<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>C</mml:mi><mml:mi>P</mml:mi></mml:math>-violating phases in active-sterile solar neutrino oscillations

H. W. Long, Yufeng Li, C. GiuntiPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The effects of $CP$-violating phases in active-sterile solar neutrino oscillations are discussed in a general scheme of $3+N_s$ mixing, without any constraint on the mixing between the three active and the $N_s$ sterile neutrinos, assuming only a realistic hierarchy of neutrino mass-squared differences. A generalized Parke formula describing the neutrino oscillation probabilities inside the Sun is calculated. The validity of the analytical calculation and the probability variation due to the unknown $CP$-violating phases are illustrated with a numerical calculation of the evolution equation in the case of $3+1$ neutrino mixing.

Introduction

In the Standard Model of particle physics, neutrinos are categorized into three "active" flavors: electron ($e$), muon ($\mu$), and tau ($\tau$). However, persistent experimental anomalies from sources like LSND and MiniBooNE have suggested the existence of "sterile" neutrinos—particles that do not participate in weak interactions but can mix with active neutrinos through oscillations.

When neutrinos propagate through the dense matter of the Sun, they experience the Mikheyev-Smirnov-Wolfenstein (MSW) effect, where varying matter density alters their effective mass and enhances flavor transitions. Modeling these transitions in a $3+N_s$ framework (3 active plus $N_s$ sterile neutrinos) is mathematically complex. Historically, many analytical simplifications have ignored or incorrectly handled $CP$-violating phases—complex parameters in the mixing matrix that represent fundamental differences in how matter and antimatter behave. This paper provides a rigorous analytical framework to account for these phases without restrictive assumptions on active-sterile mixing strength.

Methodology

The Hierarchy Approximation

The researchers utilized the fact that the mass-squared differences associated with sterile neutrinos ($\Delta m^2_{SBL}$) are significantly larger than the solar mass-squared difference ($\Delta m^2_{SOL}$). This hierarchy allows for the "decoupling" of high-energy sterile states. By doing so, the complex $N$-dimensional evolution equation can be reduced to an effective $2 \times 2$ system focused on the 1-2 sector, simplifying the calculation while maintaining physical accuracy.

Generalized Parke Formula

A central contribution of this work is the derivation of a generalized Parke formula. This analytical expression calculates the probability of neutrino flavor transitions based on the production point within the solar core, the local matter density, and the influence of $CP$-violating phases. Unlike previous iterations, this formula correctly incorporates the phases that arise when the matter density ($Y_e$) varies along the neutrino's trajectory.

Numerical Validation

To validate the analytical derivation, the authors performed a $3+1$ (three active plus one sterile neutrino) simulation. They employed a 4th-order Runge-Kutta integration method and utilized the BSB2005(OP) Standard Solar Model to provide a realistic density profile of the Sun. To ensure the conservation of probability (unitarity), a density matrix formalism was used throughout the numerical calculations.

Key Insights and Results

The Role of CP Phases

A significant finding is that $CP$ phases cannot be "phased away" or ignored in environments with varying matter density. The varying density makes these phases physically observable in the oscillation probability. The researchers identified a distinct "kink" in the probability variation at approximately 2 MeV. This energy level corresponds to the point where the effective mixing angle in matter changes sign, leading to a sudden shift in how $CP$ phases influence the oscillation outcome.

Selective Sensitivity: $P_{ee}$ vs. $P_{es}$

The study reveals a stark difference in how $CP$ phases affect different transition probabilities:

  • Electron Neutrino Survival ($P_{ee}$): The impact of unknown $CP$ phases on the survival of electron neutrinos is minimal, typically less than 1.2%. This explains why current solar neutrino experiments, which primarily measure $P_{ee}$, have not been significantly hindered by these unknown variables.
  • Sterile Transition ($P_{es}$): Conversely, the transition probability into sterile states ($P_{es}$) is highly sensitive to $CP$ violation. Depending on the values of the unknown phases, the probability of a neutrino becoming sterile can vary by as much as 100%, effectively doubling or halving the expected flux of sterile neutrinos.

Accuracy

The analytical generalized Parke formula demonstrated remarkable agreement with the heavy numerical simulations, achieving an accuracy better than $10^{-5}$. This establishes the formula as a robust and efficient tool for future theoretical and experimental neutrino research.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the derived formula is general for $3+N_s$ scenarios, the numerical illustrations in this paper focused on the $3+1$ case. Further exploration into $3+2$ or $3+3$ models would introduce additional $CP$ phases and greater complexity. Furthermore, the derivation relies on the assumption that sterile neutrinos are significantly heavier than active ones; if "light" sterile neutrinos exist at the solar mass scale, the formula would require further refinement.

Currently, there is an experimental gap in high-precision measurements of the electron-to-sterile transition ($P_{es}$). The authors anticipate that this work will be most impactful for future precision solar neutrino experiments capable of detecting these elusive sterile transitions, potentially unlocking new physics beyond the Standard Model.

Summary updated

Abstract

The effects of $CP$-violating phases in active-sterile solar neutrino oscillations are discussed in a general scheme of $3+{N}_{s}$ mixing, without any constraint on the mixing between the three active and the ${N}_{s}$ sterile neutrinos, assuming only a realistic hierarchy of neutrino mass-squared differences. A generalized Parke formula describing the neutrino oscillation probabilities inside the Sun is calculated. The validity of the analytical calculation and the probability variation due to the unknown $CP$-violating phases are illustrated with a numerical calculation of the evolution equation in the case of $3+1$ neutrino mixing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{long2013mml,
  author = {H. W. Long and Yufeng Li and C. Giunti},
  title = {{<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>C</mml:mi><mml:mi>P</mml:mi></mml:math>-violating phases in active-sterile solar neutrino oscillations}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.87.113004},
}
Figure