Abstract: A pulse counting method has been used to determine gains of an electron multiplier for various ions. A 16-stage box and grid type electron multiplier with copper-beryllium dynodes has been employed in equipment to a single focusing mass spectrometer. The condition, where the gain determined by the pulse counting method becomes almost identical to that by a Faraday cup method for each of various ions, has been discussed.
Introduction
In mass spectrometry, accurately measuring the amplification (gain) of an electron multiplier is essential for quantifying weak ion signals, such as those encountered in Knudsen effusion cell experiments. While strong signals can be measured directly using a Faraday cup, weak signals require pulse counting. Historically, a discrepancy has been noted between gain values determined by these two methods. This paper investigates the conditions under which the pulse counting method ($G_c$) yields results identical to the gold-standard Faraday cup method ($G_F$).
Experimental Methodology
The researchers employed a 16-stage copper-beryllium (Cu-Be) box-and-grid type electron multiplier integrated with a single-focusing mass spectrometer. The experimental setup allowed for the simultaneous evaluation of gain through two distinct techniques:
- Faraday Cup Method ($G_F$): This direct measurement compares the output current at the anode to the raw ion current measured at the initial dynodes.
- Pulse Counting Method ($G_c$): This indirect measurement calculates gain by dividing the anode current ($I_a$) by the product of the ion count rate ($N$) and the elementary charge ($e$).
The team systematically varied the ion accelerating voltage ($V_I$) and the multiplier applied voltage ($V_{EM}$) to identify the parameters that minimize the discrepancy between $G_c$ and $G_F$.
Optimization of Operating Conditions
A critical finding of this study is the sensitivity of the $G_c/G_F$ ratio to the operating voltages. As shown in the experimental data, the gain increases almost linearly on a logarithmic scale with the applied multiplier voltage. More importantly, the ratio $G_c/G_F$ converges toward unity as the multiplier voltage is optimized.
The researchers discovered a "sweet spot" at a multiplier voltage of 2.0 kV and an ion accelerating voltage of 4.8 kV. Under these specific conditions, the pulse counting method achieved near-perfect agreement with the Faraday cup method across 16 different ion species, including light atomic ions ($H^+$, $Li^+$), heavy atomic ions ($Ba^+$, $Ag^+$), and various molecular ions ($CO_2^+$, $H_2O^+$).
Insights into Gain Characteristics
The study revealed several key characteristics of the Cu-Be multiplier:
- Mass Dependency: Gain generally decreases as the atomic mass of the incident ion increases.
- Chemical Effects: Molecular ions often exhibit higher gains than atomic ions of similar mass, likely due to fragmentation upon impact which generates additional secondary electrons.
- Efficiency: Although the hardware features 16 physical stages, the "effective" number of stages was calculated to be between 7.6 and 7.9, reflecting inherent inefficiencies in secondary electron emission.
Conclusion
By optimizing the ion accelerating and multiplier voltages, the pulse counting method can be calibrated to provide gain measurements as accurate as the Faraday cup method. This validation bridges previous discrepancies in the literature and establishes pulse counting as a reliable standard for quantitative mass spectrometry of weak ion beams. The researchers suggest that this experimental calibration is preferable to relying on simple theoretical curves, which often fail to account for complex chemical and mass-dependent effects.
Summary updated