Study on Energy Distribution of Thermal Ion by a Retarding Field Modulation Method

Mitsuru Asano, Toshio Harada, Kenji KuboShitsuryou 1978 · DOI

Abstract

A specially designed retarding field energy analyzer has been set in the front of a quadrupole mass filter for studying the energy distribution of thermal ion emitted from a hot metal surface. The distribution curve and its derivative are obtained by the technique of electrical differentiation of the retarding voltage curve in which a small sinusoidal modulation voltage is applied to the two retarding grids in a method similar to Auger electron spectroscopy with a four-grid low energy electron diffraction optics. The effects of frequency and amplitude of the modulation voltage on fundamental and second harmonic components being proportional to the energy distribution function and its derivative have been investigated. The results have been applied to study the energy distributions of $Na^+$, $K^+$ and $Rb^+$ thermal ions emitted from a tungsten ribbon.

Introduction

The study of thermal ions emitted from heated metal surfaces provides critical insights into fundamental surface properties, particularly the work function—the minimum energy required to remove an electron from a solid. Traditionally, these studies utilize a Retarding Field Analyzer (RFA), which measures the total ion current as a function of a variable retarding voltage ($V_R$). However, determining the actual energy distribution requires differentiating this current curve, a process that was historically prone to noise and graphical errors when performed manually.

This paper presents a hardware-based solution developed at Kyoto University. By integrating an RFA with a Quadrupole Mass Filter (QMF) and employing a signal modulation technique, the researchers achieved real-time, high-resolution observation of ion energy distributions and their derivatives directly from the instrument.

Experimental Methodology

The experimental apparatus consists of a thermal ion source (a tungsten ribbon heated between 940K and 1085K) and a specialized RFA. The RFA utilizes a six-grid system where grids $G_3$ and $G_4$ serve as the energy selection gates. To ensure species-specific measurements, a QMF is positioned downstream of the analyzer to isolate ions such as $Na^+$, $K^+$, and $Rb^+$.

Schematic of the experimental setup including the Retarding Field Analyzer (RFA) and Quadrupole Mass Filter (QMF).

The core innovation is the "modulation method." A small sinusoidal AC voltage ($V_{p-p}$) is superimposed onto the DC retarding voltage. Using a lock-in amplifier, the system detects signals at the fundamental frequency to directly yield the energy distribution function $N(E)$. Detecting at the second harmonic frequency provides the derivative $dN(E)/dE$. This approach, adapted from Auger electron spectroscopy, significantly enhances the signal-to-noise ratio compared to traditional differentiation methods.

Results and Discussion

The modulation technique allows for the simultaneous acquisition of the retarding current and its derivatives. As shown in the following figure, the method effectively transforms the raw current signal into clear distribution peaks and derivative curves, facilitating precise analysis of the ion energy landscape.

Comparison of (a) retarding current $I$, (b) $\ln I$, (c) energy distribution $-N(E)$, and (d) its derivative $-dN(E)/dE$ as functions of retarding voltage $V_R$.

Key findings from the study include:

  • Maxwellian Agreement: The measured energy distributions for $K^+$ ions at 1000K showed nearly perfect agreement with theoretical Maxwell-Boltzmann distributions. At 940K, the measured Full Width at Half Maximum (FWHM) was 0.21V, remarkably close to the theoretical value of 0.206V.
  • Modulation Optimization: The researchers identified that the modulation amplitude must be carefully controlled. Resolution remains high as long as the amplitude is less than half of the energy distribution's half-width ($\Delta E_{1/2}$).
  • Work Function Mapping: The peak of the energy distribution reflects the contact potential difference between the source and analyzer. The team observed a work function shift of approximately 0.16V as the tungsten ribbon was heated from 940K to 1085K, likely due to the evaporation of surface impurities.

Conclusion and Limitations

While the method provides high precision, it is constrained by the RFA's internal capacitance, which limits the optimal modulation frequency to approximately 600 Hz. Additionally, the physical resolution is bounded by the modulation amplitude; a balance must be struck between signal strength and peak broadening. Despite these constraints, the RFA-QMF modulation method proves to be a powerful tool for real-time surface analysis and the study of thermal ion kinetics.

Summary updated

Abstract

A specially designed retarding field energy analyzer has been set in the front of a quadrupole mass filter for studying the energy distribution of thermal ion emitted from a hot metal surface. The distribution curve and its derivative are obtained by the technique of electrical differentiation of the retarding voltage curve in which a small sinusoidal modulation voltage is applied to the two retarding grids in a method similar to Auger electron spectroscopy with a four-grid low energy electron diffraction optics. The effects of frequency and amplitude of the modulation voltage on fundamental and second harmonic components being proportional to the energy distribution function and its derivative have been investigated. The results have been applied to study the energy distributions of Na+, K+ and Rb+ thermal ions emitted from a tungsten ribbon.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{asano1978study,
  author = {Mitsuru Asano and Toshio Harada and Kenji Kubo},
  title = {{Study on Energy Distribution of Thermal Ion by a Retarding Field Modulation Method}},
  booktitle = {Shitsuryou},
  year = {1978},
  doi = {10.5702/massspec1953.26.251},
}
Figure