theory of defect condensations, including:

  • Precise Mathematical Descriptions: Detailed definitions and theorems are provided for the k-step condensation process, characterizing the resulting topological phases and domain walls.
  • Unified Theory for All Dimensions: The framework is developed for general n+1D topological orders and k-codimensional defects, unifying previous results in lower dimensions.
  • Connection to Higher Morita Theory: The theory naturally leads to insights into higher Morita theory, exploring equivalences between different topological orders.
  • Classification of Defects and Phases: The work provides tools for the construction and classification of condensable algebras and Lagrangian algebras, which are crucial for understanding topological orders and their transitions.
  • Geometric Approach: A geometric theory of defect condensations is developed, offering physical intuition and computational advantages.
  • Connections to Gauging Symmetries: The paper establishes explicit connections between defect condensations and various notions of gauging symmetries.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mathematical Rigor: The authors acknowledge that while the paper provides physical intuition and mathematical results, a fully rigorous mathematical treatment of the subject, particularly concerning higher categories and their structures, is beyond the scope of this work and will be presented in a separate mathematical companion.
  • Fermionic Condensations: The condensations studied in this work are primarily "bosonic." A systematic study of fermionic condensations is left for future work.
  • Infinite Type Condensations: The theory focuses on "finite type" condensations. The concept of "infinite type" condensations, relevant for approaching critical points of phase transitions where systems become gapless, is mentioned as a direction for future development.
  • Gapless Liquid-like Defects: While the theory is generalized to discuss condensations of liquid-like gapless defects, a more detailed study is deferred to future work.
  • Higher Dimensional Chiral Topological Orders: The classification of condensations involving chiral topological orders in higher dimensions (n > 3) is noted as a challenging area due to the limited knowledge of such orders.
  • Physical Realizations: The paper mentions the need for more progress in constructing lattice models that realize anyon condensations, particularly for higher dimensions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We develop a unified mathematical theory of defect condensations for topological orders in all dimensions based on higher categories, higher algebras and higher representations. A k-codimensional topological defect $A$ in an n+1D (potentially anomalous) topological order $C^{n+1}$ is condensable if it is equipped with the structure of a condensable $E_k$-algebra. Condensing such a defect $A$ amounts to a k-step process. In the first step, we condense the defect $A$ along one of its transversal directions, thus obtaining a (k-1)-codimensional defect $ΣA$, which is naturally equipped with the structure of a condensable $E_{k-1}$-algebra. In the second step, we condense the defect $ΣA$ in one of the remaining transversal directions, thus obtaining a (k-2)-codimensional defect $Σ^2 A$, so on and so forth. In the k-th step, we condense the 1-codimensional defect $Σ^{k-1}A$ along the only transversal direction, thus defining a phase transition from $C^{n+1}$ to a new n+1D topological order $D^{n+1}$. We give precise mathematical descriptions of each step in above process, including the precise mathematical characterization of the condensed phase $D^{n+1}$. When $C^{n+1}$ is anomaly-free, the same phase transition can be alternatively defined by replacing the last two steps by a single step of condensing the $E_2$-algebra $Σ^{k-2}A$ directly along the remaining two transversal directions. When n=2, this modified last step is precisely a usual anyon condensation in a 2+1D topological order. We derive many new mathematical results physically along the way. We also establish the connections among various notions of "gauging" symmetries. We also briefly discuss questions, generalizations and applications that naturally arise from our theory, including higher Morita theory, a theory of integrals and the condensations of liquid-like gapless defects in topological orders.
BibTeX
@misc{kong2024higher,
  author = {Liang Kong and Zhi-Hao Zhang and Jiaheng Zhao and Hao Zheng},
  title = {{Higher condensation theory}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2403.07813},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07813},
}

Loading related content...

Figure