Ionization Suppression of Diatomic Molecules in Intense Midinfrared Laser Field

Zhijie Lin, X. Y. Jia, C. Wang, Zhe Hu, H. Kang, Wei Quan, XuanYang Lai, Xiaocheng Liu, Jin-Jian Chen, B. Zeng, Wei Chu, Jinping Yao, Ya Cheng, Zhenzhu XuarXiv 2011 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have finally pinpointed why certain molecules, like oxygen ($O_2$), are much harder to ionize with intense lasers than atoms with similar energy requirements. By pushing experiments into the mid-infrared (2000 nm) regime, they demonstrated that this "ionization suppression" is driven by destructive interference between electron waves escaping from different nuclei—a phenomenon known as two-center interference.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of strong-field physics, "ionization" is the fundamental process where an intense laser pulse rips an electron away from an atom or molecule. Curiously, diatomic molecules often show a "suppressed" ionization rate compared to their "companion atoms" (atoms with nearly identical ionization potentials). For instance, $O_2$ ionizes much less easily than Xenon ($Xe$), even though they require almost the same amount of energy to lose an electron.

While several models existed to explain this—ranging from electron screening to tunneling theories—there was no consensus. Most previous studies were limited to near-infrared wavelengths (800 nm), where complex resonance effects can muddy the waters. The authors of this paper sought to clarify the mechanism by moving to the mid-infrared regime, where "tunnel ionization" is the dominant, cleaner process.

Methods

The team combined high-precision experimental measurements with advanced theoretical modeling:

  • Experimental: They used a wavelength-tunable mid-infrared femtosecond laser system (an Optical Parametric Amplifier) to compare ionization yields at 800 nm and 2000 nm. They measured the ion signals of $O_2$ vs. $Xe$ and $N_2$ vs. $Ar$ using a standard time-of-flight (TOF) mass spectrometer.
  • Theoretical: They employed S-matrix theory to calculate ionization rates. To represent the molecules, they used the LCAO-MO (Linear Combination of Atomic Orbitals - Molecular Orbital) approximation. This allowed them to specifically isolate the "trigonometric term" that represents interference between the two nuclear centers of the diatomic molecule.

Datasets

The study relies on original experimental data:

  • Ion Yield Curves: Measured for $O_2^+$, $Xe^+$, $N_2^+$, and $Ar^+$ as a function of laser intensity ($10^{13}$ to $10^{14}$ W/cm²).
  • Wavelength Comparison: Data sets for both 800 nm (near-infrared) and 2000 nm (mid-infrared).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Symmetry Secret: The suppression isn't universal. $O_2$ shows strong suppression, but $N_2$ behaves almost exactly like its companion atom, Argon. The difference lies in the symmetry of their outermost electrons (HOMO). $O_2$ has an antibonding ($\pi_g$) symmetry, while $N_2$ has a mix of bonding and antibonding orbitals that effectively cancel out the suppression effect.
  • Two-Center Interference: For $O_2$, the electron can be thought of as being ejected from two different nuclei simultaneously. Because of the antibonding symmetry, the electron waves from these two centers interfere destructively, making it harder for the electron to escape.
  • Wavelength Matters: Suppression is actually less pronounced at longer wavelengths (2000 nm) compared to shorter ones (800 nm). This is because longer wavelengths result in higher electron momenta, which reduces the "completeness" of the destructive interference.
  • Intensity Scaling: The ratio of $O_2/Xe$ ionization increases linearly with laser intensity ($\propto I$). The authors found that this scaling is a combined result of the interference effect and the specific nature of the atomic orbitals involved ($2p$ for oxygen vs. $5p$ for xenon).

Key Results

  • Validation of S-Matrix Theory: The S-matrix calculations successfully reproduced the experimental observations, including the linear intensity dependence. This outperformed the popular MO-ADK model, which incorrectly predicts a square-root dependence ($\sqrt{I}$).
  • Quantifying Suppression: At 2000 nm, the ionization of $O_2$ is significantly suppressed compared to $Xe$, but the gap closes as intensity increases.
  • $N_2$ as a "Structureless Atom": The ratio of $N_2^+/Ar^+$ remained near 1.0 across all tested intensities and wavelengths, confirming that $N_2$ does not experience significant ionization suppression in these regimes.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors noted a "perceptible discrepancy" between theory and experiment at very low laser intensities. They attribute this to resonance effects (specifically Freeman resonances), which occur when the laser intensity is low enough that the process is better described by multiphoton ionization rather than pure tunneling. The S-matrix model used here ignores these resonances.

Future research could involve extending these mid-infrared studies to even more complex polyatomic molecules or using these "interfering" electrons as a probe to image molecular orbitals in real-time.

Summary updated

Abstract

Diatomic molecules (e.g., O$_2$) in intense laser field exhibit a peculiar suppressed ionization behavior compared to their companion atoms. Several physical models have been proposed to account for this suppression while no consensus has been achieved. In this letter, we aim to clarify the underlying mechanisms behind this molecular ionization suppression. Experimental data recorded at midinfrared laser wavelength and its comparison with that at near-infrared wavelength revealed a peculiar wavelength and intensity dependence of the suppressed ionization of O$_2$ with respect to its companion atom of Xe, while N$_2$ behaves like a structureless atom. It is found that the S-matrix theory calculation can reproduce well the experimental observations and unambiguously identifies the significant role of two-center interference effect in the ionization suppression of O$_2$.
BibTeX
@misc{lin2011ionization,
  author = {Zhijie Lin and X. Y. Jia and C. Wang and Zhe Hu and H. Kang and Wei Quan and XuanYang Lai and Xiaocheng Liu and Jin-Jian Chen and B. Zeng and Wei Chu and Jinping Yao and Ya Cheng and Zhenzhu Xu},
  title = {{Ionization Suppression of Diatomic Molecules in Intense Midinfrared Laser Field}},
  year = {2011},
  eprint = {1111.3206},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1111.3206},
}
Figure