Imaging superatomic molecular orbitals in a ${\bf C_{60}}$ molecule through four 800-nm photons

G. P. Zhang, Heng Zhu, Y. H. Bai, Jason Bonacum, Xiao Wu, Thomas F. George

Abstract

Superatomic molecular orbitals (SAMOs) in $C_{60}$ are ideal building blocks for functional nanostructures. However, imaging them spatially in the gas phase has been historically unsuccessful. Experimentally, it has been observed that when $C_{60}$ is excited by an 800-nm laser, the resulting photoelectron casts an anisotropic velocity image, whereas excitation at 400 nm produces an isotropic image. While this difference was previously attributed to electron thermal ionization, recent 800-nm experiments reveal a clear non-diffuse image superimposed on the diffuse background, the origin of which remained a mystery. This study demonstrates that the non-diffuse anisotropic image is the precursor of the $1f$ SAMO. We predict that four 800-nm photons can directly access the $1f$ SAMO, and with one additional photon, image the orbital. The resulting photoelectron angular distribution features two maxima at $0^\circ$ and $180^\circ$ and two humps separated by $56.5^\circ$. This finding provides a natural explanation for the non-diffuse image difference, complementing the thermal scenario.

Introduction

The Buckminsterfullerene ($C_{60}$) molecule is a cornerstone of molecular physics, particularly due to its Superatomic Molecular Orbitals (SAMOs). These are large, diffuse electron clouds that reside outside the carbon cage, mimicking the orbitals of a single atom but on a much larger scale. Because of their unique spatial properties, SAMOs are considered prime candidates for building blocks in functional nanotechnology.

Despite their potential, capturing a spatial "image" of these orbitals in the gas phase has proven difficult. The primary tool for this task is Velocity-Map Imaging (VMI), which maps the velocity and direction of ejected photoelectrons. A long-standing puzzle in VMI experiments involves the wavelength dependence of the results: 400-nm light produces a blurry, uniform (isotropic) electron distribution, while 800-nm light produces a sharp, directional (anisotropic) pattern. This research identifies the quantum mechanical mechanism behind this discrepancy.

The Experimental Discrepancy

In previous studies, the diffuse nature of the 400-nm images was largely attributed to thermal ionization—a process where the molecule absorbs energy and eventually "boils off" an electron in a random direction. However, newer experiments using 800-nm pulses revealed sharp, non-diffuse features that thermal theories could not explain.

These sharp features suggested a direct ionization process where the electron retains the "memory" of the orbital it inhabited before being ejected. The challenge was to identify which specific orbital was being imaged and why it only appeared clearly at 800 nm.

Computational Methodology

To solve this, the researchers employed first-principles computational methods based on Density Functional Theory (DFT). To ensure the results were robust and not artifacts of a specific mathematical model, they utilized three distinct solvers:

  1. Gaussian09: Utilizing basis-function approaches.
  2. VASP: A planewave-based approach.
  3. Octopus: A real-space grid-based approach.

By calculating the energy gaps between the molecule's Highest Occupied Molecular Orbital (HOMO) and various excited states, they modeled the "transition matrix elements"—the probability of an electron jumping through multiple energy levels by absorbing several photons simultaneously.

Key Findings: The 4-Photon Resonance

The study's breakthrough was the identification of a specific resonance. The energy gap between the $C_{60}$ HOMO and the $1f$ SAMO is approximately 6.2 eV. This energy corresponds almost exactly to the combined energy of four 800-nm photons (each $\sim$1.55 eV).

Symmetry Filtering

The reason for the difference between 400-nm and 800-nm light lies in the symmetry of the target states:

  • At 400 nm: Two photons (totaling $\sim$6.2 eV) resonantly excite the $1s$ SAMO. Because $s$-orbitals are spherical, the resulting electron distribution is isotropic, appearing as a uniform circle on the detector.
  • At 800 nm: Four photons target the $1f$ SAMO. Unlike the $s$-orbital, the $f$-orbital is highly directional and complex. This orbital acts as a "doorway state"; the electron lingers in this shape before a fifth photon provides the final kick to eject it from the molecule.

Validation and Results

The theoretical model's predictions showed remarkable agreement with experimental data:

  • Kinetic Energy: The predicted kinetic energy of the ejected electron (0.2 eV) matched experimental peaks.
  • Angular Distribution: The simulation predicted a specific pattern for the $1f$ SAMO: two primary peaks at $0^\circ$ and $180^\circ$, with two secondary "humps" separated by $56.5^\circ$.
  • Experimental Match: This prediction was validated by experimental observations (from Li and coworkers), which showed humps separated by $54.4^\circ$. This small margin of error (less than $3^\circ$) provides strong evidence that the $1f$ SAMO is indeed the source of the anisotropic image.

Conclusion

This research successfully complements the traditional thermal ionization scenario by providing a direct quantum mechanical explanation for non-diffuse VMI features. By demonstrating that 800-nm pulses can selectively target and image the $1f$ SAMO through a four-photon resonance, the study opens new avenues for "orbital-selective" imaging. Future work may involve tuning laser wavelengths to bring other superatomic states, such as $1h$ or $2p$ orbitals, into focus, further expanding our ability to map and manipulate the electronic structure of complex molecules.

Summary updated

Abstract

Superatomic molecular orbitals (SAMO) in C60 are ideal building blocks for functional nanostructures. However, imaging them spatially in the gas phase has been unsuccessful. It is found experimentally that if C60 is excited by an 800-nm laser, the photoelectron casts an anisotropic velocity image, but the image becomes isotropic if excited at a 400-nm wavelength. This diffuse image difference has been attributed to electron thermal ionization, but more recent experiments (800 nm) reveal a clear non-diffuse image superimposed on the diffuse image, whose origin remains a mystery. Here we show that the non-diffuse anisotropic image is the precursor of the $f$ SAMO. We predict that four 800-nm photons can directly access the $1f$ SAMO, and with one more photon, can image the orbital, with the photoelectron angular distribution having two maxima at 0$^\circ$ and 180$^\circ$ and two humps separated by 56.5$^\circ$. Since two 400-nm photons only resonantly excite the spherical $1s$ SAMO and four 800-nm photon excite the anisotropic $1f$ SAMO, our finding gives a natural explanation of the non-diffuse image difference, complementing the thermal scenario.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2015imaging,
  author = {G. P. Zhang and Heng Zhu and Y. H. Bai and Jason Bonacum and Xiao Wu and Thomas F. George},
  title = {{Imaging superatomic molecular orbitals in a $\{\textbackslash\{\}bf C\_\{60\}\}$ molecule through four 800-nm photons}},
  journal = {International Journal of Modern Physics B},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1142/s0217979215501155},
}
Figure