Abstract: The specially designed ion source of mass spectrometer has been used to measure simultaneously both ions formed by electron impact and by self surface ionization, and from these measurements the work functions and the heats of sublimation of atoms and positive ions of rhenium, tantalum and tungsten have been determined. These values obtained are 5.62±0.08, 7.94±0.20 and 10.19±0.28eV for rhenium, 5.02±0.11, 8.04±0.12 and 10.90±0.23eV for tantalum, and 5.04±0.29, 9.28±0.27 and 12.22±0.56eV for tungsten, respectively.
Introduction
Understanding the interaction between atoms, ions, and metal surfaces is fundamental to vacuum electronics and high-temperature materials science. Key parameters in these interactions include the work function ($\phi$)—the energy required to remove an electron from a surface—and the heat of sublimation ($l_0^T$)—the energy required to transition a solid metal into a gaseous state.
Historically, these properties were measured using external gases impinging on a surface. However, polycrystalline surfaces are often "patchy" and non-uniform. This study, published in 1970 by researchers at Kyoto University, addresses this by operating at temperatures exceeding 2500 K. At such extremes, rapid surface atom migration creates an effectively homogeneous surface, allowing for "in-situ" measurements using the metal's own sublimating particles.
Experimental Methodology
The researchers employed a 60-degree sector magnetic deflection mass spectrometer featuring a unique, custom-built ion source designed to distinguish between two distinct ion populations.
Dual Ion Generation
As the metal filament (Rhenium, Tantalum, or Tungsten) is heated, it emits positive ions through Self Surface Ionization (SI). Concurrently, it evaporates neutral atoms, which are subsequently ionized by an electron beam via Electron Impact (EI).
The Potential Difference Method
To differentiate these two ion types, which share the same mass-to-charge ratio, a small potential difference ($\Delta V \approx 3–7$ V) was applied between the filament and the ionization chamber. This bias imparts slightly higher kinetic energy to the SI ions compared to the EI ions.
In the resulting mass spectrum, this energy difference causes the SI and EI signals to appear as distinct, adjacent peaks. By analyzing the ratio of these peak intensities across various temperatures, the researchers could utilize the Saha-Langmuir equation to calculate the work function directly.
Results and Discussion
The study provided precise thermodynamic values for three refractory metals in a high-vacuum environment ($< 7 \times 10^{-7}$ torr) at temperatures between 2550 K and 3010 K.
| Metal | Work Function ($\phi$) | Sublimation Heat (Atom, $l_0^T$) | Sublimation Heat (Ion, $l_+^T$) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rhenium | $5.62 \pm 0.08$ eV | $7.94 \pm 0.20$ eV | $10.19 \pm 0.28$ eV |
| Tantalum | $5.02 \pm 0.11$ eV | $8.04 \pm 0.12$ eV | $10.90 \pm 0.23$ eV |
| Tungsten | $5.04 \pm 0.29$ eV | $9.28 \pm 0.27$ eV | $12.22 \pm 0.56$ eV |
Thermodynamic Consistency
A significant insight from this work is the use of an energy cycle to link the heat of sublimation for a positive ion ($l_+^T$) to the heat of sublimation of the atom, the work function, and the ionization potential ($I$). The simultaneous measurement of ions ($n_+$) and atoms ($n_M$) at the same location and time minimizes calibration errors typical of separate measurement techniques.
Furthermore, the results support the hypothesis that surface "patchiness" in polycrystalline metals vanishes near the melting point, leading to stable, reproducible work function values.
Limitations and Conclusion
The authors noted a persistent discrepancy: work functions derived from surface ionization are generally ~0.5 eV higher than those from thermionic emission. While they argue their values are more appropriate for sublimation studies, the underlying physical cause remains a subject for further investigation. Additionally, the model assumes constant statistical weights for ionic and atomic states across the temperature range.
In conclusion, the simultaneous EI/SI mass spectrometric method offers a robust framework for studying the high-temperature properties of refractory materials, providing high-precision data essential for advanced materials engineering.
Summary updated