Investigating the association between synchronization and social capital

Marco Mamei, Francesca Pancotto, Marco De Nadai, Bruno Lepri, Michele Vescovi, Francesco Zambonelli, Alex Pentland

Abstract

Social capital has been studied in economics, sociology and political science as one of the key elements that promote the development of modern societies. It can be defined as the source of capital that facilitates cooperation through shared social norms. In this work, we investigate whether and to what extent synchronization aspects of mobile communication patterns are associated with social capital metrics. Interestingly, our results show that our synchronization-based approach well correlates with existing social capital metrics (i.e., Referendum turnout, Blood donations, and Association density), being also able to characterize the different role played by high synchronization within a close proximity-based community and high synchronization among different communities. Hence, the proposed approach can provide timely, effective analysis at a limited cost over a large territory.

Introduction: The Challenge of Measuring Social Capital

Social capital is often described as the "secret sauce" of prosperous societies. It encompasses the shared norms, trust, and networks that facilitate cooperation and reduce transaction costs. However, measuring social capital is notoriously difficult. Traditional methods rely on large-scale surveys that are expensive, infrequent, and often subjective.

This research explores a "digital breadcrumb" for social capital: synchronization. The authors hypothesize that the way communities "pulse" together in their communication patterns can serve as a proxy for human cooperation. Specifically, they investigate whether high synchronization in mobile phone activity correlates with civic engagement metrics like blood donations and referendum turnout.

Methods: Extracting Synchronization from Call Records

The researchers developed a privacy-preserving framework to extract synchronization patterns from aggregated Call Detail Records (CDRs).

Time-Series Normalization

To isolate spontaneous social coordination from predictable daily routines, the team applied a specific normalization process. They aggregated call volumes into hourly bins and used z-score normalization. Crucially, they calculated the mean and standard deviation for each specific hour of the day across the study period. This removes the "circadian rhythm"—the obvious fact that call volume peaks during the day and drops at night—leaving only the subtle, spontaneous deviations in activity.

Figure 3: Mobile phone call volume normalization. Panel A shows raw call counts over time, while Panel B shows the Z-score normalized data which removes the dominant circadian patterns.

Measuring Synchronization

Instead of simple linear correlation, the study utilized Mutual Information (MI) to measure synchronization. MI is better suited for capturing non-linear dependencies between the activity "pulses" of different geographical cells. From this, two primary indices were derived:

  • Within-synchronization: The average MI between cells within the same municipality (a proxy for "bonding" social capital).
  • Between-synchronization: The average MI between cells in different municipalities (a proxy for "bridging" social capital).

Key Insights and Results

The study analyzed one month of CDRs from 16 Italian provinces, comparing synchronization metrics against official statistics for referendum turnout, blood donations, and association density.

The Bonding vs. Bridging Distinction

The results highlighted a clear distinction between internal and external synchronization. "Within-synchronization" generally correlated positively with social capital, reflecting the "muscular bonding" of tight-knit, cooperative communities. In contrast, "between-synchronization" often showed a negative correlation with civic metrics, suggesting that high levels of inter-community fragmentation might undermine local trust.

Figure 4: Distribution of average synchronization (within vs. between) across various Italian cities. The violin plots illustrate the variance and central tendencies of these two key metrics.

Predictive Power

The synchronization-based models proved remarkably effective, explaining a significant portion of the variance in social capital:

  • Referendum Turnout: $R^2_{adj} = 0.68$
  • Blood Donations: $R^2_{adj} = 0.55$
  • Association Density: $R^2_{adj} = 0.52$

Notably, these synchronization metrics were often as predictive as, or more predictive than, traditional economic indicators like per-capita income.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This "sync-sensing" approach offers a low-cost, timely, and privacy-preserving method for monitoring social health over large territories. While the study was limited to 16 Italian provinces and establishes association rather than causality, it opens the door for real-time mapping of social capital using diverse data streams like social media or public transport flows. Future work will focus on validating these findings in different cultural contexts and exploring the causal mechanisms behind these temporal rhythms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Social capital has been studied in economics, sociology and political science as one of the key elements that promote the development of modern societies. It can be defined as the source of capital that facilitates cooperation through shared social norms. In this work, we investigate whether and to what extent synchronization aspects of mobile communication patterns are associated with social capital metrics. Interestingly, our results show that our synchronization-based approach well correlates with existing social capital metrics (i.e., Referendum turnout, Blood donations, and Association density), being also able to characterize the different role played by high synchronization within a close proximity-based community and high synchronization among different communities. Hence, the proposed approach can provide timely, effective analysis at a limited cost over a large territory.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mamei2018investigating,
  author = {Marco Mamei and Francesca Pancotto and Marco De Nadai and Bruno Lepri and Michele Vescovi and Francesco Zambonelli and Alex Pentland},
  title = {{Investigating the association between synchronization and social capital}},
  booktitle = {EPJ Data Sci},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=oFUcy_nYgA},
}
Figure