Study on the electric resistance method in crack depth measurements

Jiahui Gu, Liang Chen, Yu Wan, Yaozong Teng, Shufa Yan, Liang Hu, Jiahao Wang, Hanxuan LuoFrontiers in Earth Science 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Obtaining geometric parameters, especially depth, and describing the morphological characteristics of cracks are of great significance to control engineering disasters and accidents caused by cracks. The electric resistance method is based on the principle of differences in electrical properties between cracks and soil, which could be used to measure the single crack depth at project sites. There exists an $R_{min}$ value corresponding to a specific electrode distance $d$ value at each $R_f - d$ value obtained by laboratory experiments. Furthermore, a two-dimensional finite element model of soil with a single crack is established to carry out numerical simulation analysis considering the crack width $W$, crack depth $D$ and complex crack conditions. The results reveal dynamic variation rules of soil resistance after crack development, and for each $R_f - d$ value, the electrode distance $d$ value corresponding to the $R_{min}$ value is approximately equal to the crack depth $D$. In the range of the electric field, the offset and rotation of the crack have little effect, while the measurement results have a strong dependence on relocation movement. The regulation gives guidance to the inversion analysis of crack depth $D$ at project sites and has been applied in crack depth measurements of an expansive soil slope. The electric resistance method as a proposed integrated approach is of great significance and brings new perspectives into the study of crack depth measurements for field applications.

Introduction

Cracks in expansive soils are a major challenge for civil engineers, as they weaken soil integrity, accelerate rainwater infiltration, and often lead to landslides and foundation failures. Despite their critical impact, measuring the depth of these cracks in real-time is difficult. Traditional methods like X-ray CT or ultrasonic testing are often too expensive or impractical for field use. This paper proposes a portable, non-destructive electrical resistance method that identifies a "golden rule" for crack measurement: the electrode distance that yields the minimum resistance value is approximately equal to the actual crack depth ($d \approx D$).

Methodology

The researchers employed a three-pronged approach to validate this method:

Laboratory Experiments

Using expansive soil from China’s South-to-North Water Diversion project, the team built a physical model. They utilized a four-electrode measurement system with an AC constant current to avoid the instability issues common with DC measurements.

Schematic of the four-electrode method showing current flow through the medium.

The laboratory setup involved measuring resistance across simulated cracks of varying depths within a controlled soil sample to observe how resistance changed with electrode spacing.

Laboratory soil sample setup for measuring resistance across a simulated crack.

Numerical Simulation

A 2D Finite Element Method (FEM) model was developed using COMSOL Multiphysics. This allowed the researchers to isolate variables that are difficult to control in the lab, such as crack width ($W$), crack rotation, and the horizontal "offset" of the crack relative to the electrodes.

Field Application

To validate the findings, the equipment was deployed to a real expansive soil slope in Jiangsu Province, where electrical measurements were compared against physical drilling results.

Data and Parameters

The study utilized several key data sources:

  • Physical Soil Data: Mineral composition and properties (Montmorillonite, Illite, etc.) of the expansive clay.
  • Experimental Resistance Logs: Records of resistance values ($\Omega$) across five electrode distances (6cm to 36cm) and seven crack depths (0cm to 10cm).
  • Field Survey Profiles: Data from 13 measurement sections on a landslide-prone slope.

Key Insights and Discussion

  • The $R_{min}$ Phenomenon: The most significant finding is that for any given crack, varying the electrode distance ($d$) produces a U-shaped resistance curve. The point of minimum resistance ($R_{min}$) occurs when the electrode distance almost perfectly matches the crack depth ($D$).
  • Width Independence: Numerical simulations showed that crack width ($W$) has almost no impact on the resistance measurement once the crack is formed, making the method robust for field work.
  • Geometric Robustness: The method is resilient to crack rotation and minor horizontal offsets. However, accuracy drops if the crack moves significantly away from the center of the electrode array (relocation).
  • The S-Curve of Resistance: As a crack grows deeper, the logarithm of the resistance ratio ($N_r$) follows an S-shaped curve, rising quickly before slowing down as the crack depth exceeds the electric field range.

Field Validation and Conclusion

In laboratory settings, the $d \approx D$ rule held true across multiple testing pairs. When applied to the Jiangsu slope, the electrical resistance method identified crack depths between 1.0m and 1.5m, which were subsequently verified by drilling.

While the method is highly effective for single cracks, future work must address complex 3D crack networks and soil heterogeneity, such as varying moisture levels. The development of sophisticated mathematical inversion algorithms will further improve the method's accuracy in diverse field conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Obtaining geometric parameters, especially depth, and describing the morphological characteristics of cracks are of great significance to control engineering disasters and accidents caused by cracks. The electric resistance method is based on the principle of differences in electrical properties between cracks and soil, which could be used to measure the single crack depth at project sites. There exists an R min value corresponding to a specific electrode distance d value at each R f - d value obtained by laboratory experiments. Furthermore, a two-dimensional finite element model of soil with a single crack is established to carry out numerical simulation analysis considering the crack width W , crack depth D and complex crack conditions. The results reveal dynamic variation rules of soil resistance after crack development, and for each R f - d value, the electrode distance d value corresponding to the R min value is approximately equal to the crack depth D . In the range of the electric field, the offset and rotation of the crack have little effect, while the measurement results have a strong dependence on relocation movement. The regulation gives guidance to the inversion analysis of crack depth D at project sites and has been applied in crack depth measurements of an expansive soil slope. The electric resistance method as a proposed integrated approach is of great significance and brings new perspectives into the study of crack depth measurements for field applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gu2023study,
  author = {Jiahui Gu and Liang Chen and Yu Wan and Yaozong Teng and Shufa Yan and Liang Hu and Jiahao Wang and Hanxuan Luo},
  title = {{Study on the electric resistance method in crack depth measurements}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2023.1082854},
}
Figure