Experimental study on frost heave of high-speed railway subgrade in the seasonally frozen region

Guotao Yang, Hongye Yan, Degou Cai, Guotang Zhao, Jianping Yao, Chen FengJapanese 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Seasonally frozen regions are widely distributed across Northern China, where extensive high-speed railway networks have been constructed. The phenomena of seasonal frost heave and thaw settlement in subgrades present a significant challenge to the strict track irregularity standards required for high-speed operations. This study analyzes state detection and in-situ monitoring data from the 2012-2013 and 2013-2014 winter periods to identify the typical rules governing subgrade deformation. The research characterizes frost depth development into two primary stages—steadily rapid development and bi-directional thawing—and defines five distinct stages of frost heave deformation. These findings provide critical technical support for the construction, operation, and maintenance of high-speed railways in severely cold climates.

Introduction

High-speed railways require exceptional track smoothness to ensure safety at high velocities. In seasonally frozen regions, the ground undergoes "frost heave" (upward expansion as soil moisture freezes) during winter and "thaw settlement" (sinking as ice melts) in spring. This freeze-thaw cycle warps the railway subgrade, creating track irregularities. Understanding the precise spatio-temporal mechanics of how engineered railway subgrades respond to these cycles compared to natural soil is vital for maintaining infrastructure integrity in cold climates.

Methodology and Data

Researchers implemented an automated, in-situ field monitoring system along a high-speed railway line in Northeast China. The study tracked real-world subgrade temperatures, frost depths, and physical deformations over two consecutive winter periods (2012-2013 and 2013-2014). By correlating atmospheric temperature fluctuations with ground displacement, the team mapped the evolution of the subgrade throughout the freeze-thaw cycle. The engineered subgrade's frost depth was also compared against the natural frost depth of the surrounding local soil to identify the impact of railway construction materials on thermal conductivity.

Characterizing the Frost Heave Cycle

The study identifies that the freeze-thaw cycle follows five distinct phases rather than a simple binary transition:

  1. Initial Fluctuation: Minor deformations occurring as temperatures hover around 0°C.
  2. Rapid Progress: Sharp temperature drops leading to fast heave development.
  3. Slow/Sustainable Progress: Deep freezing accompanied by stable, sustained heave.
  4. Fluctuated Thaw Settlement: Surface melting while deep soil remains frozen, trapping water and causing unstable settlement.
  5. Steady Thaw Settlement: Full melting of the frozen layer and final residual deformation.
The five stages of subgrade frost heave deformation correlated with atmospheric temperature and frost depth.

Frost Depth and Thawing Mechanics

A key finding is that engineered subgrades freeze significantly deeper than surrounding natural soil—typically 1.2 to 1.6 times deeper. This is attributed to the high thermal conductivity and lower water content of engineered filling materials. Furthermore, when spring arrives, the subgrade experiences "bi-directional thawing." The surface melts due to rising air temperatures while the deep frost line simultaneously rises from below as the ground warms from the bottom up.

Evolution of frost depth over time, illustrating the sustained development and bi-directional melting stages across multiple monitoring sites.

Key Results

  • Critical Layer: The graded crushed rock layer in the upper subgrade is the primary source of deformation, accounting for approximately 65% to 68% of total frost heave.
  • Thermal Multiplier: The maximum frost depth in the engineered subgrade averaged a 1.4x multiplier over natural soil in 2012-2013 and 1.2x in 2013-2014.
  • Geographic and Climatic Factors: Frost depth increases linearly with latitude. Additionally, the severity of the winter dictates heave magnitude; the milder 2013-2014 winter saw an average maximum frost depth 24 cm less than the previous year.
  • Maximum Recorded Depth: The study recorded an absolute maximum frost depth of 300 cm at a specific monitoring station, highlighting the extreme conditions these tracks must withstand.

Conclusion

This research identifies the graded crushed rock layer as the critical failure point for track irregularity due to frost heave. While the study provides a robust framework for understanding these cycles over two years, future research will focus on the specific freeze-thaw mechanisms and material properties of graded aggregates to develop more effective physical mitigation strategies for high-speed rail infrastructure.

Summary updated

Abstract

Most of seasonally frozen regions are widely distributed in the northern part of China; a lot of high-speed railways have been built in these regions. Due to the seasonally frost Most of seasonally frozen regions are widely distributed in the northern part of China; a lot of high-speed railways have been built in these regions. Due to the seasonally frost heave and thaw settlement phenomena in the subgrade, the irregularity problem of railway lines will occur; this will become a great challenge to the strict control standard of Chinese high-speed railway. Based on the state detection of high-speed railway track and the in-situ monitoring of subgrade frost heave deformation condition in 2012-2013 and 2013-2014 periods, the typically rules of frost heave and thaw settlement in high-speed railway subgrade in the seasonally frozen region have been found out. Take a high-speed railway in the seasonally frozen region as an example, the frost depth of subgrade can be divided into two stages, the steadily rapid development stage and the two-direction thaw stage. The relationship between the in-situ detected engineering frost depth and the latitude,the frozen index and the naturally frost depth have been achieved. The amount of subgrade frost heave in winter is relatively low, and the distributed area is relatively narrow. The whole process of frost heave can be divided into five typically stages: the initially fluctuation stage, the rapidly developed stage, the gently developed stage, the fluctuated thaw settlement stage and the thaw settlement deformation stage. The spatio-temporal changing laws of frost heave deformation in each stage and the relationship to the foundation structure, the characteristics of filling material and the moisture condition have been pointed out. The frozen-thaw features of high-speed railway subgrade and the comparison results between two winter periods have provided important technology support to the construction, the operation and the maintenance of high-speed railway in the severely cold region.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2016experimental,
  author = {Guotao Yang and Hongye Yan and Degou Cai and Guotang Zhao and Jianping Yao and Chen Feng},
  title = {{Experimental study on frost heave of high-speed railway subgrade in the seasonally frozen region}},
  booktitle = {Japanese},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3208/jgssp.chn-32},
}
Figure