Evaluation Method of Frost Heave for Unsaturated Soils

Jae‐Mo Kang, Young‐Seok Kim, Jangguen LeeJournal of the Korean Geosynthetic Society 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Frost heave occurs when ground temperature decreases under $0^{\circ}C$ and soil volume expands, which causes roadway and buried pipe line failure due to differential heaving. There are several models to predict volumetric strain caused by frost heave, but they often require expertise in complex numerical analysis. This study presents an evaluation method to predict volumetric strain caused by frost heave using fundamental physical properties of soils. The evaluation method is assessed and validated through comparison with experimental results.

Introduction

As infrastructure projects extend into extreme environments like Siberia and the Antarctic, engineers must contend with the destructive force of frost heave. When soil temperatures drop below freezing, pore water turns to ice, expanding in volume. This expansion leads to "differential heaving," which can buckle roadways and snap buried pipelines. While sophisticated numerical models exist, they are often "black boxes" requiring advanced geotechnical expertise. This paper proposes a simplified calculation method based on standard soil properties—such as water content and porosity—to bridge the gap between high-level research and practical field application.

Theoretical Framework: Multi-Phase Soil Modeling

The proposed method models soil as a multi-phase system to track volume changes accurately. In its initial unsaturated state, the soil is treated as a four-phase system consisting of air, water, soil grains, and any added anti-frost materials.

Initial four-phase system of unsaturated soil including anti-frost materials.

Upon freezing, the system transitions into a five-phase model. This model explicitly accounts for the fact that not all water freezes simultaneously; it distinguishes between frozen water (ice) and unfrozen water ($w_u$), which remains liquid even below $0^{\circ}C$.

Five-phase system model of frozen soil used for frost heave calculation, showing volume (V) and weight (W) components.

The calculation framework establishes two predictive boundaries:

  • Lower Bound Expansion: Assumes that as ice forms, it first fills existing air voids. Expansion only occurs once the ice volume exceeds the available air space.
  • Upper Bound Expansion: Assumes air is incompressible or that ice formation immediately contributes to total volume increase, providing a conservative estimate for engineering safety.

Experimental Validation

The model was validated using a Silty-Sand (SM) soil in a "closed-system" frost heave cell. Samples were compacted to 90% and frozen to -12.5°C in a specialized chamber. Key findings include:

  • Unfrozen Water Sensitivity: The unfrozen water content ($w_u$) stabilized at approximately 11% at -6°C for the tested soil. The researchers found that ignoring this value leads to a significant overestimation of frost heave.
  • Moisture Impact: Frost heave is highly sensitive to initial moisture. For the SM soil tested, a 3% increase in moisture content above the optimum led to a 1.3% increase in the frost heave ratio.
  • Predictive Accuracy: Measured volumetric strains (ranging from 0.4% to 2.8%) consistently fell within the bounds predicted by the model, particularly when using the measured $w_u$ value to bracket the results.

Conclusion

This study provides a practical tool for estimating frost heave using basic laboratory data like wet unit weight, porosity, and specific gravity. By utilizing the "Upper Bound" calculation with known unfrozen water content, engineers can obtain reliable, conservative estimates for infrastructure design in freezing environments without requiring specialized numerical simulation software. Future work will focus on expanding the model to include fine-grained clays and "open-system" conditions where groundwater recharge can lead to even greater expansion.

Summary updated

Abstract

동결 지반에서 발생하는 동상(frost heave)은 지반의 부등융기를 야기하고, 이때 발생하는 동결하중에 의해 동절기 도로 및 기초 구조물에 피해를 가져온다. 이러한 동결 피해를 방지하기 위해 동상 예측이 필요하다. 대부분의 동상 예측 방법은 경험과 지식을 갖춘 전문가의 수치해석에 의존하고 있어 현장에서 활용성이 낮다. 본 논문에서는 동결지반 피해의 주요 원인인 지반의 동상량을 예측하기 위해 기본적인 지반 물성 데이터를 이용해 동상량을 계산할 수 있는 방안을 제시하였으며, 실내 동상 실험결과와의 비교 분석을 통해 제안된 계산식의 신뢰성을 검토하였다. Frost heave occurs when ground temperature decreases under <TEX>$0^{\circ}C$</TEX> and soil volume expands, which causes roadway and buried pipe line failure due to differential heaving. There are several models to predict volumetric strain caused by frost heave, but they requires expertises who have professional background and experience related to numerical analysis. This study presents an evaluation method to predict volumetric strain caused by frost heave with fundamental physical properties of soils. The evaluation method is assessed with experimental results.
BibTeX
@article{kang2013evaluation,
  author = {Jae‐Mo Kang and Young‐Seok Kim and Jangguen Lee},
  title = {{Evaluation Method of Frost Heave for Unsaturated Soils}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korean Geosynthetic Society},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.12814/jkgss.2013.12.1.093},
}
Figure