Abstract
Social capital has been studied in economics, sociology and political science as one of the key elements that promote the development of modern societies. It can be defined as the source of capital that facilitates cooperation through shared social norms. In this work, we investigate whether and to what extent synchronization aspects of mobile communication patterns are associated with social capital metrics. Interestingly, our results show that our synchronization-based approach well correlates with existing social capital metrics (i.e., Referendum turnout, Blood donations, and Association density), being also able to characterize the different role played by high synchronization within a close proximity-based community and high synchronization among different communities. Hence, the proposed approach can provide timely, effective analysis at a limited cost over a large territory.
Introduction
Social capital—the networks and norms that enable collective action—is a cornerstone of modern societal health, linked to economic growth and reduced corruption. However, traditional measurement via surveys is slow and expensive. This research explores whether digital traces, specifically the temporal synchronization of mobile communication, can serve as a high-resolution, real-time proxy for social capital. The central hypothesis is that communities with highly synchronized communication patterns exhibit the shared norms and trust characteristic of high social capital.
Methodology
The study utilizes aggregated Call Detail Records (CDRs) from a major Italian mobile operator, covering one month in 2015. To extract meaningful synchronization metrics, the researchers followed a multi-step process:
- Aggregation: CDRs were binned into hourly intervals for specific geographic cells.
- Normalization: To isolate coordination from standard daily routines (circadian bias), a Z-score normalization was applied to each hour. This ensures the study measures meaningful coordination rather than just the universal increase in activity during daylight hours.
- Quantification: Mutual Information (MI) was used to measure the non-linear dependence between the time series of different cells.
Two primary indices were developed to distinguish between different types of social capital:
- Within Synchronization: Average daily synchronization between cells in the same municipality (a proxy for "bonding" social capital).
- Between Synchronization: Average daily synchronization between cells in different municipalities (a proxy for "bridging" social capital or community heterogeneity).
Results and Discussion
The synchronization metrics demonstrated significant explanatory power when compared against official Italian statistics (ISTAT) for referendum turnout, blood donations, and association density. Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) models revealed that "Within Synchronization" consistently correlates positively with civic engagement. For instance, it showed a strong positive relationship with blood donations ($\beta = 19.49$).
Conversely, "Between Synchronization" often showed negative correlations ($\beta = -24.91$ for blood donations), suggesting that high synchronization with external communities might dilute local civic norms—a finding that aligns with sociological theories regarding community heterogeneity.
The model's performance was robust, explaining 68% of the variation in referendum turnout and over 50% for both blood donations and association density. These results suggest that synchronization is not merely a mathematical artifact but a reflection of the cooperative nature of a community; in an evolutionary sense, synchronization reduces the costs of coordinated action.
Conclusion and Future Work
This study provides a privacy-preserving method to monitor social capital using aggregate cell-level data rather than individual logs. While the current results focus on traditional civic metrics, future research could explore how these patterns evolve over longer periods or how "bridging" synchronization might positively correlate with other factors like economic innovation or novelty seeking. Extending this framework to social media or mobility data could further refine our understanding of regional social health.
Summary updated