In the study of topological matter, the most striking phenomena often occur at the edges. While topological insulators are defined by their insulating bulk and conducting surfaces, a newer class of materials—topological semimetals—features a bulk that is metallic but possesses unique "nodes" where electronic bands touch.
The defining characteristic of these materials is the bulk-boundary correspondence: the specific way that 3D bulk band crossings manifest as exotic 2D electronic states on the material's surface. These surface states, such as Fermi arcs and drumhead states, are not just incidental features; they are the definitive experimental fingerprints of the material's underlying topology.
From Points to Arcs: Weyl and Dirac Semimetals
In a conventional metal, the surface electrons form a "Fermi surface" that appears as a closed loop in momentum space. However, in Weyl semimetals, the bulk contains pairs of points where bands cross, known as Weyl nodes. These nodes act as "monopoles" of Berry curvature—one node acts as a source and the other as a sink.
Because of this topological charge, the surface states cannot form closed loops. Instead, they form Fermi arcs: open-ended trajectories in momentum space that terminate exactly at the projections of the bulk Weyl nodes. Su-Yang Xu, Baoliang Lv, and colleagues provided the first definitive proof of this in Discovery of Weyl semimetal TaAs and NbAs, showing that these arcs are analytically tied to the 3D bulk structure.
This concept extends to Dirac semimetals, such as the alkali pnictides $A_3$Bi identified by Zhijun Wang and Hongming Weng in Dirac semimetal and topological phase transitions in A3Bi. While Dirac points are essentially two overlapping Weyl points of opposite charge, they still host discontinuous surface states that serve as unique signatures of their 3D protected nature.
From Lines to Membranes: Drumhead States
Topology in 3D is not limited to point-like crossings. In Topological Nodal-Line Semimetals (TNLS), the bands touch along one-dimensional closed loops or lines rather than isolated points.
When these 3D bulk loops are projected onto a 2D surface, they create a "shadow" or boundary. Inside this boundary, the material hosts nearly flat electronic bands known as drumhead surface states. As Guang Bian and Tay-Rong Chang demonstrated in Topological Nodal-Line Fermions in the Non-Centrosymmetric Superconductor Compound PbTaSe2, these states appear as flat, membrane-like structures stretched across the projection of the bulk nodal ring.
The intuition here is one of dimensionality:
- A 0D point in the bulk leads to a 1D arc on the surface.
- A 1D line in the bulk leads to a 2D "drumhead" on the surface.
Because these drumhead states are nearly flat, the electrons within them have very low velocity, leading to a high density of states. This makes TNLS materials, such as the $\text{CaP}_3$ family predicted by Qiunan Xu and Rui Yu, prime candidates for studying many-body effects like high-temperature superconductivity and magnetism.
Symmetry as a Topological Shield
Why don't these band crossings simply gap out and disappear? The answer lies in crystal symmetry. In many of these materials, the nodes are protected by specific symmetries like mirror reflection, time-reversal, or spatial inversion.
For example, in Topological node-line semimetal in compressed black phosphorus, Jianzhou Zhao and Hongming Weng showed that hydrostatic pressure can force band touchings that are then protected by the crystal's internal symmetry. Similarly, Guang Bian identified that in TlTaSe2, mirror reflection symmetry prevents the nodal lines from vanishing even when strong spin-orbit coupling is present.
Beyond Electrons: Topological Phonons
The logic of topological semimetals is so robust that it applies to bosonic systems as well. Recent research has shown that lattice vibrations (phonons) can also host nodal lines and points.
In Phononic Helical Nodal Lines with PT Protection in MoB2, Tiantian Zhang and H. Miao experimentally confirmed that bulk topological nodal lines in the phonon spectrum generate the same flat drumhead surface states seen in electronic systems. Even common materials like Silicon have been revealed by Nianlong Zou and Yong Xu to host a rich variety of topological phononic states, suggesting that these "exotic" surface signatures may be a ubiquitous feature of solid-state matter.