Generalized Short Path Algorithms: Towards Super-Quadratic Speedup over Markov Chain Search for Combinatorial Optimization

Shouvanik Chakrabarti, Dylan Herman, Guneykan Ozgul, Shuchen Zhu, Brandon Augustino, Tianyi Hao, Zichang He, Ruslan Shaydulin, Marco Pistoia

Abstract

We analyze generalizations of algorithms based on the short-path framework, originally proposed by Hastings and extended by Dalzell et al., to achieve super-Grover speedups for binary optimization problems. By replacing standard quantum mixers with operators derived from problem-specific Markov chains, we demonstrate that this framework can achieve super-quadratic speedups over classical optimization algorithms that search for the optimum by sampling from the stationary distribution of a Markov Chain. We apply this framework to variants of Max-Bisection, Maximum Independent Set, the Ising Model, and the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Model. Our results show that for random regular graphs of sufficiently high degree, these algorithms are asymptotically faster than the best rigorously proven classical runtimes. Furthermore, we identify settings where the algorithm is super-quadratically faster than any polynomial-time Gibbs sampler, unless NP = RP.

Introduction

Combinatorial optimization—the task of finding an optimal solution within a discrete, massive search space—is a fundamental challenge across finance, logistics, and physics. While Grover’s algorithm provides a well-known quadratic speedup over unstructured search, this advantage is often insufficient to overcome the practical overhead of fault-tolerant quantum computing. To achieve a meaningful "break-even" point against classical supercomputers, quantum algorithms must deliver speedups that exceed the quadratic limit.

Moreover, many practical problems are constrained (e.g., selecting exactly $k$ items). Standard quantum algorithms often struggle with these constraints, either by searching through invalid states or by using penalty terms that degrade performance. This research introduces a generalized short-path framework that respects problem constraints while delivering super-quadratic speedups over classical Markov Chain Search.

The Generalized Short Path Framework

The core of the proposed approach is an extension of the "Short Path" framework. Traditional adiabatic quantum computing often fails due to "avoided crossings"—bottlenecks where the gap between energy levels becomes exponentially small. The short-path method avoids these bottlenecks by "jumping" between Hamiltonians rather than evolving continuously.

Markov Chain Integration

Instead of using a generic transverse-field mixer (the Pauli-X operator), the algorithm utilizes the discriminant matrix of a Markov chain tailored to the specific problem. For example, Glauber dynamics are used for spin models, while transposition walks are employed for problems with fixed-weight constraints. This ensures the quantum walk remains within the feasible solution space.

The Two-Step Jump

The algorithm operates in two primary phases:

  1. The Short Jump: The system moves from the stationary distribution of the Markov chain to an intermediate "guiding state." This guiding state is designed to have a significantly higher overlap with the optimal solution than a uniform distribution.
  2. The Long Jump: Using fixed-point amplitude amplification, the algorithm leverages the guiding state to reach the actual optimal solution.

To prove the efficiency of these jumps, the researchers utilize functional inequalities from classical probability, specifically log-Sobolev and Poincaré inequalities. These tools allow for rigorous bounds on the runtime relative to the mixing time of the underlying classical Markov chain.

Applications and Benchmarking

The framework was evaluated against several well-known mathematical models and random graph ensembles:

  • Max-Bisection and MaxCut-Hamming: Evaluated using Erdős-Rényi random graphs.
  • Maximum Independent Set (Hardcore Model): Evaluated on random regular graphs.
  • Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) Model: A benchmark for unconstrained optimization in spin glasses.

Numerical simulations were performed on instances up to 30 qubits to validate the theoretical predictions. These simulations focused on the stability of $\Delta_P$, a measure of how smoothly the cost function changes across the Markov chain's edges. A smoother landscape allows the quantum algorithm to more effectively navigate toward the optimum.

Key Results and Insights

Super-Quadratic Speedups

The primary theoretical contribution is the proof of runtimes $O^*(T(n)^{0.5-c})$, where $T(n)$ is the classical Markov Chain Search time and $c > 0$. In several instances, $c$ is a constant, representing a breakthrough beyond the $0.5$ exponent of Grover-style search. For Max-Bisection on specific random graphs, a true super-quadratic speedup was achieved.

Resistance to Dequantization

A critical question in quantum algorithm design is whether a classical algorithm could simply replicate the quantum advantage (e.g., by sampling the guiding state). The authors provide evidence that for certain models, the quantum advantage is likely resistant to such "dequantization," suggesting the speedup is inherently quantum mechanical.

Practical Performance

Numerical results indicated that the algorithm often performs better than the conservative theoretical bounds suggest. Specifically, the optimal "jump" parameters ($b$) found in practice were significantly larger than those required for the rigorous proofs, suggesting the framework may be even more robust in real-world applications.

Conclusion and Future Work

This generalized short-path framework provides a path toward achieving super-quadratic speedups for constrained combinatorial optimization. By integrating classical Markov chain theory with quantum amplitude amplification, the algorithm respects problem structure while outperforming traditional search methods.

Future research will focus on extending these techniques to counting problems (estimating the number of solutions) and further refining the heuristics for parameter tuning. While the algorithm currently requires long-coherence, fault-tolerant hardware, it establishes a new theoretical benchmark for what quantum optimization can achieve beyond the Grover limit.

Summary updated

Abstract

We analyze generalizations of algorithms based on the short-path framework first proposed by Hastings [Quantum 2, 78 (2018)], which has been extended and shown by Dalzell et al. [STOC '22] to achieve super-Grover speedups for certain binary optimization problems. We demonstrate that, under some commonly satisfied technical conditions, an appropriate generalization can achieve super-quadratic speedups not only over unstructured search but also over a classical optimization algorithm that searches for the optimum by drawing samples from the stationary distribution of a Markov Chain. We employ this framework to obtain algorithms for problems including variants of Max-Bisection, Max Independent Set, the Ising Model, and the Sherrington Kirkpatrick Model, whose runtimes are asymptotically faster than those obtainable from previous short path techniques. For random regular graphs of sufficiently high degree, our algorithm is super-quadratically faster than the best rigorously proven classical runtimes for regular graphs. Our results also shed light on the quantum nature of short path algorithms, by identifying a setting where our algorithm is super-quadratically faster than any polynomial time Gibbs sampler, unless NP = RP. We conclude the paper with a numerical analysis that guides the choice of parameters for short path algorithms and raises the possibility of super-quadratic speedups in settings that are currently beyond our theoretical analysis.
BibTeX
@misc{chakrabarti2024generalized,
  author = {Shouvanik Chakrabarti and Dylan Herman and Guneykan Ozgul and Shuchen Zhu and Brandon Augustino and Tianyi Hao and Zichang He and Ruslan Shaydulin and Marco Pistoia},
  title = {{Generalized Short Path Algorithms: Towards Super-Quadratic Speedup over Markov Chain Search for Combinatorial Optimization}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2410.23270},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.23270},
}

Loading related content...

Figure