Imaging superatomic molecular orbitals in a <font>C</font>60 molecule through four 800-nm photons

G. P. Zhang, Heng Zhu, Y. H. Bai, Jason Bonacum, Xiao Wu, Thomas F. George

TL;DR

This paper provides a theoretical explanation for the observed anisotropic photoelectron images from C<sub>60</sub> molecules excited by 800-nm lasers, attributing them to the excitation of the anisotropic 1f superatomic molecular orbital (SAMO). The authors predict that four 800-nm photons can access this orbital, offering a new pathway for imaging these complex structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fullerenes, particularly C<sub>60</sub>, are fascinating molecules with unique electronic properties due to their high symmetry and delocalized electrons. These properties make them promising building blocks for advanced nanostructures. Within C<sub>60</sub>, researchers have identified "superatomic molecular orbitals" (SAMOs), which are essentially larger, more diffuse versions of atomic orbitals. While these SAMOs are theoretically interesting, experimentally imaging them in the gas phase has proven challenging.

Recent experiments using velocity-map imaging (VMI) have observed a puzzling difference in photoelectron images when C<sub>60</sub> is excited by 800-nm versus 400-nm lasers. The 800-nm excitation yields an anisotropic image, while the 400-nm excitation produces an isotropic one. While some of this difference has been attributed to thermal ionization, more recent observations revealed distinct, non-diffuse features superimposed on the diffuse background in the 800-nm excitation, the origin of which remained a mystery. This paper aims to unravel the origin of these non-diffuse anisotropic images and propose a method for their direct imaging.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of first-principles computational methods, specifically density functional theory (DFT), to investigate the electronic structure of C<sub>60</sub> and the multiphoton excitation processes. They utilized two complementary approaches:

  • Basis function-based methods: Gaussian09 and VASP were used to calculate the energy gaps between different SAMOs and the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO). They explored the effect of various functionals and basis sets, including augmented basis sets and the use of fictitious hydrogen atoms to enhance basis set completeness.
  • Real grid mesh method: The Octopus code was used to perform calculations on a real-space grid, which offers a balanced treatment of SAMOs and non-SAMOs. This method was employed to obtain a more accurate estimate of the energy gap in the infinite sphere limit.

To understand the excitation dynamics, they computed the product of transition matrix elements for both two-photon (400-nm) and four-photon (800-nm) excitation processes. This involved integrating the product of Kohn-Sham wavefunctions and the dipole operator. Finally, they calculated the photoelectron angular distribution for the 1f SAMO to compare with experimental observations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • 1f SAMO as the source of anisotropy: The paper strongly suggests that the observed non-diffuse anisotropic photoelectron images from 800-nm excitation are a direct signature of the 1f superatomic molecular orbital.
  • Four-photon access to 1f SAMO: A key prediction is that four photons of 800-nm light have precisely the right cumulative energy to excite electrons from the HOMO to the 1f SAMO. This provides a specific, testable pathway for experimental observation.
  • Distinctive angular distribution: The theoretical calculation of the photoelectron angular distribution for the 1f SAMO reveals two maxima at 0° and 180° and two humps separated by 56.5°. This unique signature is predicted to be observable in VMI experiments.
  • Explaining the 400-nm vs. 800-nm difference: The study proposes that two 400-nm photons primarily excite the spherical 1s SAMO, leading to an isotropic image. In contrast, four 800-nm photons preferentially excite the anisotropic 1f SAMO, resulting in the observed anisotropic image. This offers a natural explanation for the experimental observations, complementing existing theories.
  • Multiphoton excitation as a powerful tool: The research highlights the significant role of multiphoton excitation in boosting the transition probability to these high-lying superorbitals, suggesting it's a crucial technique for their investigation.

Key Results

  • The energy gap between the HOMO and the 1f SAMO is calculated to be approximately 6.2 eV, which precisely matches the four-photon energy of an 800-nm laser (4 x 2.07 eV = 8.28 eV, but the paper implies a different photon count or energy calculation, stating "four-photon energy of 800 nm" matches the gap. Re-reading suggests 4 photons of 800nm light are needed to reach the IP, and the 1f SAMO is accessed by 4 photons. The energy gap between HOMO and 1f SAMO is ~6.2eV, which matches the energy of 4 photons of 800nm light (4 * 1.55eV = 6.2eV)).
  • A peak at 0.2 eV kinetic energy for the ejected electron is predicted, corresponding to the ionization of the 1f SAMO.
  • For 400-nm excitation, the 1s SAMO is found to be nearly resonantly excited from HOMO-2, while non-SAMOs are off-resonance.
  • For 800-nm excitation, the 1f SAMO is strongly excited, with significant contributions from four-photon transitions.
  • The calculated photoelectron angular distribution for the 1f SAMO shows excellent agreement with recent experimental results, particularly in the shape and the separation of the two humps (56.5° theoretically vs. 54.4° experimentally).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Verification: The authors emphasize the need for future experimental verification of their predictions, particularly regarding the 0.2 eV photoelectron peak and the specific angular distribution of the 1f SAMO.
  • Density Functional Choice: The paper discusses the significant impact of different density functionals and basis sets on the calculated energy gaps. Further investigation into which functional and basis set combination most accurately describes these superorbitals is suggested.
  • Basis Set Effects: The study highlights that basis functions strongly affect the accuracy of SAMO energy levels, indicating that careful selection and potentially larger basis sets are crucial for precise calculations.
  • Laser Intensity Optimization: For future experiments aiming to observe SAMOs, careful optimization of laser intensity is recommended to avoid populating unwanted non-SAMOs.
  • Other SAMOs: While the focus is on the 1f SAMO, the study briefly mentions the possibility of probing other SAMOs (2p, 3p, 1h) by tuning the laser wavelength, suggesting this as a future avenue.
  • Degeneracy of 1f SAMO: The paper acknowledges the challenge posed by the seven-fold degeneracy of the 1f SAMO and how spatial averaging might affect the observed image. However, they propose that differences in transition paths for each degenerate state may prevent complete washing out of the image.

Summary updated

Abstract

Superatomic molecular orbitals (SAMOs) in C 60 are ideal building blocks for functional nanostructures. However, imaging them spatially in the gas phase has been unsuccessful. It is found experimentally that if C 60 is excited by an 800-nm laser, the photoelectron casts an anisotropic velocity image, but the image becomes isotropic if excited at a 400-nm wavelength. This diffuse image difference has been attributed to electron thermal ionization, but more recent experiments (800 nm) reveal a clear nondiffuse image superimposed on the diffuse image, whose origin remains a mystery. Here we show that the nondiffuse anisotropic image is the precursor of the f SAMOs. We predict that four 800-nm photons can directly access the 1f SAMO, and with one more photon, can image the orbital, with the photoelectron angular distribution having two maxima at 0° and 180° and two humps separated by 56.5°. Since two 400-nm photons only resonantly excite the spherical 1s SAMO and four 800-nm photons excite the anisotropic 1f SAMO, our finding gives a natural explanation of the nondiffuse image difference, complementing the thermal scenario.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2015imaging,
  author = {G. P. Zhang and Heng Zhu and Y. H. Bai and Jason Bonacum and Xiao Wu and Thomas F. George},
  title = {{Imaging superatomic molecular orbitals in a <font>C</font><sub>60</sub> molecule through four 800-nm photons}},
  journal = {International Journal of Modern Physics B},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1142/s0217979215501155},
}
Figure