Abstract
The newly discovered kagome superconductor CsCr3Sb5 exhibits distinct features with flat bands and unique magnetism, providing a compelling platform for exploring novel quantum states of correlated electron systems. Emergent charge order in this material is a key for understanding unconventional superconductivity, but it remains unexplored at the atomic scale and the underlying physics is elusive. Here, we identify and unreported stripe orders on the surface which are distinct from the bulk and investigate the underlying bulk electronic properties using a combination of scanning tunneling microscopy (STM), angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Specifically, a mixture of 2a0 * a0 and 3a0 * a0 stripe order is found on Cs-terminated surface while 4a0 * root3a0 stripe order is found on the Sb-terminated surface. The electronic spectra exhibit strongly correlated features resembling that of high temperature superconductors, with kagome flat bands lying about 330 meV above EF, suggesting that the electron correlations arise from Coulomb interactions and Hund's coupling. Moreover, a distinct electron-boson coupling mode is observed at approximately 100 meV. These findings provide new insights into the interplay between surface and bulk charge orders in this strongly correlated kagome system.
Introduction
Kagome lattices—networks of corner-sharing triangles—have emerged as a premier "quantum playground" for condensed matter physics. Their unique geometry naturally gives rise to exotic electronic features, including Dirac nodes, van Hove singularities (vHS), and "flat bands" where electron kinetic energy is quenched, leading to enhanced many-body interactions.
While the vanadium-based kagome family ($AV_3Sb_5$) has been extensively studied for its unconventional superconductivity and charge density waves (CDW), its electron correlations are relatively weak. The discovery of the chromium-based $CsCr_3Sb_5$ introduces both magnetism and significantly stronger correlations into the system. However, the atomic-scale nature of its charge orders and the precise energy of its flat bands have remained subjects of debate. This study utilizes high-resolution spectroscopy and imaging to resolve these discrepancies and clarify the origin of the material's complex electronic landscape.
Methods
To probe the material's properties across both real and momentum space, a multi-modal experimental approach was employed:
- Sample Synthesis: High-quality single crystals of $CsCr_3Sb_5$ were grown using a self-flux method.
- Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM): Used to achieve atomic-resolution imaging of the surface and measure the local density of states, allowing for the direct visualization of stripe patterns.
- Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy (ARPES): Both synchrotron-based and high-resolution laser-based ARPES were utilized to map the electronic band structure in momentum space.
- Density Functional Theory (DFT): Theoretical calculations provided a baseline for interpreting experimental results and modeling the band structure.
Surface vs. Bulk Divergence
A primary finding of this research is that the surface of $CsCr_3Sb_5$ does not mirror its bulk structure. While the bulk material exhibits a $4a_0 \times a_0$ stripe order, the surfaces develop entirely distinct reconstructions. On the Cesium (Cs)-terminated surface, a mixture of $2a_0$ and $3a_0$ stripe orders was identified. Conversely, the Antimony (Sb)-terminated surface displays a $4a_0 \times \sqrt{3}a_0$ order.
STM imaging confirmed that these stripes are indeed Charge Density Waves (CDW) through the observation of "contrast inversion" when switching between positive and negative bias voltages—a hallmark of CDW behavior. Furthermore, temperature-dependent measurements revealed that the Sb $p$-orbital bands remain largely unaffected by the phase transition at 55 K, suggesting that the charge order is primarily driven by the Cr $d$-orbitals.
Electronic Correlations and Flat Bands
One of the most significant contributions of this work is the definitive placement of the kagome flat bands. Previous studies had disagreed on their location; this study identifies them at approximately 330 meV above the Fermi level ($E_F$). Because these bands reside so far above $E_F$, they are not the primary drivers of the material's low-energy properties or its superconductivity.
Instead, the strong electron correlations observed—evidenced by "waterfall-like" features in ARPES spectra—likely stem from traditional atomic-scale forces such as Coulomb interactions and Hund’s coupling. This suggests that $CsCr_3Sb_5$ shares more physical commonalities with high-temperature cuprate superconductors than with other kagome systems where geometry-driven flat bands dominate the physics. This is further supported by the measured electron-specific heat coefficient ($\gamma_{exp} = 100 \text{ mJ}\cdot\text{K}^{-1}\cdot\text{mol}^{-1}$), which is roughly six times larger than theoretical DFT predictions, confirming a highly correlated state.
Electron-Boson Coupling
The researchers also identified a distinct "kink" in the electronic dispersion at approximately 100 meV. This feature represents a significant departure from the 30 meV kink observed in the vanadium-based family (which is attributed to phonons). In $CsCr_3Sb_5$, this 100 meV mode is likely associated with spin excitations, or magnons, reflecting the magnetic nature of the chromium atoms.
Conclusion
This study clarifies the complex interplay between surface and bulk charge orders in $CsCr_3Sb_5$ and establishes the material as a strongly correlated kagome system where Hund's coupling and Coulomb interactions play a central role. While the exotic surface stripes and high-energy flat bands provide a clearer picture of the electronic landscape, the exact relationship between these features and the material's superconductivity remains an open question. Future research involving pressure-dependent studies and advanced theoretical modeling will be essential to determine if these orders compete with or enhance the superconducting state.
Summary updated