Self-dual Quantum Electrodynamics on the boundary of 4d Bosonic Symmetry Protected Topological States

Zhen Bi, Kevin Slagle, Cenke XuarXiv 2015 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

In the study of condensed matter physics, Symmetry Protected Topological (SPT) phases represent states of matter that are "trivial" in their bulk—meaning they are gapped and non-degenerate—but possess highly unusual, protected states on their boundaries. While 1D, 2D, and 3D SPTs, such as topological insulators, have been extensively documented, higher-dimensional systems offer a unique playground for theoretical physics.

This research explores the exotic physics emerging when a 3D universe is viewed as the boundary (or "skin") of a 4D bosonic symmetry-protected topological (BSPT) state. By utilizing a systematic nonlinear sigma model (NLSM) field theory, the study demonstrates the existence of a stable, self-dual version of Quantum Electrodynamics (QED) that evades the standard constraints of 3D gauge theories.

The Challenge of 3D Compact QED

A fundamental problem in 3D (or 3+1D) physics is that "compact" QED—where the gauge group is $U(1)$—typically undergoes a process known as confinement. In a standalone 3D system, the vacuum is susceptible to the proliferation of magnetic monopoles. These monopoles effectively "eat" the photons, causing them to become gapped and heavy, which prevents the existence of a stable, gapless photon phase like the one observed in our universe.

This paper addresses whether the topological protection afforded by a 4D bulk can prevent this confinement. The authors investigate if the boundary of a 4D BSPT state can host a stable, gapless 3D photon phase that carries unique topological signatures, effectively "deconfining" the theory through bulk-boundary correspondence.

Theoretical Framework: Nonlinear Sigma Models

The authors employ a Nonlinear Sigma Model (NLSM) field theory description to map the behavior of these states. This approach allows for a rigorous analysis of how fields behave under specific symmetry groups. Key technical components of their methodology include:

  • Wess-Zumino-Witten (WZW) Terms: The researchers use these topological terms to describe the boundary physics, showing that a 4D bulk action can be reduced to a 3D boundary action characterized by a level-1 WZW term.
  • $CP^1$ Parametrization: By representing 3D boundary fields using complex variables, the authors identify the relationship between "electric" charges ($e$) and "magnetic" monopoles ($m$).
  • Dimensional Reduction: Through mathematically "slicing" the 4D system into domain walls, the study proves that the core of a monopole in this specific system behaves like a 1D quantum spin chain, providing a link between high-dimensional topology and lower-dimensional quantum mechanics.

Symmetry-Enforced Duality and Topological Protection

One of the most significant findings is the emergence of an exact electric-magnetic duality. In standard Maxwellian electromagnetism, electric and magnetic fields are similar but not perfectly symmetric. However, in this 4D-bulk/3D-boundary system, the bulk symmetry forces a perfect duality.

For instance, under time-reversal symmetry ($\mathcal{T}$), the electric charge and the magnetic monopole are exactly swapped. Furthermore, the authors find that a "dyon"—a particle carrying both electric and magnetic charge—behaves as a fermion (specifically a Kramers doublet), despite the system's original building blocks being entirely bosonic.

Because the electric charges and magnetic monopoles carry "projective representations" of the bulk symmetry (fractional quantum numbers), they are forbidden from condensing and disappearing. This symmetry protection keeps the photon gapless and deconfined, creating a stable "topological photon phase."

The 4D Slab Model

To bridge the gap between 4D theory and 3D reality, the authors propose a "slab" concept. In this model, a thin slice of 4D material is considered. One 3D surface of the slab hosts the self-dual QED (photons), while the opposite surface hosts a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ topological order.

In this configuration, the statistics and symmetry transformations of point particles and vison loop excitations ensure that the topological order cannot be driven into a trivial confined or Higgs phase. Together, these two boundaries constitute an exotic 3D self-dual topological photon phase that is intrinsically linked to the 4D bulk physics.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The paper successfully provides an existence proof for a 3D boundary theory that remains gapless and deconfined, avoiding the monopole proliferation that usually destabilizes 3D compact QED. While 4D systems are not naturally occurring, they can be simulated in "synthetic dimensions" using cold atoms or photonic crystals.

Future research may explore the $Z_4$ symmetry case more deeply, as the authors suspect a perturbative gauge anomaly might influence its transition into a gapped topological order. Additionally, the framework suggests that even more complex boundary states, such as deconfined non-abelian gauge fields (similar to gluons in QCD), could exist on the boundaries of higher-dimensional SPT states, opening new avenues for understanding the fundamental forces of nature through the lens of topological matter.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study $3d$ (or $(3+1)d$) Quantum Electrodynamics (QED) realized on the boundary of $4d$ (or $(4+1)d$) bosonic symmetry protected topological (BSPT) states, using a systematic nonlinear sigma model (NLSM) field theory description of BSPT states. We demonstrate that many of these QED states have an exact electric-magnetic duality due to the symmetry of the BSPT states in the $4d$ bulk. The gauge charge and Dirac monopole both carry projective representations of the bulk symmetry, and the emergent gapless photons of the QED phase also transform nontrivially under the bulk symmetry. Some of these QED boundary states can be further driven into a $3d$ $\mathbb{Z}_2$ topological order, and the statistics and symmetry transformation of its point particle and vison loop excitations guarantee that this topological order cannot be driven into a trivial confined or Higgs phase. With a finite fourth dimension, the entire system becomes a $3d$ lattice, the self-dual QED and the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ topological order can coexist on two opposite boundaries respectively, which together constitute an exotic $3d$ self-dual "topological photon phase".
BibTeX
@misc{bi2015self,
  author = {Zhen Bi and Kevin Slagle and Cenke Xu},
  title = {{Self-dual Quantum Electrodynamics on the boundary of 4d Bosonic Symmetry Protected Topological States}},
  year = {2015},
  eprint = {1504.04373},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1504.04373},
}
Figure