Geometric phases of mixed quantum states: A comparative study of interferometric and Uhlmann phases

Xu-Yang Hou, Xin Wang, Zheng Zhou, Hao Guo, Chih-Chun ChienarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Two geometric phases of mixed quantum states, known as the interferometric phase and Uhlmann phase, are generalizations of the Berry phase of pure states. After reviewing the two geometric phases and examining their parallel-transport conditions, we specify a class of cyclic processes that are compatible with both conditions and therefore accumulate both phases through their definitions, respectively. Those processes then facilitate a fair comparison between the two phases. We present exact solutions of two-level and three-level systems to contrast the two phases. While the interferometric phase exhibits finite-temperature transitions only in the three-level system but not the two-level system, the Uhlmann phase shows finite-temperature transitions in both cases. Thus, using the two geometric phases as finite-temperature topological indicators demonstrates the rich physics of topology of mixed states.

Introduction

In quantum mechanics, the Berry phase characterizes the global geometric properties of a pure state's evolution. However, real-world quantum systems are often in mixed states due to thermal fluctuations or environmental coupling. Generalizing the Berry phase to these mixed states has led to two distinct theoretical frameworks: the interferometric phase and the Uhlmann phase.

The interferometric phase is motivated by physical measurements in interferometry, treating a mixed state as a statistical ensemble of pure states. In contrast, the Uhlmann phase relies on the mathematical concept of "purification," where the system is embedded in a larger Hilbert space. Historically, it was believed that the interferometric phase lacked the sharp topological transitions observed in the Uhlmann phase at finite temperatures. This study investigates whether this difference is fundamental or a consequence of the simplicity of the models typically studied.

Methodology: A Unified Comparison

A major challenge in comparing these two phases is that they rely on different "parallel-transport" conditions—the rules governing how a state evolves to ensure the accumulated phase is purely geometric. The authors identify a specific class of cyclic processes that satisfy both conditions simultaneously. By using an auxiliary "ancilla" system to purify the mixed state, they create a "fair comparison" environment where both phases can be evaluated for the same physical path.

The study focuses on two exactly solvable models:

  1. A two-level system (qubit) subjected to a rotating magnetic field.
  2. A three-level system (qutrit) where one level remains decoupled from the external parameters.

Results and Discussion

Topological Transitions in Two-Level Systems

In two-level systems, the Uhlmann phase is known to exhibit quantized jumps (from $\pi$ to $0$) at specific critical temperatures $T_c$. These jumps are signaled by a divergence in a "geometrical generating function" $g$, which acts analogously to free energy in thermodynamics.

The geometrical generating function $g$ and the Uhlmann phase $\theta_U$ (inset) for a two-level system. Both winding numbers $\Omega=1$ and $\Omega=2$ exhibit sharp topological transitions where the phase jumps and $g$ diverges.

Conversely, the interferometric phase in the same two-level system remains smooth and continuous, showing no such topological transitions regardless of the temperature.

The Three-Level Breakthrough

The most significant finding of this research is that the "smoothness" of the interferometric phase is not universal. In a three-level system, the interferometric phase finally exhibits a quantized jump.

The geometrical generating function $g$ and the interferometric phase $\theta_I$ (inset) for a three-level system. While the $\Omega=1$ case remains trivial, the $\Omega=2$ case shows a sharp transition from $\pi$ to $0$ at $T/R \approx 2.89$, accompanied by a divergence in $g$.

This transition occurs specifically for even winding numbers ($\Omega$) and at a critical temperature defined by $T_c = \frac{2}{\ln 2} R$. The jump coincides with the point where the "visibility" of the interference pattern vanishes, indicating that the initial and final purified states have become orthogonal.

Conclusion

This comparative study reveals that both the Uhlmann and interferometric phases can serve as indicators of finite-temperature topological transitions, though they possess different sensitivities. While the Uhlmann phase is a more robust indicator across various system sizes, the interferometric phase reveals hidden topological richness in systems with three or more levels. These findings suggest that multi-level systems, such as spin-1 atomic nuclei or nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond, are ideal candidates for experimental observation of these "geometrical phase transitions."

Summary updated

Abstract

Two geometric phases of mixed quantum states, known as the interferometric phase and Uhlmann phase, are generalizations of the Berry phase of pure states. After reviewing the two geometric phases and examining their parallel-transport conditions, we specify a class of cyclic processes that are compatible with both conditions and therefore accumulate both phases through their definitions, respectively. Those processes then facilitate a fair comparison between the two phases. We present exact solutions of two-level and three-level systems to contrast the two phases. While the interferometric phase exhibits finite-temperature transitions only in the three-level system but not the two-level system, the Uhlmann phase shows finite-temperature transitions in both cases. Thus, using the two geometric phases as finite-temperature topological indicators demonstrates the rich physics of topology of mixed states.
BibTeX
@misc{hou2023geometric,
  author = {Xu-Yang Hou and Xin Wang and Zheng Zhou and Hao Guo and Chih-Chun Chien},
  title = {{Geometric phases of mixed quantum states: A comparative study of interferometric and Uhlmann phases}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2301.01210},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2301.01210},
}
Figure