First Search for<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi mathvariant="italic">CP</mml:mi></mml:math>Violation in Tau Lepton Decay

S. Anderson, Y. Kubota, S. J. Lee, J. J. O’Neill, R. Poling, T. Riehle, A. Smith, M. S. Alam, S. B. Athar, Z. Ling, A. H. Mahmood, S. Timm, F. Wappler, A. Anastassov, J. E. Duboscq, D. Fujino, K. K. Gan, T. Hart, K. Honscheid, H. Kagan, R. Kass, H. Schwarthoff, M. B. Spencer, M. Sung, A. Undrus, A. Wolf, M. M. Zoeller, S. J. Richichi, H. Severini, P. Skubic, M. Bishai, J. Fast, J. W. Hinson, N. Menson, D. H. Miller, E. I. Shibata, I. P. J. Shipsey, M. Yurko, S. Glenn, Y.-j. Kwon, A. L. Lyon, S. Roberts, E. H. Thorndike, C. Jessop, K. Lingel, H. Marsiske, M. Perl, V. Savinov, D. Ugolini, Xingyu Zhou, T. E. Coan, V. Fadeyev, I. Korolkov, Y. Maravin, I. Narsky, V. Shelkov, J. Staeck, R. Stroynowski, I. Volobouev, J. Ye, M. Artuso, F. Azfar, А. Efimov, M. Goldberg, D. He, S. Köpp, G. C. Moneti, R. Mountain, S. Schuh, T. Skwarnicki, S. Stone, G. H. A. Viehhauser, J. C. Wang, X. Xing, J. Bartelt, S. E. Csorna, V. Jain, K. W. McLean, S. Márka, R. Godang, K. Kinoshita, I. C. Lai, P. Pomianowski, S. Schrenk, G. Bonvicini, D. Cinabro, R. Greene, L. P. Perera, Gao-Liang Zhou, M. Chadha, S. Chan, G. Eigen, J. S. Miller, M. Śchmidtler, J. Urheim, A. J. Weinstein, F. Würthwein, Daniel W. Bliss, D. E. JaffePhysical 1998 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first experimental search for CP violation in tau lepton decays, specifically in the $\tau^- \rightarrow K^0 \pi^- \nu$ decay channel. While the Standard Model of particle physics does not predict CP violation in lepton decays, extensions like the multi-Higgs doublet model do. The researchers found no evidence for CP violation, setting limits on the parameters of these extended models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model (SM) of particle physics successfully describes fundamental particles and their interactions, but it has limitations. One such limitation is its inability to explain the observed asymmetry between matter and antimatter in the universe. While CP violation (a violation of charge-parity symmetry) is a known phenomenon in the quark sector (responsible for the matter-antimatter asymmetry), the SM predicts it to be negligible in lepton decays. However, some extensions to the SM, such as those involving multiple Higgs doublets, predict observable CP violation in lepton decays. This paper addresses the question of whether CP violation, beyond the SM, can be detected in tau lepton decays, which are a rich source of information about new physics. Specifically, it investigates the $\tau^- \rightarrow K^0 \pi^- \nu$ decay mode, which is sensitive to interference between SM (W boson exchange) and potential new physics (e.g., Higgs boson exchange) amplitudes.

Methods

The researchers searched for CP violation by looking for a difference in the decay angular distributions between tau leptons ($\tau^-$) and anti-tau leptons ($\tau^+$). CP violation would manifest as a characteristic asymmetry in these distributions. They defined an observable asymmetry, $A_{observed}(\cos\beta\cos\psi)$, which is proportional to the product of the magnitudes of the scalar and vector form factors, the coupling strength $g$, the sine of the strong phase difference ($\sin\delta_{strong}$), and the sine of the CP-violating phase ($\sin\theta_{CP}$), multiplied by $\cos\beta\cos\psi$. The angles $\beta$ and $\psi$ are physical decay angles measured in the hadronic rest frame.

The analysis utilized data collected by the CLEO II detector at the Cornell Electron Storage Ring (CESR) from $e^+e^-$ collisions at a center-of-mass energy of 10.6 GeV. Events were selected with a specific topology: a $\tau^-$ decaying into a $K^0$ and a $\pi^-$, with the $K^0$ subsequently decaying into a $\pi^+\pi^-$. This decay mode was chosen because it is expected to be sensitive to CP-violating effects from potential scalar interactions. A detailed selection procedure was applied to isolate these events, including requirements on charged track properties, missing momentum, and visible energy. The invariant mass distribution of the $K^0$ decay products ($\pi^+\pi^-$) was used to identify the signal region, with sideband regions used to estimate backgrounds and detector effects.

