Abstract
Pairing states are essential to understanding the underlying mechanisms of high-temperature superconductivity. Here the non-superconducting state in an optimally doped $YBa_2Cu_3O_{7-\delta}$ (YBCO) film was driven out of equilibrium by an optical pump with low fluence at a temperature well below the critical temperature ($T_c$), and its recovery dynamics were exclusively measured using transient terahertz (THz) spectroscopy. The pump-fluence dependent experiments unveiled evidence of local pairs without superconductivity coexisting with the superconducting Cooper pairs. An energy gap opening induced by the local pairing with short-range coherence was invoked to rationalize the temperature-dependent recovery time of local pairs with a characteristic divergence at a temperature substantially below $T_c$. These local pairs displayed remarkable likeness to the short-range pair-density-wave state. Our finding sheds light on understanding the dynamic interplay between the coexisting superconducting and non-superconducting pairs in cuprate superconductors.
Introduction
High-temperature superconductivity (HTSC) in cuprates remains one of the greatest mysteries in condensed matter physics. In conventional superconductors, electrons form "Cooper pairs" and simultaneously develop long-range phase coherence at a specific critical temperature ($T_c$). In cuprates, however, pairing and coherence appear to be distinct processes. Scientists have long suspected that "local pairs"—electrons that are paired but lack the long-range coherence needed for zero resistance—exist in a "pseudogap" state above $T_c$. The challenge has been detecting these local pairs below $T_c$, where they are normally masked by the dominant superconducting state.
Methods: Transient Terahertz Spectroscopy and the "Fluence Trick"
The researchers studied an optimally doped thin film of YBCO ($T_c = 91$ K) using Transient Terahertz (THz) Spectroscopy. This pump-probe technique uses a femtosecond laser pulse (pump) to drive the material out of equilibrium and a THz pulse (probe) to measure its complex conductivity as it relaxes. THz frequencies are ideal as they match the low energy scales of superconducting gaps.
By varying the pump intensity (fluence), the team discovered a selective excitation method. While high intensity breaks the superconducting state entirely, very low fluence selectively excites the "normal fluid" (local pairs) while leaving the superconducting superfluid intact. This allowed the isolation of local pair recovery dynamics for the first time.
Key Insights: Bipartite Recombination and the PDW State
The study provides direct evidence that non-superconducting local pairs coexist with superconducting Cooper pairs well below $T_c$. A critical piece of evidence comes from the recovery kinetics. Below $T_c$, the recovery of the low-fluence signal follows a linear relationship ($1/Δσ_1$ vs. time), which is a "smoking gun" for bipartite recombination. This indicates that broken pairs are finding each other and reforming in a two-particle process.
Furthermore, the characteristic recovery time for these local pairs ($τ_{LP}$) shows a clear divergence at approximately 70 K, significantly below the $T_c$ of 91 K. This divergence implies a distinct, temperature-dependent energy gap ($Δ'$) associated with local pairing. The authors argue these local pairs represent a short-range Pair-Density-Wave (PDW) state—a state with enough local coherence to form a gap but insufficient for global superconductivity.
Conclusion
By utilizing low-fluence transient THz spectroscopy, this research successfully isolated the signatures of local pairs coexisting with the superconducting state in YBCO. The discovery of distinct recovery kinetics and a separate energy gap for these pairs suggests they are a short-range PDW state. This finding provides a new tool for exploring the complex phase diagrams of cuprates and understanding the interplay between different pairing mechanisms in high-temperature superconductors.
Summary updated