Analysis of the Relationship between Unconfined Compression Strength and Shear Strength of Frozen Soils

Jae‐Mo Kang, Jangguen Lee, Joonyong Lee, Young Seok KimJournal of the Korean Geosynthetic Society 2013 · DOI

Abstract

동결토는 물과 얼음의 상변화에 따라 일반적인 흙과는 다른 거동을 보이며, 동결토의 강도는 온도, 함수비, 시간, 토질 특성 등 다양한 인자에 의해 영향을 받는다. 특히 지반이 동결되는 경우, 얼음과 흙 입자의 결합력에 의해 높은 강도 특성을 보이며, 이때의 전단강도는 흙의 구조적 결합에 영향을 미치는 얼음과 세립분의 함량에 따라 달라지며, 이로 인해 점착력이 동결토의 전단강도에 미치는 영향은 증가한다. 본 논문에서는 동결조건에서 직접전단시험과 일축압축강도시험을 실시하여 온도에 따른 흙의 강도 특성을 확인하였으며, 점착력과 일축압축강도와의 상관관계를 확인하였다.

The mechanical behavior of frozen soils is different from that of unfrozen soils due to the phase change between water and ice. The strength characteristics of frozen soils are governed by intrinsic material properties and externally imposed testing conditions. In this study, direct shear tests and unconfined compression tests were carried out inside a large-scale freezing chamber to discuss the relationships between cohesion and unconfined compression strength under various freezing temperature conditions.

Introduction

As global interest in cold-region construction grows—driven by projects like the Jang Bogo Antarctic Research Station and Siberian gas pipelines—engineers face the challenge of designing stable foundations in permafrost. Frozen soil behaves differently than unfrozen soil because the ice acts as a bonding agent, significantly increasing strength but also making it highly sensitive to temperature and moisture.

In traditional soil mechanics, the shear strength of unfrozen clay is often estimated as half of its unconfined compressive strength ($c \approx q_u/2$). However, it was previously unclear if this rule of thumb holds for frozen weathered granite soil, a common soil type in Korea. This study seeks to determine if simple unconfined compression tests can reliably predict the more complex shear strength parameters needed for engineering design in sub-zero environments.

Methods and Materials

The researchers conducted experimental testing on weathered granite soil collected from the Gwanak Mountain area near Seoul National University. The soil is classified as well-graded sand (SW) with a 5% fine content and a specific gravity of 2.67.

Key aspects of the methodology included:

  • Sample Preparation: All samples were prepared with a 15.5% water content and 76% relative density.
  • Testing Conditions: Tests were conducted at three specific freezing temperatures: -5°C, -10°C, and -15°C, using a large-scale freezing chamber.
  • Comparative Testing: The team performed Direct Shear Tests (DST) to measure cohesion and internal friction angles, and Unconfined Compression Tests (UCT) to measure peak compressive strength.
  • Standardization: A fixed displacement rate was used (0.5 mm/min for shear and 1 mm/min for compression) to maintain consistency across tests.

Results and Discussion

The strength of frozen soil is primarily governed by the "ice binding capacity." As temperature decreases, the ice becomes stiffer and the bond between soil particles and the ice matrix strengthens, leading to a linear increase in both compressive and shear strength.

Shear stress versus vertical effective stress at various freezing temperatures.

As shown in Figure 3, the shear strength envelopes shift upward as the temperature drops. The cohesion ($c$), represented by the intercept on the shear stress axis, nearly doubled from 1,247.2 kPa at -5°C to 2,708.9 kPa at -15°C. The internal friction angle of the frozen soil was found to be relatively small compared to unfrozen sand, confirming that cohesion (ice bonding) is the dominant factor in frozen soil strength.

The study specifically evaluated the accuracy of using $q_u/2$ as a predictor for cohesion.

Comparison of unconfined compressive strength and shear strength parameters at -10°C.

Figure 5 illustrates the relationship between the axial stress-strain curve and the shear strength parameters at -10°C. The researchers found that while unconfined compression tests tend to overestimate shear strength, the correlation improves as temperatures drop:

  • At -5°C: Cohesion ($c$) = 1,247 kPa; $q_u/2$ = 1,661 kPa (25% error).
  • At -15°C: Cohesion ($c$) = 2,709 kPa; $q_u/2$ = 3,097 kPa (13% error).

The presence of even a small amount of fine particles (5%) significantly influences this relationship. In pure sands, the discrepancy is typically high (~40%), but in this weathered granite soil, the error was much lower, suggesting that fines make the soil behave more like a cohesive medium where $q_u/2$ is a better predictor.

Conclusion

While $q_u/2$ overestimates strength (making it a non-conservative estimate), it remains a useful practical method for preliminary design in permafrost regions where complex shear testing is difficult. The correlation between unconfined compression and shear strength improves as the soil gets colder, reaching an error margin of only 13% at -15°C. Future work should aim to refine these correlation factors for a wider variety of soil types and moisture conditions to enhance the safety and efficiency of cold-region infrastructure.

Summary updated

Abstract

동결토는 물과 얼음의 상변화에 따라 일반적인 흙과는 다른 거동을 보이며, 동결토의 강도는 온도, 함수비, 시간, 토질 특성 등 다양한 인자에 의해 영향을 받는다. 특히 지반이 동결되는 경우, 얼음과 흙 입자의 결합력에 의해 높은 강도 특성을 보이며, 이때의 전단강도는 흙의 구조적 결합에 영향을 미치는 얼음과 세립분의 함량에 따라 달라지며, 이로 인해 점착력이 동결토의 전단강도에 미치는 영향은 증가한다. 본 논문에서는 동결조건에서 직접전단시험과 일축압축강도시험을 실시하여 온도에 따른 흙의 강도 특성을 확인하였으며, 점착력과 일축압축강도와의 상관관계를 확인하였다. The mechanical behavior of frozen soils is different from that of unfrozen soils due to the phase change between water and ice. The strength characteristics of frozen soils are governed by the intrinsic material properties such as grain size, ice and water content, air bubbles, and by externally imposed testing conditions such as temperature, freezing time, and strain rate. Especially, the strength of the frozen soils is generally higher than that of unfrozen soils due to ice binding capacity with soil particles, and is strongly affected by a highly complex interaction between the solid soil skeleton and the pore matrix, composed of ice and unfrozen water. In this study, the direct shear test and unconfined compression test are carried out inside of a large-scaled freezing chamber, and the relationships between cohesion and unconfined compression strength under various freezing temperature conditions are discussed.
BibTeX
@article{kang2013analysis,
  author = {Jae‐Mo Kang and Jangguen Lee and Joonyong Lee and Young Seok Kim},
  title = {{Analysis of the Relationship between Unconfined Compression Strength and Shear Strength of Frozen Soils}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korean Geosynthetic Society},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.12814/jkgss.2013.12.3.023},
}
Figure