Datasets

The analysis used a dataset of $e^+e^-$ collisions collected by the CLEO II detector at CESR. The total integrated luminosity of the data sample was 4.8 fb$^{-1}$, corresponding to approximately $4.4 \times 10^6$ $\tau^+\tau^-$ events.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • First direct search for CP violation in tau decays: This paper marks a significant step by being the first to directly search for CP violation in tau lepton decays, a phenomenon not predicted by the minimal Standard Model.
  • Sensitivity to New Physics: The chosen decay mode ($\tau^- \rightarrow K^0 \pi^- \nu$) is particularly sensitive to CP violation arising from interference between Standard Model W-boson exchange and potential new physics contributions, such as those from scalar (Higgs-like) exchanges in extended models.
  • Empirical estimation of detector effects: The use of sideband regions in the invariant mass distribution of the $K^0$ decay products allowed the researchers to empirically estimate and subtract potential asymmetries arising from charge-dependent detector inefficiencies.
  • No evidence for CP violation found: Despite the sensitivity of the chosen channel, the experiment found no statistically significant evidence for CP violation in tau lepton decays.

Key Results

The observed asymmetries in both the signal and sideband regions were found to be small and statistically insignificant. For the signal region, the observed asymmetry was $A_{observed}(\cos\beta\cos\psi < 0) = 0.058 \pm 0.023$ and $A_{observed}(\cos\beta\cos\psi > 0) = 0.024 \pm 0.021$. After subtracting the estimated detector effects using the sideband sample, the resulting subtracted asymmetry was consistent with zero, with uncertainties of $\pm 0.038$ and $\pm 0.039$. This result is consistent with no CP violation and allows for the setting of limits on the parameters of extended models. Specifically, the paper sets a constraint of $g\sin\theta_{CP} < 1.7$ at the 90% confidence level, assuming $F_s=1$ (where $F_s$ is the scalar form factor).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical Significance: The primary limitation acknowledged is the limited statistical significance of the observed asymmetries, which prevents a definitive conclusion about the presence or absence of CP violation.
  • Model Dependence: The interpretation of the results and the setting of limits on parameters like $g\sin\theta_{CP}$ are dependent on assumptions about the underlying physics, such as the dominance of scalar exchange and the mass dependence of couplings.
  • Future Prospects: The authors highlight that future experiments at B-factories will offer substantial improvements in sensitivity due to increased statistical precision and enhanced detector capabilities. Specifically, improved $K^0$ detection, better $\pi/\text{K}$ separation, and more precise tracking will significantly reduce backgrounds and improve the ability to search for CP violation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We have performed the first search for $\mathrm{CP}$ violation in tau lepton decay. $\mathrm{CP}$ violation in lepton decay does not occur in the minimal standard model but can occur in extensions such as the multi-Higgs doublet model. It appears as a characteristic difference between the ${\ensuremath{\tau}}^{\ensuremath{-}}$ and ${\ensuremath{\tau}}^{+}$ decay angular distributions for the semileptonic decay modes such as ${\ensuremath{\tau}}^{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{K}^{0}{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremath{\nu}$. We define an observable asymmetry to exploit this and find no evidence for any $\mathrm{CP}$ violation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{anderson1998first,
  author = {S. Anderson and Y. Kubota and S. J. Lee and J. J. O’Neill and R. Poling and T. Riehle and A. Smith and M. S. Alam and S. B. Athar and Z. Ling and A. H. Mahmood and S. Timm and F. Wappler and A. Anastassov and J. E. Duboscq and D. Fujino and K. K. Gan and T. Hart and K. Honscheid and H. Kagan and R. Kass and J. Lee and H. Schwarthoff and M. B. Spencer and M. Sung and A. Undrus and A. Wolf and M. M. Zoeller and S. J. Richichi and H. Severini and P. Skubic and M. Bishai and J. Fast and J. W. Hinson and N. Menson and D. H. Miller and E. I. Shibata and I. P. J. Shipsey and M. Yurko and S. Glenn and Y.-J. Kwon and A. L. Lyon and S. Roberts and E. H. Thorndike and C. Jessop and K. Lingel and H. Marsiske and M. Perl and V. Savinov and D. Ugolini and Xingyu Zhou and T. E. Coan and V. Fadeyev and I. Korolkov and Y. Maravin and I. Narsky and V. Shelkov and J. Staeck and R. Stroynowski and I. Volobouev and J. Ye and M. Artuso and F. Azfar and А. Efimov and M. Goldberg and D. He and S. Köpp and G. C. Moneti and R. Mountain and S. Schuh and T. Skwarnicki and S. Stone and G. H. A. Viehhauser and J. C. Wang and X. Xing and J. Bartelt and S. E. Csorna and V. Jain and K. W. McLean and S. Márka and R. Godang and K. Kinoshita and I. C. Lai and P. Pomianowski and S. Schrenk and G. Bonvicini and D. Cinabro and R. Greene and L. P. Perera and Gao-Liang Zhou and M. Chadha and S. Chan and G. Eigen and J. S. Miller and M. Śchmidtler and J. Urheim and A. J. Weinstein and F. Würthwein and Daniel W. Bliss and D. E. Jaffe},
  title = {{First Search for<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi mathvariant="italic">CP</mml:mi></mml:math>Violation in Tau Lepton Decay}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1998},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.81.3823},
}
Figure