In the standard account of the Big Bang, energy transforms into matter and antimatter in equal parts. Because these pairs annihilate upon contact, a perfectly symmetric early universe should have resulted in a void of pure radiation. The fact that we inhabit a universe made almost entirely of matter implies a fundamental gap in the Standard Model of particle physics.
To explain this "Baryon Asymmetry of the Universe" (BAU), researchers are investigating mechanisms that satisfy the three Sakharov conditions: baryon number violation, $C$ and $CP$ symmetry violation, and a departure from thermal equilibrium.
The Need for a Violent Phase Transition
A leading candidate for generating this asymmetry is Electroweak Baryogenesis (EWBG). This process occurs during the era when the Higgs field first turned on, giving particles mass. For this to create a lasting excess of matter, the transition must be "strongly first-order"—meaning it must occur through the violent formation and expansion of bubbles, rather than a smooth, gradual change.
As Jonathan Kozaczuk and Michael J. Ramsey-Musolf have noted, the Standard Model’s Higgs boson cannot provide this violent transition; it results in a smooth "crossover" that washes out any generated asymmetry. This suggests the existence of "New Physics," such as additional scalar fields or supersymmetric partners. Nikita Blinov and David E. Morrissey have explored two-step transitions where an exotic field triggers the initial asymmetry before handing off the vacuum to the Higgs.
Hunting for the Source of Asymmetry
Even with a violent phase transition, nature must treat matter and antimatter differently—a phenomenon called Charge-Parity (CP) violation. While $CP$ violation has been observed in mesons by the BABAR Collaboration and the Belle Collaboration, the amount discovered so far is far too small to account for the universe's matter density.
Current research is expanding the search for $CP$ violation into three main frontiers:
- Baryons: Most known $CP$ violation occurs in mesons (quark-antiquark pairs). However, explaining the BAU requires understanding how it affects baryons (three-quark particles like protons). Recent work by the BESIII Collaboration and L. K. Li has pushed the precision of baryon symmetry tests to new limits, searching for the subtle decay differences that favor matter.
- Neutrinos: The DUNE experiment is designed to measure $CP$ violation in neutrino oscillations. If neutrinos and antineutrinos oscillate differently, it could point to "Leptogenesis," where an initial lepton asymmetry is converted into the baryon asymmetry we see today.
- Forbidden Decays: Experiments like the MAJORANA DEMONSTRATOR search for neutrinoless double-beta decay. Observing this would prove that neutrinos are their own antiparticles and that "lepton number" is not conserved—a crucial requirement for many baryogenesis models.
Baryogenesis Beyond the Thermal Era
While EWBG focuses on the cooling of the hot early universe, other models suggest the asymmetry was baked in even earlier. Haipeng An and Qi Chen have proposed that the kinetic energy of the inflaton field during cosmic inflation could act as a chemical potential, biasing the production of matter over antimatter before the thermal era even began.
Alternatively, "non-thermal" models suggest the asymmetry arose from the decay of heavy, unstable particles. B. S. Acharya and Gordon Kane have shown that the decay of heavy fields (moduli) can simultaneously produce dark matter and the observed baryon asymmetry. This "assimilation" approach, also explored by Jesse Thaler, suggests that the density of dark matter and regular matter are linked by a shared origin story in the early universe.