Coloured gravitational instantons, the strong CP problem and the companion axion solution

Zhe Chen, Archil KobakhidzeThe European Physical Journal C 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues that a new source of CP violation arising from "coloured gravitational instantons" compromises the standard axion solution to the strong CP problem. The authors propose that a viable solution requires at least one additional "companion axion."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The strong CP problem is a long-standing puzzle in particle physics. It arises because the Standard Model of particle physics, specifically Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), allows for a term that violates charge-parity (CP) symmetry. However, experimental searches for such CP violation, particularly in the neutron electric dipole moment, have found it to be extremely small. The standard solution, proposed by Peccei and Quinn, involves introducing a new symmetry (U(1)PQ) and a corresponding particle (the axion). This mechanism elegantly cancels out the problematic CP-violating term.

This paper addresses a potential flaw in this standard solution. It points out that quantum gravity itself can introduce new sources of CP violation. Specifically, the authors focus on "coloured gravitational instantons" (CEH instantons), which are solutions in quantum gravity that interact with the strong force. They argue that these CEH instantons bundle the CP violation from gravity with the CP violation inherent in QCD, creating a combined effect that the standard axion mechanism may not be able to fully cancel. This would mean the standard axion solution is compromised, and a new approach is needed.

Methods

The authors delve into the theoretical framework of gravitational instantons, particularly focusing on "coloured Eguchi-Hanson (CEH) instantons." They analyze the mathematical structure of these instantons, which are defined on asymptotically locally Euclidean (ALE) manifolds. A key step involves computing the contribution of these CEH instantons to the effective axion potential. This is done by considering the interaction of these instantons with fermions, leading to the calculation of "t Hooft vertices" and ultimately an expression for the axion potential that includes terms dependent on both the QCD CP-violating parameter ($\theta_{QCD}$) and a new parameter related to the CEH instantons ($\theta_{CEH}$).

To address the compromised standard axion solution, they propose a modification to the Peccei-Quinn mechanism. This involves introducing an additional spontaneously broken anomalous U(1)'PQ symmetry, leading to a "companion axion" ($\alpha'$). The paper then derives the potential for a system with two axions, showing how this new potential can be minimized to achieve a CP-invariant vacuum state, thus resolving the strong CP problem. They also calculate the masses and mixing angles of these physical axion states.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gravitational Instantons as a New CP Source: The paper highlights that quantum gravity isn't CP-neutral and can introduce its own CP-violating terms, particularly through CEH instantons.
  • Bundling of CP Violation: CEH instantons are shown to "bundle" the CP violation from gravity with that from QCD, making it a more complex problem than previously thought.
  • Compromise of the Standard Axion Solution: The combined CP violation from QCD and CEH instantons means that a single axion might not be sufficient to cancel out all CP-violating effects to the required experimental precision.
  • Necessity of a Companion Axion: The authors propose that a more robust solution to the strong CP problem requires at least one additional axion, a "companion axion," arising from a second spontaneously broken anomalous U(1)'PQ symmetry.
  • Two-Axion Potential: The paper derives a two-axion potential that can be minimized to yield a CP-conserving vacuum, effectively solving the strong CP problem.

Key Results

  • The paper provides a detailed mathematical description of coloured gravitational instantons and their contribution to the effective axion potential.
  • They demonstrate that the standard Peccei-Quinn mechanism, with a single axion, is compromised by the CEH instanton contributions, as the resulting axion potential is not CP-invariant unless fine-tuning is invoked.
  • A two-axion potential is derived, showing that the combined CP-violating terms ($\theta_{QCD}$ and $\theta_{CEH}$) can be canceled by the vacuum expectation values of two axions, leading to a CP-conserving vacuum.
  • Formulas for the masses and mixing angles of the physical axion states in the two-axion model are presented.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Zero-Mode Solutions: The paper mentions that explicit solutions for the 12 bosonic zero-modes of SU(2) CEH instantons are not known and are planned for future work.
  • Phenomenology: While the paper proposes the companion axion solution, it notes that the detailed phenomenology of this model, including photon couplings and cosmological implications, has been studied in related works ([27, 28]).
  • Neglected Terms: The derivation of the two-axion potential neglects mixing with neutral $\pi$ and $\eta$ mesons, and also ignores electromagnetic and weak $\theta$ parameters, suggesting these could be areas for further investigation.
  • Experimental Verification: The paper lays out a theoretical framework. Future work would involve exploring how these theoretical predictions could be tested experimentally, particularly concerning the properties and detection of the proposed companion axion.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Quantum gravity introduces a new source of the combined parity (CP) violation in gauge theories. We argue that this new CP violation gets bundled with the strong CP violation through the coloured gravitational instantons. Consequently, the standard axion solution to the strong CP problem is compromised. Further, we argue that the ultimate solution to the strong CP problem must involve at least one additional axion particle.
BibTeX
@article{chen2022coloured,
  author = {Zhe Chen and Archil Kobakhidze},
  title = {{Coloured gravitational instantons, the strong CP problem and the companion axion solution}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-022-10542-3},
}
Figure