Thermal Conductivity of Saturated Unfrozen Kaolinite during Consolidation

Hak-Seung Kim, Jangguen Lee, Jae‐Mo Kang, Young Seok Kim, Seungseo HongThe Journal of Engineering Geology 2011 · DOI

Abstract

Experimental tests have been performed to measure the thermal conductivity of unsaturated soils, and computational models have been widely used to predict thermal conductivity. However, measured values of the thermal conductivity of unsaturated soils cannot be compared with predicted values because of the gradient in moisture content within unsaturated soils. In this study, experimental consolidation tests on saturated unfrozen kaolinite were performed to investigate the effect of dry density and moisture content on thermal conductivity. The results were used to evaluate the validity of a model employed to calculate thermal conductivity.

Introduction

Accurately predicting the thermal conductivity ($k$) of soil is essential for designing infrastructure in cold regions, such as foundations, roads, and pipelines. Engineers rely on these values to estimate frost depth and ground temperature distribution. However, measuring $k$ in unsaturated soils is notoriously difficult; the heat from measuring probes often causes moisture to migrate away from the sensor, creating a moisture gradient that introduces significant error into the results.

To address this challenge, this study focuses on saturated unfrozen kaolinite clay. By using saturated soil, the researchers eliminated the interference of moisture migration, allowing for a precise investigation into how dry density and moisture content influence thermal performance during the consolidation process.

Experimental Methodology

The researchers developed a specialized experimental setup that integrated a consolidation cell with a thermal needle probe. The material used was pure Kaolinite, classified as a high plasticity clay (CH).

Experimental setup for measuring thermal conductivity during consolidation.

A key innovation in this study was the use of continuous measurement. A needle probe (Quickline-30) was inserted into the clay specimen before the consolidation process began. This allowed the team to measure thermal conductivity at the conclusion of every loading stage—ranging from approximately 1.8 kPa to 696 kPa—without disturbing the soil structure between measurements. To ensure high precision, the probe maintained a length-to-diameter ratio of 40, keeping errors from axial heat flow below 1%.

Results and Model Comparison

The experimental results were compared against the Woodside and Messmer (1961) model, a theoretical framework that predicts the thermal conductivity of a mixture based on the volume fractions and conductivities of its components (soil particles and water). The thermal conductivity of the kaolinite mineral particles ($k_s$) was determined to be 2.54 W/mK.

Thermal conductivity vs. dry density for kaolinite samples C1 and C2 compared to the Woodside and Messmer model.

As the soil was consolidated and water was expelled, the dry density increased, leading to a corresponding increase in thermal conductivity. Measured values rose from approximately 0.96 W/mK at low density to 1.39 W/mK at the highest density.

The comparison with the Woodside and Messmer model revealed a distinct trend: while the model was highly accurate for "slurry-like" states where moisture content exceeded 80%, it began to diverge as the soil became more compact. At dry densities above 900 kg/m³, the model consistently underestimated the actual thermal conductivity by 4% to 7%.

Discussion and Conclusions

The study demonstrates that while traditional geometric models like Woodside and Messmer are effective for loose, high-moisture soils, they lose accuracy as soil particles become more tightly packed. The observed 4-7% discrepancy at higher densities suggests that the geometric assumptions of the model may not fully capture the thermal interactions in dense clay structures.

Future research will focus on expanding the density range beyond the 1186.2 kg/m³ reached in this study to see if the model's underestimation continues to grow. Additionally, testing different clay minerals and silts will help in developing a more robust, optimized prediction model for a wider variety of geotechnical engineering applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

지금까지 열전도계수는 불포화토를 대상으로 측정하였으며 측정결과를 토대로 예측 모델의 신뢰성을 연구해 왔다. 그러나 측정 장치의 발열로 인해 불포화토에서는 함수비 구배가 발생하여 열전도계수 측정에 오차가 발생한다. 본 연구에서는 포화된 점성토의 압밀에 따른 열전도계수를 연속적으로 측정하여 건조밀도와 함수비의 변화에 따른 열전도계수의 관계를 연구하였다. 열전도계수는 니들브로브로 측정하였으며 시료의 교란을 최소화하기 위해 니들브로브를 삽입한 상태에서 압밀실험을 진행하였다. 측정결과는 열전도계수 예측 모델을 이용한 결과와 비교를 통해 예측 모델의 신뢰성을 분석하였다. Experimental tests have been performed to measure the thermal conductivity of unsaturated soils, and computational models have been widely used to predict thermal conductivity. However, measured values of the thermal conductivity of unsaturated soils cannot be compared with predicted values because of the gradient in moisture content within unsaturated soils. In this study, experimental consolidation tests on saturated unfrozen kaolinite were performed to investigate the effect of dry density and moisture content on thermal conductivity. The results were used to evaluate the validity of a model employed to calculate thermal conductivity.
BibTeX
@article{kim2011thermal,
  author = {Hak-Seung Kim and Jangguen Lee and Jae‐Mo Kang and Young Seok Kim and Seungseo Hong},
  title = {{Thermal Conductivity of Saturated Unfrozen Kaolinite during Consolidation}},
  journal = {The Journal of Engineering Geology},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.9720/kseg.2011.21.2.157},
}
Figure