Topological Crystalline Kondo Insulator in Mixed Valence Ytterbium Borides

Hongming Weng, Jianzhou Zhao, Zhijun Wang, Zhong Fang, Xi DaiPhysical 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The electronic structures of two mixed valence insulators YbB$_6$ and YbB$_{12}$ are studied by using the local density approximation supplemented with the Gutzwiller method and dynamic mean field theory. YbB$_6$ is found to be a moderately correlated $Z_2$ topological insulator, similar to SmB$_6$ but having much larger bulk band gap. Notably, YbB$_{12}$ is revealed to be in a new novel quantum state, strongly correlated topological crystalline Kondo insulator, which is characterized by its nonzero mirror Chern number. The surface calculations find an odd (three) and an even (four) number of Dirac cones for YbB$_6$ and YbB$_{12}$, respectively.

Introduction: The Search for Strongly Correlated Topological Phases

Most known Topological Insulators (TIs)—materials that are insulating in their bulk but conduct electricity perfectly on their surfaces—are found in systems with "weakly correlated" electrons, such as $Bi_2Se_3$. In these materials, electrons behave largely independently. However, a major frontier in condensed matter physics is the discovery of topological phases in "strongly correlated" systems, where electron-electron interactions are dominant.

These interactions can lead to the Kondo effect, where itinerant electrons screen the magnetic moments of localized electrons, creating a narrow insulating gap at low temperatures. While SmB$_6$ was identified as the first "Topological Kondo Insulator" candidate, researchers at the Beijing National Laboratory for Condensed Matter Physics have now identified YbB$_6$ and YbB$_{12}$ as significant new players in this field.

Crystal structures and Brillouin zones of YbB$_6$ (a, c) and YbB$_{12}$ (b, d).

Computational Methodology

Modeling the complex electronic structures of YbB$_6$ and YbB$_{12}$ requires accounting for "heavy fermion" behavior, where interactions make electrons act as if they are significantly more massive. The researchers employed a three-tiered computational approach:

  1. LDA (Local Density Approximation): Establishes the baseline band structure.
  2. Gutzwiller Method: Supplements LDA to accurately model the ground state of correlated electron systems.
  3. DMFT (Dynamic Mean Field Theory): Calculates the temperature-dependent spectral functions to map electron states.

This methodology was validated against experimental crystal structure data and benchmarks from X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) and transport measurements.

Electronic Structure and Topological Protection

The topological nature of these materials stems from band inversion, where $4f$ and $5d$ electron orbitals swap energy levels. This inversion creates the "twist" in the electronic structure that necessitates protected surface states.

A critical distinction emerged between the two compounds:

  • YbB$_6$ is a moderately correlated $Z_2$ topological insulator. Its topology is protected by time-reversal symmetry.
  • YbB$_{12}$ is a Topological Crystalline Kondo Insulator (TCKI). Its topological state is protected by the mirror symmetry of its crystal lattice, characterized by a non-zero Mirror Chern Number (MCN = 2).

Furthermore, YbB$_{12}$ is much more strongly correlated than YbB$_6$. In YbB$_{12}$, electrons are nearly four times "heavier" than in a non-interacting system, whereas YbB$_6$ shows only moderate renormalization.

Comparative Analysis of Surface States

The most definitive evidence for these topological classifications comes from the surface electronic structure. On the surface, electrons form "Dirac cones" where they behave as massless particles.

Surface spectral functions showing Dirac cones for YbB$_6$ (a, b) and YbB$_{12}$ (c, d).

As shown in the calculations:

  • YbB$_6$ exhibits an odd number (three) of Dirac cones, a hallmark of a standard $Z_2$ TI. It features a bulk band gap of 31 meV, significantly larger than the ~10 meV gap in SmB$_6$, potentially making it more suitable for practical applications.
  • YbB$_{12}$ exhibits an even number (four) of Dirac cones, which is the signature of its crystalline topological nature.

Temperature sensitivity is also a key factor. DMFT calculations indicate that YbB$_{12}$'s topological features only emerge below its Kondo temperature (~200 K) as coherent heavy fermion bands form. In contrast, YbB$_6$ remains stable across a wider temperature range due to its weaker correlations.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work establishes YbB$_6$ as a robust TI with a large gap and identifies YbB$_{12}$ as a rare TCKI. The next step is experimental confirmation via Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy (ARPES) to directly observe the predicted Dirac cones. Future research may also explore the effects of breaking crystal symmetry—for instance, through physical strain—to manipulate these exotic topological states.

Summary updated

Abstract

The electronic structures of two mixed valence insulators YbB6 and YbB12 are studied by using the local density approximation supplemented with the Gutzwiller method and dynamic mean field theory. YbB6 is found to be a moderately correlated Z2 topological insulator, similar to SmB6 but having much larger bulk band gap. Notably, YbB12 is revealed to be in a new novel quantum state, strongly correlated topological crystalline Kondo insulator, which is characterized by its nonzero mirror Chern number. The surface calculations find an odd (three) and an even (four) number of Dirac cones for YbB6 and YbB12, respectively.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{weng2014topological,
  author = {Hongming Weng and Jianzhou Zhao and Zhijun Wang and Zhong Fang and Xi Dai},
  title = {{Topological Crystalline Kondo Insulator in Mixed Valence Ytterbium Borides}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.112.016403},
}
Figure