Performance Requirement Analysis and Weight Estimation of Reusable Launch Vehicle using Rocket based Air-breathing Engine

Kyungjae Lee, Inyoung Yang, Yang-Ji Lee, Chun-Taek Kim, Soo-Seok YangJournal of the Korean Society of Propulsion Engineers 2015 · DOI

Abstract

Performance requirement analysis and weight estimation of a reusable launch vehicle (RLV) with a rocket-based air-breathing engine (RBCC) were performed. An integrated engine-trajectory model was developed and validated against previous research. Based on this model, engine performance requirements were derived for an RLV with a gross take-off weight of 15 tons. The study analyzed how propellant requirements depend on mode transition Mach numbers, providing a roadmap for the conceptual design of small-scale reusable launch systems.

Introduction

Traditional rocket engines are fundamentally limited by the necessity of carrying both fuel and oxidizer, which results in low specific impulse ($I_{sp}$) and massive takeoff weights. In contrast, air-breathing engines like ramjets and scramjets utilize atmospheric oxygen, offering significantly higher efficiency. However, these engines cannot operate from a standstill or in the vacuum of space.

The Rocket-Based Combined Cycle (RBCC) engine integrates rocket and air-breathing modes into a single propulsion system to bridge this gap. Designing an RLV around an RBCC engine requires a complex balancing act to determine optimal mode transitions while managing aerodynamic drag and structural weight. This paper specifically addresses these performance requirements and weight estimations for a 15-ton class RLV.

Mission profile of the RBCC-based reusable launch vehicle showing transitions from ejector rocket to ramjet, scramjet, and final rocket modes.

Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-disciplinary modeling approach to simulate the vehicle's performance:

  • Engine Modeling: A quasi-one-dimensional model was developed to account for the efficiencies of the intake, isolator, and combustor. Combustion efficiency was estimated using a polynomial function calibrated against experimental data from the Korea Aerospace Research Institute (KARI).
  • Trajectory Analysis: A 3-DOF flight simulation was integrated with the engine model to calculate thrust, drag, and propellant consumption across a polar orbit mission profile.
  • Weight Estimation: Mass estimation equations were used to calculate the "dry weight" of the vehicle based on its geometry and required propellant volume, ensuring the feasibility of the 15-ton takeoff weight constraint.

Key Insights and Trade-offs

A critical finding of the study is the sensitivity of the design to transition Mach numbers ($M_{tr}$). The transition from scramjet to the final rocket mode ($M_{tr3}$) is particularly sensitive. While extending the scramjet phase saves oxidizer, the escalating aerodynamic drag at high Mach numbers can negate these efficiency gains. The study suggests that if the thrust-to-drag ratio drops below 1.5, it is more efficient to switch to rocket mode earlier and climb into the thinner atmosphere.

Furthermore, the analysis of fixed-geometry intakes revealed that while they introduce efficiency losses compared to variable geometry, the mission remains feasible, albeit requiring a longer ramjet operation phase to compensate.

Performance Results

For a 15-ton Gross Take-Off Weight (GTOW), the estimated dry weight is approximately 3,520 kg, with a required propellant mass of roughly 11,480 kg. The RBCC engine demonstrated a massive efficiency advantage over traditional chemical rockets.

Comparison of Specific Impulse ($I_{sp}$) versus Mach number for the KARI model and other reference models, highlighting the high efficiency in air-breathing modes.

As illustrated in Figure 2, the engine achieved a peak $I_{sp}$ of 4,540 seconds in ramjet mode (at Mach 3) and maintained between 2,680 and 2,360 seconds during the scramjet phase. This performance is nearly an order of magnitude higher than the ~450 seconds typical of high-performance liquid rockets. Sensitivity analysis showed that lowering the final transition Mach number ($M_{tr3}$) from 10.7 to 8.0 increased the required propellant by 3.4% (390 kg), highlighting the critical nature of high-Mach scramjet performance for vehicle mass margins.

Conclusion

The integrated model successfully demonstrated the feasibility of a mission delivering a 100 kg satellite and a single pilot to a 185 km polar orbit using a 15-ton RLV. Future work will focus on refining aero-thermal loading models to better account for structural weight increases necessitated by hypersonic flight and physical testing of RBCC engine sub-scale models to verify the computational combustion efficiencies.

Summary updated

Abstract

로켓 기반 공기흡입추진(RBCC : Rocket Based Combined Cycle) 엔진이 적용된 재사용 발사체의 요구 중량 및 성능을 분석하고 예측하였다. RBCC 엔진을 위해 개발한 엔진 모델과 비행체 궤적 모델을 통합하여 RBCC 기반 재사용 발사체의 궤적 및 성능계산 모델을 개발하였으며, 기존 논문의 결과와 비교함으로써 검증하였다. 개발된 모델과 기존 논문을 바탕으로 총 이륙중량 15톤의 재사용 발사체에 대한 무게분석과 엔진의 요구 조건을 도출하였으며, 엔진의 모드 전환 마하수 변화 등에 따른 비행체의 추진제 요구량 변화를 분석하였다. Performance requirement analysis and weight estimation of a reusable launch vehicle with a rocket-based air-breathing engine(RBCC : Rocket Based Combined Cycle) were performed. Performance model for an RBCC engine was developed and integrated with flight trajectory model. The integrated engine-trajectory model was validated by comparing the results with those from previous research reference. Based on the new engine-trajectory model and previous research results, engine performance requirements were derived for an reusable launching vehicle with gross take-off weight of 15 tones. Dependence of the propellant amount requirement on the mode transition Mach number of the engine was also analyzed.
BibTeX
@article{lee2015performance,
  author = {Kyungjae Lee and Inyoung Yang and Yang-Ji Lee and Chun-Taek Kim and Soo-Seok Yang},
  title = {{Performance Requirement Analysis and Weight Estimation of Reusable Launch Vehicle using Rocket based Air-breathing Engine}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korean Society of Propulsion Engineers},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.6108/kspe.2015.19.6.010},
}
Figure