Intertwined magnetism and charge density wave order in kagome FeGe

Xiaokun Teng, Ji Seop Oh, Hengxin Tan, Lebing Chen, Jianwei Huang, Bin Gao, Jia‐Xin Yin, Jiun‐Haw Chu, Makoto Hashimoto, Dong-Hui Lu, Chris Jozwiak, Aaron Bostwick, Eli Rotenberg, G. E. Granroth, Binghai Yan, R. J. Birgeneau, Pengcheng Dai, Ming YiarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

This paper, published in Nature, explores the fascinating physics of the kagome lattice—a crystal structure inspired by Japanese basket weaving—and how it hosts competing and cooperating quantum states.

TL;DR

Researchers have discovered that in the kagome metal FeGe, magnetism and charge density waves (CDW) are not just coexisting, but deeply "intertwined." The material's underlying magnetic order shifts its electronic bands, positioning specific "van Hove singularities" near the Fermi level to trigger the formation of a charge density wave.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Kagome lattice materials are a hotbed for "emergent" phenomena—complex behaviors like superconductivity, magnetism, and charge density waves (where electrons self-organize into a periodic pattern) that arise from simple geometric rules.

Usually, kagome materials fall into two camps: those that are magnetic and those that host CDWs. FeGe is a rare exception that does both. The central challenge addressed here is understanding the "chicken and egg" problem: does the magnetism drive the CDW, or are they independent? Understanding this interplay is crucial for designing new quantum materials with tunable topological properties.

Methods

The team used a multi-pronged approach combining experimental spectroscopy with theoretical modeling:

  • ARPES (Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy): This was the primary tool used to "see" the electronic band structure. By hitting the crystal with high-energy photons and measuring the ejected electrons, the researchers mapped out the energy and momentum of the electrons inside the material.
  • INS (Inelastic Neutron Scattering): This technique was used to observe collective excitations—specifically phonons (lattice vibrations) and magnons (spin waves). This helped identify how the crystal lattice itself reacts when the CDW forms.
  • DFT (Density Functional Theory): The authors used first-principles calculations to simulate the electronic structure, providing a theoretical "map" to compare against their experimental ARPES data.
  • Crystal Growth: High-quality single crystals of FeGe were synthesized using chemical vapor transport.

Datasets

As an experimental physics paper, the "datasets" consist of:

  • High-resolution ARPES spectra taken at various temperatures (from 11 K to 260 K) and photon energies.
  • INS spectra measuring phonon and magnon dispersions.
  • DFT-calculated band structures and Density of States (DOS) for both paramagnetic and antiferromagnetic phases.
  • Comparison data from existing literature on related kagome systems like $AV_3Sb_5$ and FeSn.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Magnetism as a "Tuning Knob": The most significant insight is that magnetism sets the stage for the CDW. FeGe becomes magnetic at a high temperature (~410 K). This magnetic order causes "exchange splitting," which physically shifts the electronic bands. Specifically, it pushes van Hove singularities (vHSs)—points where the electron density of states is very high—toward the Fermi level ($E_F$).
  • Orbital Selectivity: The researchers found that the CDW doesn't affect all electrons equally. It is "orbital-selective," primarily involving the $xz/yz$ orbitals. This suggests that the specific "flavor" of the electron matters for the formation of the CDW.
  • The "Kink" and the Phonon: In the ARPES data, the researchers noticed a "kink" in the electronic dispersion. This is a classic signature of electrons interacting with a boson. By using INS, they identified this boson as an optical phonon mode ($A_{2u}$) that "hardens" (increases in energy) exactly when the CDW appears.
  • A Universal Mechanism? The phenomenology in magnetic FeGe looks surprisingly similar to non-magnetic kagome superconductors ($AV_3Sb_5$). This suggests there might be a universal "kagome recipe" for CDWs involving vHSs and electron-phonon coupling, regardless of whether magnetism is the initial trigger.

Key Results

  • Direct Observation: The team successfully observed all three hallmark signatures of the kagome lattice: flat bands, Dirac crossings, and vHSs.
  • Band Shifting: They tracked the energy of the vHS1 as a function of temperature, showing it shifts upward as the magnetic moment grows, eventually landing near the Fermi level where it can trigger the CDW.
  • Gap Opening: They measured a CDW-induced energy gap of approximately 50 meV, which is consistent with previous scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) studies.
  • Renormalization: By comparing DFT to experiment, they found a renormalization factor of 1.6, indicating that FeGe is a "moderately correlated" system—meaning electrons interact with each other significantly, but not as strongly as in some other exotic insulators.

Limitations and Future Work

While the paper establishes a clear link between magnetism and the CDW, the authors note that the microscopic origin is still not fully resolved.

  • DFT Mismatch: Standard DFT calculations struggle to perfectly match the experimental dispersions and fail to stabilize the CDW order on their own. This indicates that "correlation effects" (complex electron-electron interactions) are playing a role that current models can't quite capture.
  • Theoretical Challenge: Future work will need to incorporate these moderate electron correlations into theoretical models to explain why FeGe develops this specific $2 \times 2$ CDW while other similar magnetic kagome materials (like FeSn) do not.
  • Tunability: The discovery opens the door to using magnetic fields or strain to tune the CDW, potentially leading to new ways to control quantum states in kagome magnets.

Summary updated

Abstract

Electron correlations often lead to emergent orders in quantum materials. Kagome lattice materials are emerging as an exciting platform for realizing quantum topology in the presence of electron correlations. This proposal stems from the key signatures of electronic structures associated with its lattice geometry: flat band induced by destructive interference of the electronic wavefunctions, topological Dirac crossing, and a pair of van Hove singularities (vHSs). A plethora of correlated electronic phases have been discovered amongst kagome lattice materials, including magnetism, charge density wave (CDW), nematicity, and superconductivity. These materials can be largely organized into two types: those that host magnetism and those that host CDW order. Recently, a CDW order has been discovered in the magnetic kagome FeGe, providing a new platform for understanding the interplay between CDW and magnetism. Here, utilizing angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy, we observe all three types of electronic signatures of the kagome lattice: flat bands, Dirac crossings, and vHSs. From both the observation of a temperature-dependent shift of the vHSs towards the Fermi level as well as guidance via first-principle calculations, we identify the presence of the vHSs near the Fermi level (EF) to be driven by the development of underlying magnetic exchange splitting. Furthermore, we show spectral evidence for the CDW order as gaps that open on the near-EF vHS bands, as well as evidence of electron-phonon coupling from a kink on the vHS band together with phonon hardening observed by inelastic neutron scattering. Our observation points to the magnetic interaction-driven band modification resulting in the formation of the CDW order, indicating an intertwined connection between the emergent magnetism and vHS charge order in this moderately-correlated kagome metal.
BibTeX
@misc{teng2022intertwined,
  author = {Xiaokun Teng and Ji Seop Oh and Hengxin Tan and Lebing Chen and Jianwei Huang and Bin Gao and Jia‐Xin Yin and Jiun‐Haw Chu and Makoto Hashimoto and Dong-Hui Lu and Chris Jozwiak and Aaron Bostwick and Eli Rotenberg and G. E. Granroth and Binghai Yan and R. J. Birgeneau and Pengcheng Dai and Ming Yi},
  title = {{Intertwined magnetism and charge density wave order in kagome FeGe}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2210.06653},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.06653},
}
Figure