In the study of electronic band structures, a naive expectation is that when two energy bands approach each other in momentum space, they will repel. In three dimensions, this band repulsion typically prevents bands from crossing unless their parameters are perfectly fine-tuned. As explained by Xi Dai in Dirac semimetal and topological phase transitions in A3Bi, three-dimensional Dirac points are generally unstable because Weyl points of opposite chirality tend to overlap, annihilate, and open up an insulating energy gap.
To prevent this mutual annihilation and stabilize exotic states of matter—such as Dirac semimetals, Weyl semimetals, and nodal-line metals—nature requires a mathematical guarantee that forbids bands from mixing. While early topological phases relied primarily on time-reversal symmetry, a powerful paradigm has emerged: using the geometric and spatial symmetries of the crystal lattice itself to protect these electronic degeneracies.
Symmorphic Protection: Mirrors and Rotations
How can a simple spatial reflection or rotation prevent two bands from repelling? The answer lies in quantum mechanical selection rules. If two crossing bands possess different eigenvalues under a specific symmetry operation (such as a mirror reflection), they belong to distinct symmetry representations. Because the crystal Hamiltonian must respect the lattice symmetry, the quantum mechanical matrix element coupling these two states is strictly zero. Hybridization is forbidden, and the crossing point remains perfectly stable.
This mechanism operates clearly in strongly correlated systems. Hongming Weng et al. demonstrated in Topological Crystalline Kondo Insulator in Mixed Valence Ytterbium Borides that mirror symmetries can protect energy-level inversions between localized and itinerant electron orbitals. This protection yields surface Dirac cones that remain robust even when traditional time-reversal protections are absent.
Instead of meeting at isolated points, bands can also intersect along continuous one-dimensional loops known as nodal lines. In Topological nodal-line fermions in spin-orbit metal PbTaSe2, Guang Bian et al. showed that crystalline mirror reflection symmetry prevents the hybridization of crossing bands, stabilizing these nodal rings against strong spin-orbit coupling. A similar mechanism is explored by Guang Bian et al. in Drumhead surface states and topological nodal-line fermions in TlTaSe2, where mirror symmetry forces conduction and valence bands to meet along a continuous loop rather than repelling.
Without Symmetry: With Mirror Symmetry:
\ / \ /
\ / \ / <- Protected Crossing
---- \/
/ \ /\
/ \ / \
(Bands repel, gap opens) (Different eigenvalues, gapless)
Beyond mirror planes, pure rotational symmetries can also shield degeneracies. Xian‐Lei Sheng et al. in Topological insulator to Dirac semimetal transition driven by sign change of spin-orbit coupling in thallium nitride showed that three-fold rotational symmetry can stabilize 3D Dirac points along high-symmetry paths. Crucially, this protection does not always require a centrosymmetric lattice. Heng Gao demonstrated in Noncentrosymmetric topological Dirac semimetals in three dimensions that fourfold ($C_{4v}$) and sixfold ($C_{6v}$) point groups can protect stable, fourfold degenerate Dirac points by substituting for the traditional inversion symmetry requirement.
Nonsymmorphic Symmetries: Enforcing Higher-Dimensional Degeneracies
The protection becomes even more robust when the lattice exhibits nonsymmorphic symmetries. Unlike standard symmorphic symmetries (like pure reflections or rotations), nonsymmorphic operations combine a point operation with a fractional translation of the unit cell. Examples include glide planes (reflection plus translation) and screw axes (rotation plus translation).
Because these operations intertwine spatial transformations with translations, they introduce a momentum-dependent phase factor. At the boundaries of the Brillouin zone, this phase factor forces electronic states to pair up, mathematically guaranteeing degeneracies that cannot be lifted by any local perturbation.
As Qifeng Liang et al. articulated in Node-surface and node-line fermions from nonsymmorphic lattice symmetries, screw axes and glide planes can force electronic bands to remain degenerate across an entire two-dimensional plane within the Brillouin zone, creating "node-surface" semimetals. Because these touchings are enforced by the space group topology of the crystal lattice, they are immune to accidental lifting.
A classic signature of nonsymmorphic protection is the emergence of "hourglass fermions," where bands weave together in a characteristic, un-gappable hourglass shape. In studying the material KHgSb, the authors of Robustness of topological states with respect to lattice instability in the nonsymmorphic topological insulator KHgSb showed that surface states protected by glide planes exhibit remarkable resilience. Even if a material undergoes a structural distortion that breaks global inversion symmetry, the topological crossing remains perfectly intact as long as the specific nonsymmorphic glide symmetry is preserved.
This geometric principle extends beyond electronic systems into classical wave physics. For instance, Jiho Noh et al. demonstrated in Observation of a Charge-2 Photonic Weyl Point in the Infrared that screw symmetries can pin complex topological degeneracies at specific high-symmetry points in a photonic crystal. This proves that the underlying geometry of the unit cell—rather than high material or dielectric contrast—is the primary driver of topological pinning.
The Achilles' Heel: Engineering and Breaking Protection
Because these topological states are strictly bound to the geometric arrangement of the crystal lattice, they possess a unique vulnerability: if you distort the lattice, you destroy the phase. This sensitivity turns crystalline protection into a powerful engineering tool, allowing researchers to toggle topological properties on and off.
If an external perturbation breaks the protecting symmetry, the forbidden hybridization suddenly becomes allowed, and an energy gap opens. This behavior was demonstrated by Dominik Kriegner et al. in Strain-induced nonsymmorphic symmetry breaking and removal of Dirac semimetallic nodal line in an orthoperovskite iridate. By applying epitaxial strain to a strontium iridate ($\text{SrIrO}_3$) film, the authors intentionally disrupted the nonsymmorphic glide planes. This structural modification lifted the topological protection, successfully removing the Dirac nodal line and opening an insulating gap.
[ Stable Semimetal ] --- Apply Strain / Distort Lattice ---> [ Gapped Insulator ]
Glide Symmetries Intact Symmetries Broken
Hybridization Forbidden Hybridization Allowed
Precisely predicting and controlling these transitions remains a central challenge in material design. As noted by Hyun‐Jung Kim et al. in Origins of the structural phase transitions in MoTe2 and WTe2, isolating the exact electronic mechanisms that drive structural phase transitions is crucial. Without this predictive power, engineering materials that can dynamically switch their topological states via mechanical strain or structural manipulation remains difficult. Understanding the interplay between spatial geometry and band topology provides the exact blueprint required to design robust, switchable quantum devices.