Competition and Intertwining of Electronic Orders in Superconductors

This direction is merged into another direction: competing electronic orders. Its last version stays readable and citable here.

Version 1 of 177 papers94 conceptsfrozen 2026-10-04

In many quantum materials, electrons face a "identity crisis." They can condense into a superconducting state where they flow without resistance, or they can lock into periodic patterns known as charge density waves (CDW) or spin density waves (SDW). For decades, the central question in condensed matter physics has been whether these states are bitter rivals, cooperative partners, or different symptoms of the same underlying "intertwined" order.

The Zero-Sum Game of the Fermi Surface

The most intuitive way to understand the relationship between superconductivity (SC) and charge density waves is as a competition for a limited resource: the electrons at the Fermi surface. Both states emerge from instabilities in the electronic structure. When a CDW forms, it "gaps" out portions of the Fermi surface, effectively removing those electrons from the pool available to form superconducting Cooper pairs.

This competition is vividly illustrated in the "M-shaped" superconducting domes discovered in kagome metals like $RbV_3Sb_5$ and $CsV_3Sb_5$. As shown by N. N. Wang and Keyu Chen, applying pressure initially suppresses the CDW state, which allows the superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$) to rise. However, the $T_c$ doesn't just go up and stay up; it fluctuates in a complex double-dome pattern, suggesting that the two states are fiercely contending for the same electronic density.

Intertwined Orders and the Pair Density Wave

While "competition" implies two separate states fighting, researchers like Eun-Ah Kim and Steven A. Kivelson have argued that these phases are often intertwined. In this view, the same microscopic interactions—typically strong electron-electron repulsions—give rise to a landscape of nearly degenerate states.

A prime example is the Pair Density Wave (PDW). Unlike a standard superconductor where the electron pairing is uniform, a PDW is a state where the superconducting order parameter itself oscillates in space. Hao-Kai Zhang and Zheng-Yu Weng have identified a "hidden string order" that explains how these spatial oscillations emerge from the phase-string sign structure of doped Mott insulators. Experimentally, Jinzhong Zhang and colleagues have used terahertz spectroscopy to observe "local pairs" in cuprates that suggest a PDW state coexists with bulk superconductivity, acting as a precursor or a competitor depending on the conditions.

Tuning the Balance: Pressure and Doping

To understand why one state wins over another, physicists use "knobs" like chemical doping and hydrostatic pressure to tilt the energy landscape.

  • Pressure: In materials like $NbTe_4$ and $HfTe_3$, pressure acts as a "CDW killer." Xiaojun Yang and Ziyi Liu demonstrated that as pressure suppresses the static lattice distortions of the CDW, superconductivity emerges from the wreckage.
  • Doping: In the newly discovered nickelate superconductor $La_3Ni_2O_7$, Yin Chen and Jun Hou found that high-temperature superconductivity (up to 80 K) only appears when magnetic and charge orders are cleared away, often by emptying specific "$\sigma$-bonding" orbitals that otherwise anchor the competing phases.

Symmetry Protection and Sublattice Interference

Why do some superconducting features, like the gapless "nodes" in d-wave superconductors, survive even when a competing order is present? Cheng-Chien Chen and Steven A. Kivelson identified a fundamental symmetry condition—invariance under time reversal followed by a lattice translation—that protects these nodal quasiparticles.

In kagome lattices, the geometry itself plays a role. Xianxin Wu showed that "sublattice interference"—where electrons on different parts of the star-shaped lattice interfere with one another—can drive unconventional pairing symmetries (like f-wave) that are uniquely suited to coexist with or emerge from the kagome CDW.

The Feedback Loop

Finally, the relationship isn't just one-way. Subir Sachdev has shown that superconducting fluctuations actually provide "feedback" that shapes the competing orders. In underdoped cuprates, this feedback explains why the material chooses a specific axial charge-density wave pattern over other theoretically stable options.

By treating these materials not as having one "true" ground state, but as a theater of competing and intertwined instabilities, researchers are moving toward a predictive framework for designing materials where superconductivity isn't just a lucky accident, but a controlled outcome of electronic engineering.

Papers in this version

Showing 60 of 77 papers.

History & citationVersion 1 · 2026-10-04

Merged into another direction · Permanent link

View frozen version 1

Cite this direction

Latest version (a living page):

@misc{lacuna_competition_and_intertwining_of_electron_67c7a796,
  title = {Competition and Intertwining of Electronic Orders in Superconductors},
  author = {{Lacuna}},
  howpublished = {Lacuna research direction},
  year = {2026},
  url = {https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/direction/competition-and-intertwining-of-electronic-orders-in-superconductors/rdr_67c7a7960c054040aa27a96979836c23},
  note = {Latest version of a living research direction; cite a version for a fixed text. Accessed 2026-11-19},
}

This exact version (version 1, frozen text):

@misc{lacuna_competition_and_intertwining_of_electron_67c7a796_v1,
  title = {Competition and Intertwining of Electronic Orders in Superconductors},
  author = {{Lacuna}},
  howpublished = {Lacuna research direction},
  year = {2026},
  url = {https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/direction/competition-and-intertwining-of-electronic-orders-in-superconductors/rdr_67c7a7960c054040aa27a96979836c23/v/1},
  note = {Version 1, frozen 2026-10-04. Accessed 2026-11-19},
}