Observation of laser-induced electronic structure in oriented polyatomic molecules

Peter M. Kraus, Oleg I. Tolstikhin, Denitsa Baykusheva, Alisa Rupenyan, J. Schneider, Christer Z. Bisgaard, Tōru Morishita, Frank Jensen, Lars Bojer Madsen, Hans Jakob WörnerNature Communications 2015 · DOI

Abstract

All attosecond time-resolved measurements have so far relied on the use of intense near-infrared laser pulses. In particular, attosecond streaking, laser-induced electron diffraction and high-harmonic generation all make use of non-perturbative light-matter interactions. Remarkably, the effect of the strong laser field on the studied sample has often been neglected in previous studies. Here we use high-harmonic spectroscopy to measure laser-induced modifications of the electronic structure of molecules. We study high-harmonic spectra of spatially oriented CH3F and CH3Br as generic examples of polar polyatomic molecules. We accurately measure intensity ratios of even and odd-harmonic orders, and of the emission from aligned and unaligned molecules. We show that these robust observables reveal a substantial modification of the molecular electronic structure by the external laser field. Our insights offer new challenges and opportunities for a range of emerging strong-field attosecond spectroscopies.

Introduction

Attosecond time-resolved measurements, including high-harmonic spectroscopy (HHS) and laser-induced electron diffraction, are fundamental tools for probing ultrafast molecular dynamics. These techniques rely on intense near-infrared laser pulses to drive non-perturbative light-matter interactions. Historically, researchers have operated under the "field-free" hypothesis, assuming that the strong driving laser field does not significantly alter the electronic structure of the target molecule during the measurement process.

While this assumption is generally valid for simple atoms, it becomes problematic for larger, polar polyatomic molecules. Due to their spatial extension and high polarizability, these molecules are susceptible to dynamic modifications by the external field. This study investigates whether the driving laser field significantly alters the electronic structure of polar molecules like methyl fluoride ($CH_3F$) and methyl bromide ($CH_3Br$) and demonstrates the necessity of accounting for these changes in attosecond science.

Methodology

The research team employed a combination of experimental measurements and a refined theoretical framework.

Experimental Setup

Molecules of $CH_3F$ and $CH_3Br$ were aligned and oriented in a supersonic helium expansion using impulsive techniques. Alignment was achieved with a single-color 800 nm pulse, while orientation was induced using a two-color (800 + 400 nm) pulse. These prepared molecules were then probed with intense laser pulses at various wavelengths (800 nm, 1275 nm, or 1330 nm) to generate high-harmonic spectra. The primary observables were the intensity ratios of emission from aligned versus unaligned molecules and the ratios of even to odd harmonic orders.

Theoretical Framework

The authors developed a "full theory" that moves beyond the field-free assumption by incorporating the laser field into the three steps of HHS: ionization, propagation, and recombination. Specifically, they generalized the Weak-Field Asymptotic Theory (WFAT) for tunneling ionization to include the linear Stark effect. This inclusion accounts for how the external electric field lifts the degeneracy of the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) and mixes its spatial components, fundamentally reshaping the electronic ground state of the molecular cation.

Results and Discussion

The experimental results clearly demonstrate the failure of the field-free model for polar molecules.

Experimental and calculated high-harmonic spectroscopy data for CH3F and CH3Br. Panels (a-d) show normalized intensity vs. pump-probe delay for specific harmonics. Panels (e-f) show calculated alignment parameters. Panels (g-h) show aligned-to-isotropic intensity ratios across photon energies.

Alignment-Induced Modulation Reversal

In $CH_3Br$, the experimental ratio of emission from aligned versus anti-aligned molecules showed a reversal at harmonic 11 (H11, ~17 eV). Traditional field-free theory incorrectly predicted this reversal would occur at 24 eV. In contrast, the "full theory" incorporating the Stark effect matched the experimental 17 eV reversal precisely. This reversal is visible in the aligned-to-isotropic intensity ratios shown in the figure.

Even-to-Odd Harmonic Ratios

For oriented $CH_3F$, a significant increase in the even-to-odd harmonic intensity ratio was observed between H10 and H14. While field-free theory predicted a near-zero ratio, the full theory quantitatively reproduced the experimental curve, assuming a realistic degree of molecular orientation (~21.5%).

Robustness of the Stark Effect

The observed modifications were found to be independent of the driving laser's intensity and wavelength (tested at 800 nm, 1275 nm, and 1330 nm). This consistency confirms that the effects are driven by the linear Stark effect on the ground state rather than interference from electronically excited states.

Conclusion

This work proves that the strong electric field of a probe laser fundamentally reshapes the electronic structure of polar polyatomic molecules by lifting orbital degeneracy and mixing spatial components. Neglecting these laser-induced modifications leads to significant errors in predicting molecular behavior. As attosecond spectroscopy continues to evolve, incorporating these field-induced distortions will be essential for the accurate study of complex chemical dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

All attosecond time-resolved measurements have so far relied on the use of intense near-infrared laser pulses. In particular, attosecond streaking, laser-induced electron diffraction and high-harmonic generation all make use of non-perturbative light-matter interactions. Remarkably, the effect of the strong laser field on the studied sample has often been neglected in previous studies. Here we use high-harmonic spectroscopy to measure laser-induced modifications of the electronic structure of molecules. We study high-harmonic spectra of spatially oriented CH3F and CH3Br as generic examples of polar polyatomic molecules. We accurately measure intensity ratios of even and odd-harmonic orders, and of the emission from aligned and unaligned molecules. We show that these robust observables reveal a substantial modification of the molecular electronic structure by the external laser field. Our insights offer new challenges and opportunities for a range of emerging strong-field attosecond spectroscopies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kraus2015observation,
  author = {Peter M. Kraus and Oleg I. Tolstikhin and Denitsa Baykusheva and Alisa Rupenyan and J. Schneider and Christer Z. Bisgaard and Tōru Morishita and Frank Jensen and Lars Bojer Madsen and Hans Jakob Wörner},
  title = {{Observation of laser-induced electronic structure in oriented polyatomic molecules}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1038/ncomms8039},
}
Figure