Cosmological phase transitions and their properties in the NMSSM

Jonathan Kozaczuk, Stefano Profumo, Laurel Stephenson Haskins, Carroll L. WainwrightJournal of High Energy Physics 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates cosmological phase transitions within the Next-to-Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (NMSSM), a popular extension of the Standard Model that can explain dark matter and the Higgs mass. The authors find that the NMSSM offers a rich phenomenology for these transitions, potentially leading to successful electroweak baryogenesis, a key mechanism for generating the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry in the universe.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The origin of the matter-antimatter asymmetry in the universe is a fundamental puzzle in cosmology and particle physics. Electroweak baryogenesis (EWB) is a leading theoretical mechanism to explain this asymmetry, but it requires specific conditions, including a strongly first-order electroweak phase transition (EWPT) and sources of CP violation. While the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) was a prime candidate for EWB, recent experimental results (like the Higgs mass and lack of new SUSY particles at the LHC) have put significant pressure on its viability. This paper explores the NMSSM as an alternative framework, investigating whether it can accommodate the necessary conditions for EWB while remaining consistent with current experimental data.

Methods

The authors employ an effective field theory (EFT) approach to calculate the finite-temperature effective potential of the NMSSM. This involves integrating out heavy "stop" squarks and then using a numerical code called CosmoTransitions to study the phase transition structure. They focus on regions of parameter space that are phenomenologically viable, meaning they are consistent with LHC searches, dark matter observations, and the measured Higgs mass. Key quantities related to the bubble wall profile (width, Δβ) and wall velocity are calculated microphysically, taking into account interactions with the plasma.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical calculations and parameter scans within a specific model (NMSSM), rather than analyzing experimental datasets directly.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NMSSM as a promising EWB candidate: The NMSSM, with its additional singlet Higgs, offers more flexibility than the MSSM for achieving a strongly first-order EWPT, making it a more attractive framework for EWB.
  • Rich phase transition phenomenology: The NMSSM exhibits a variety of phase transition patterns, including one-step and two-step transitions, and transitions involving different field directions (SU(2) and singlet).
  • Bubble wall properties are crucial: The parameters describing the bubble wall (width, Δβ, velocity) are found to vary significantly and are critical for successful EWB. These parameters are often more favorable in the NMSSM than in the MSSM.
  • Sub-sonic wall velocities are key for EWB: The paper emphasizes that for successful EWB, bubble walls must move at sub-sonic speeds to allow sphaleron processes to generate the baryon asymmetry. Runaway (ultra-relativistic) walls are detrimental.
  • Dark matter and Higgs mass are naturally accommodated: The chosen parameter space in the NMSSM naturally accommodates a viable neutralino dark matter candidate and the observed Higgs mass, while remaining consistent with LHC constraints.

Key Results

  • The NMSSM can exhibit one- or two-step first-order phase transitions, with parameters that can lead to successful electroweak baryogenesis.
  • Bubble wall parameters like width and Δβ vary significantly across the parameter space, with values often more promising for EWB than in the MSSM.
  • For non-runaway solutions, the estimated bubble wall velocities are typically sub-sonic (O(0.01-0.1)), consistent with the requirements for successful EWB.
  • The study identified specific benchmark points that satisfy experimental constraints and exhibit interesting phase transition behaviors.
  • No detectable gravitational wave emission was found for the considered points, suggesting that current or near-future gravitational wave detectors might not be sensitive to these specific scenarios.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximations in wall velocity calculation: The calculation of wall velocity relies on several simplifying assumptions, particularly in the non-relativistic limit and neglecting the spatial variation of perturbations. The authors acknowledge that a full treatment of relativistic hydrodynamics is needed for more precise results.
  • CP violation sources: While the paper focuses on the phase transition dynamics, a detailed study of the CP-violating sources required for EWB in the NMSSM is deferred to future work.
  • Gravitational wave signals: The predicted gravitational wave signals for the considered scenarios are too faint to be observed by current or planned detectors like BBO or eLISA.
  • Further exploration of parameter space: The study focuses on a specific region of the NMSSM parameter space. Exploring other regions could reveal different and potentially more observable phenomena.
  • More detailed study of runaway walls: While runaway walls are identified as detrimental to EWB, their potential for generating observable gravitational waves warrants further investigation, even if the current predictions are faint.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study cosmological phase transitions in the Next-to-Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (NMSSM) in light of the Higgs discovery. We use an effective field theory approach to calculate the finite temperature effective potential, focusing on regions with significant tree-level contributions to the Higgs mass, a viable neutralino dark matter candidate, 1-2 TeV stops, and with the remaining particle spectrum compatible with current LHC searches and results. The phase transition structure in viable regions of parameter space exhibits a rich phenomenology, potentially giving rise to one- or two-step first-order phase transitions in the singlet and/or SU(2) directions. We compute several parameters pertaining to the bubble wall profile, including the bubble wall width and Δβ (the variation of the ratio in Higgs vacuum expectation values across the wall). These quantities can vary significantly across small regions of parameter space and can be promising for successful electroweak baryogenesis. We estimate the wall velocity microphysically, taking into account the various sources of friction acting on the expanding bubble wall. Ultra-relativistic solutions to the bubble wall equations of motion typically exist when the electroweak phase transition features substantial supercooling. For somewhat weaker transitions, the bubble wall instead tends to be sub-luminal and, in fact, likely sub-sonic, suggesting that successful electroweak baryogenesis may indeed occur in regions of the NMSSM compatible with the Higgs discovery.
BibTeX
@article{kozaczuk2015cosmological,
  author = {Jonathan Kozaczuk and Stefano Profumo and Laurel Stephenson Haskins and Carroll L. Wainwright},
  title = {{Cosmological phase transitions and their properties in the NMSSM}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep01(2015)144},
}
Figure