Is social capital associated with synchronization in human communication? An analysis of Italian call records and measures of civic engagement

Marco Mamei, Francesca Pancotto, Marco De Nadai, Bruno Lepri, Michele Vescovi, Francesco Zambonelli, Alex Pentland

Abstract

Social capital has been studied in economics, sociology, and political science as one of the key elements that promote the development of modern societies. It can be defined as the source of capital that facilitates cooperation through shared social norms. In this work, we investigate whether and to what extent synchronization aspects of mobile communication patterns are associated with social capital metrics. Interestingly, our results show that our synchronization-based approach well correlates with existing social capital metrics (i.e., Referendum turnout, Blood donations, and Association density), being also able to characterize the different role played by high synchronization within a close proximity-based community and high synchronization among different communities. Hence, the proposed approach can provide timely, effective analysis at a limited cost over a large territory.

Introduction

Social capital—the shared norms and networks that facilitate cooperation—is a cornerstone of healthy, prosperous societies. However, measuring it is notoriously difficult. Traditional methods rely on expensive, infrequent, and often subjective surveys. This research explores the intersection of network science and sociology, investigating whether the "rhythm" of our digital lives can predict the strength of our social fabric. By analyzing Italian mobile phone records, the researchers demonstrate that synchronization in communication patterns is a robust, low-cost proxy for traditional social capital metrics like voting and blood donations.

Methodology

The researchers proposed two novel "synchronization indices" derived from Call Detail Records (CDRs):

  1. Within Synchronization: Measures the average coordination between mobile phone cells within the same municipality, capturing "bonding" social capital (internal cohesion).
  2. Between Synchronization: Measures coordination between cells in different municipalities, capturing "bridging" social capital (external links).

To isolate subtle synchronization beyond the obvious circadian rhythm (where everyone calls more at noon than at 3 AM), the team applied a Z-score normalization based on the specific hour of the day. This process, illustrated below, ensures that the resulting metrics reflect behavioral coordination rather than just the time of day.

Time-series of mobile phone calls (A) and the corresponding Z-score normalized values (B) used to isolate subtle synchronization patterns.

Instead of simple linear correlation, they used Mutual Information (MI) to quantify the non-linear dependence between time series. They then used Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) models to see how well these indices could explain official social capital statistics from the Italian National Institute of Statistics (ISTAT), such as referendum turnout and blood donations.

Key Insights and Results

The core finding is that synchronization acts as a behavioral signature of cooperation. High "within" synchronization was a consistent positive predictor of civic engagement metrics. The models showed impressive predictive power, explaining a large portion of the variance across Italian provinces:

  • Referendum Turnout: Adjusted $R^2 = 0.68$.
  • Blood Donations: Adjusted $R^2 = 0.55$.
  • Association Density: Adjusted $R^2 = 0.52$.
Geographic distribution of 'within synchronization' across Italian provinces, illustrating the spatial variation in local coordination.

Interestingly, high "between" synchronization often correlated negatively with local civic engagement. This supports the theory that high community diversity or a focus on external ties can sometimes undermine local social cohesion. Because the method uses aggregated cell-level data rather than individual logs, it offers a way to monitor social health while preserving privacy.

Conclusion

This study proves a strong association between digital synchronization and real-world social capital. While it does not definitively establish causality, the results suggest that synchronization reduces the "transaction costs" of cooperation. Future work could look at how these rhythms change over years or during social crises. For policymakers, this approach provides a timely, effective tool for evaluating the effectiveness of social programs in near real-time across large territories.

Summary updated

Abstract

Social capital has been studied in economics, sociology and political science as one of the key elements that promote the development of modern societies. It can be defined as the source of capital that facilitates cooperation through shared social norms. In this work, we investigate whether and to what extent synchronization aspects of mobile communication patterns are associated with social capital metrics. Interestingly, our results show that our synchronization-based approach well correlates with existing social capital metrics (i.e., Referendum turnout, Blood donations, and Association density), being also able to characterize the different role played by high synchronization within a close proximity-based community and high synchronization among different communities. Hence, the proposed approach can provide timely, effective analysis at a limited cost over a large territory.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mamei2018is,
  author = {Marco Mamei and Francesca Pancotto and Marco De Nadai and Bruno Lepri and Michele Vescovi and Francesco Zambonelli and Alex Pentland},
  title = {{Is social capital associated with synchronization in human communication? An analysis of Italian call records and measures of civic engagement}},
  booktitle = {EPJ Data Sci},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=oFUcy_nYgA},
}
Figure