WITHDRAWN: Discovery of New Metallic and Superconducting Phase in GaTa4Se8 Under High Pressure

Hongshan Deng, Jianbo Zhang, Min Yong Jeong, Raimundas Sereika, Dong Wang, Takeshi Nakagawa, Bijuan Chen, Xia Yin, Ji‐Chang Ren, Myung Joon Han, Jun Chang, Hongming Weng, Yang Ding, Ho‐kwang MaoResearch Square 2020 · DOI

Pressure serves as a powerful "tuning knob" in condensed matter physics, allowing researchers to force atoms closer together and alter electronic orbitals without changing a material's chemical composition. This capability is essential for exploring quantum phase competitions and uncovering novel states of matter that remain hidden under ambient conditions. A recent study focused on the molecular magnetic Mott insulator $\text{GaTa}_4\text{Se}_8$, a material already known for its fascinating "resistive switching" properties and a variety of quantum phases, such as $J_{eff} = 3/2$ Mott insulating behavior and $d$-wave topological superconductivity. This research pushed the boundaries of investigation into the ultra-high-pressure regime, reaching pressures up to 68 GPa.

Probing Matter Under Extreme Compression

To investigate the structural and electronic evolution of $\text{GaTa}_4\text{Se}_8$ under such intense conditions, the researchers employed a multi-modal experimental strategy. High-pressure Raman spectroscopy was used to monitor vibrational modes, providing clues about structural transitions. Synchrotron X-ray diffraction (XRD) allowed for the precise characterization of the crystal structure at various pressure points. To understand the local atomic environment and bonding changes, the team used Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure (EXAFS).

Crucially, transport measurements were conducted to track electrical resistance, which is the primary method for identifying transitions into metallic or superconducting states. These experimental findings were complemented by theoretical calculations, which provided a framework for understanding how the electronic structure of the molecular clusters in $\text{GaTa}_4\text{Se}_8$ responds to extreme pressure.

A Rich Landscape of Quantum Phases

The study revealed a remarkably complex phase diagram, positioning $\text{GaTa}_4\text{Se}_8$ as a unique playground where multiple quantum orders coexist and compete. In the previously unreached pressure regime above the known transitions, the authors identified a "new" metallic phase. This phase exhibits structural and magnetic signatures that are clearly distinct from the metallic state observed at lower pressures.

The most significant claim of the research is the discovery of a new superconducting phase emerging in this high-pressure regime. The researchers reported a superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$) of approximately 5.5 K. These findings suggest that $\text{GaTa}_4\text{Se}_8$ can transition from a Mott insulator to a Fermi liquid, hosting multiple distinct metallic and superconducting states as it is compressed. This variety of phases highlights the material's potential for studying the interplay between magnetism, electron correlation, and superconductivity.

Important Status Update: Manuscript Withdrawal

Despite the intriguing nature of these findings, it is critical for the scientific community to note that this preprint has been withdrawn by the authors. According to the editorial notes, the withdrawal was necessitated by internal disagreements among the research team regarding the manuscript and the identification of necessary corrections to the work.

Because the full text has been removed from the public record by the authors, the reported discoveries—specifically the 5.5 K superconducting phase and the distinct high-pressure metallic state—should be treated as preliminary. Until a corrected or peer-reviewed version is published, these results should not be cited as a definitive reference. Future research will be essential to resolve the internal discrepancies within the team and to independently verify the reproducibility of these high-pressure quantum phases.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Pressure is a unique thermodynamic variable to explore the phase competitions and novel phases inaccessible at ambient conditions. The resistive switching material GaTa4Se8 displays several quantum phases under pressure, such as Jeff = 3/2 Mott insulator, correlated quantum magnetic metal, and d-wave topological superconductivity, which has recently drawn mounting interest. Using high-pressure Raman, X-ray diffraction, extended X-ray absorption, and transport measurements, together with theoretical calculations, we reveal a remarkably rich phase diagram of this molecular magnetic Mott insulator at pressures up to ~ 68 GPa. In this previously unreached pressure regime, we find, GaTa4Se8 exhibits a new metallic phase whose structural and magnetic properties are clearly distinctive from the lower pressure one. Further, we identify a new superconducting phase in this high-pressure regime below Tc ~ 5.5K. Our discoveries highlight GaTa4Se8 as a unique playground in which novel quantum phases and orders coexist and compete with each other; ranges from Mott insulator to Fermi liquid and exhibits multiple metallic and superconducting states.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{deng2020withdrawn,
  author = {Hongshan Deng and Jianbo Zhang and Min Yong Jeong and Raimundas Sereika and Dong Wang and Takeshi Nakagawa and Bijuan Chen and Xia Yin and Ji‐Chang Ren and Myung Joon Han and Jun Chang and Hongming Weng and Yang Ding and Ho‐kwang Mao},
  title = {{WITHDRAWN: Discovery of New Metallic and Superconducting Phase in GaTa4Se8 Under High Pressure}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-52547/v1},
}
Figure