Classification and description of bosonic symmetry protected topological phases with semiclassical nonlinear sigma models

Zhen Bi, Alex Rasmussen, Kevin Slagle, Cenke XuPhysical 2015 · DOI · arXiv

Symmetry Protected Topological (SPT) phases represent a significant frontier in condensed matter physics. These quantum phases are characterized by the fact that they remain distinct from a trivial vacuum as long as certain symmetries—such as time-reversal or charge conservation—are preserved. While mathematicians and theoretical physicists have successfully classified these phases using the abstract framework of group cohomology, there has long been a need for a more physically intuitive description.

This paper, published in Physical Review B, provides that bridge. The authors develop a systematic framework using semiclassical Nonlinear Sigma Models (NLSMs) with topological $\Theta$-terms to classify and describe bosonic SPT phases across all physical dimensions. This approach not only aligns with the mathematical rigor of group cohomology but also offers a transparent physical picture of boundary states and the relationships between different topological phases.

The NLSM Framework

The core of the authors' methodology is the use of semiclassical Nonlinear Sigma Models. In these models, the state of a system is described by a unit-vector order parameter (living on a sphere). For a system in $d$ spatial dimensions, the authors employ an $O(d+2)$ NLSM in $(d+1)$-dimensional spacetime.

The "secret sauce" of this field theory is the addition of a topological $\Theta$-term to the action. In this context, the value of $\Theta$ determines the topological nature of the phase:

  • $\Theta = 0$: Represents a trivial phase.
  • $\Theta = 2\pi$: Represents a non-trivial SPT phase.

By embedding various symmetry groups—such as $Z_2$ (Ising), $U(1)$ (charge), or $SO(3)$ (spin)—into the transformations of this vector field, the authors can describe a wide variety of physical systems within a single unified framework.

The "Decorated Defect" Construction

One of the most insightful contributions of this work is the "decorated defect" picture. This provides a recursive, intuitive way to understand high-dimensional SPT phases. The authors demonstrate that many complex SPT phases can be viewed as lower-dimensional SPT phases "trapped" or "decorated" onto the defects of a symmetry-breaking order parameter.

For example, a 3D SPT phase can be constructed by taking the domain walls of an Ising symmetry and decorating them with 2D SPT phases. This construction clarifies how topological properties are woven into the fabric of the system's symmetry structure and provides a roadmap for building higher-dimensional topological states from simpler building blocks.

Boundary Physics and Stability

A primary advantage of the NLSM approach over abstract cohomology is its ability to explicitly describe what happens at the boundary of the material. The authors derive effective boundary theories (such as Wess-Zumino-Witten terms) to prove that the edges of these phases cannot be simple, gapped insulators. Instead, the boundaries must be either:

  1. Gapless: Behaving like a conductor or a critical liquid.
  2. Degenerate: Possessing multiple ground states that carry "fractional" quantum numbers.

In 3D systems, this leads to the fascinating possibility of "boundary topological order," where the 2D surface of a 3D bulk material hosts its own intrinsic topological order, complete with anyonic excitations that carry fractional symmetry labels.

Key Results and Classification Parity

The NLSM classification is shown to be perfectly consistent with the established group cohomology results. Furthermore, the field theory provides a simple explanation for the "parity" observed in topological classifications across dimensions:

  • Even-dimensional systems (like 2D) often have an infinite ($\mathbb{Z}$) classification.
  • Odd-dimensional systems (like 1D or 3D) usually have a finite ($\mathbb{Z}_2$) classification.

This distinction arises from whether multiple copies of a phase can be merged and smoothly deformed back to a trivial state within the NLSM framework. The paper provides a comprehensive "dictionary" of how different symmetries transform the NLSM vector field, making it a vital reference for researchers in the field.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the NLSM framework is powerful, the authors note that it primarily captures phases within the "group cohomology" classification. There exist rarer "beyond cohomology" phases—often related to gravity or specific lattice symmetries—that require even more complex field theories. Additionally, this work focuses strictly on bosonic systems (such as magnets or cold atom gases). Extending this intuitive NLSM approach to fermionic systems, like topological insulators, remains a significant and ongoing challenge in theoretical physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper we systematically classify and describe bosonic symmetry protected topological (SPT) phases in all physical spatial dimensions using semiclassical nonlinear Sigma model (NLSM) field theories. All the SPT phases on a $d-$dimensional lattice discussed in this paper can be described by the same NLSM, which is an O(d+2) NLSM in $(d+1)-$dimensional space-time, with a topological $\Theta-$term. The field in the NLSM is a semiclassical Landau order parameter with a unit length constraint. The classification of SPT phases discussed in this paper based on their NLSMs is consistent with the more mathematical classification based on group cohomology. Besides the classification, the formalism used in this paper also allows us to explicitly discuss the physics at the boundary of the SPT phases, and it reveals the relation between SPT phases with different symmetries. For example, it gives many of these SPT states a natural "decorated defect" construction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bi2015classification,
  author = {Zhen Bi and Alex Rasmussen and Kevin Slagle and Cenke Xu},
  title = {{Classification and description of bosonic symmetry protected topological phases with semiclassical nonlinear sigma models}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.91.134404},
}
Figure