Dynamic resilient modulus of subgrade silty clay for heavy-haul railway: an experimental investigation and the predicted method

Jianwen Hao, Wang Hong-guo, Xiaoning Zhang, Tao Lin, Xiufeng Jiang, Congcong Liu, Xiangyang LiFrontiers in Earth Science 2023 · DOI

Introduction

Heavy-haul railways are essential for industrial logistics, supporting axle loads that significantly exceed those of standard rail systems. These massive loads generate intense cyclic stresses that penetrate deep into the subgrade—the soil foundation of the track. A critical parameter for ensuring track stability and preventing deformation is the dynamic resilient modulus ($M_R$), which measures the soil's ability to recover its shape after compression. This study investigates the behavior of silty clay, a common subgrade material, under the high-intensity loading conditions characteristic of heavy-haul operations.

Methodology and Data Collection

Researchers conducted a comprehensive series of cyclic triaxial tests to map the response of silty clay to various environmental and mechanical factors.

Map and site photo of the Datong–Qinhuangdao heavy-haul railway where silty clay samples were collected.

Soil samples were collected from the Datong–Qinhuangdao heavy-haul railway in China. The experimental design utilized a novel loading sequence specifically tailored to simulate the three-dimensional stress states induced by 400 kN axle loads. The study evaluated four primary variables across 108 distinct test conditions:

  • Deviatoric stress: Vertical pressure from the train load.
  • Confining stress: Lateral pressure from the surrounding soil matrix.
  • Initial moisture content: The degree of soil saturation.
  • Compaction degree: The density of the soil packing.

Predictive Modeling Approaches

To translate experimental data into engineering tools, two predictive methods were developed:

  1. Modified Empirical Model: An enhancement of the standard NCHRP 1–28A model, incorporating moisture and compaction variables to improve field applicability.
  2. GA-BP ANN: An Artificial Neural Network (ANN) utilizing Back-Propagation (BP) and optimized by a Genetic Algorithm (GA). The GA optimization helps the model avoid local minima, ensuring higher global accuracy.

Key Insights

The investigation revealed several critical relationships governing subgrade performance:

  • Moisture Sensitivity: Increasing moisture content from 9.8% to 15.8% resulted in a 27.79% decrease in $M_R$. This "softening" occurs as thicker water films reduce inter-particle friction.
  • Stress Dynamics: While increased vertical (deviatoric) stress reduces the modulus (averaging a 14.65% drop from 60 to 150 kPa), increased lateral (confining) stress improves it (averaging a 23.25% increase from 20 to 60 kPa).
  • Compaction Benefits: Improving the compaction degree from 0.91 to 0.95 increased the modulus by 27.48%, as denser soil structures provide a sturdier skeleton against deformation.

Results and Practical Application

Both models demonstrated exceptional predictive capabilities. The Modified Empirical Model achieved an $R^2$ of 0.94, while the GA-BP ANN model reached an $R^2$ of 0.99. These high correlation coefficients indicate that the models can reliably predict subgrade stiffness under diverse conditions. Furthermore, the researchers developed a Graphical User Interface (GUI) to allow engineers to perform these complex calculations efficiently during the design phase.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the current models provide a robust framework for silty clay subgrades, the authors note that future research should incorporate long-term environmental factors such as freeze-thaw cycles and wetting-drying periods. Expanding the dataset to include other soil types would also broaden the utility of these predictive tools for global railway infrastructure.

Summary updated

Abstract

A large-scale series of cyclic triaxial tests were conducted to explore the evolution of the dynamic resilient modulus of silty clay for the heavy-haul railway subgrade. A novel loading sequence for measuring the dynamic resilient modulus was established, which characterized the dynamic stress state of the subgrade induced by the heavy-haul train load. In the experimental investigation, the deviatoric stresses, confining stress, initial moisture content, and compaction degree were considered as variables, and the effects of the aforementioned variables were evaluated quantitatively. The experimental results showed that the dynamic resilient modulus was negatively related to deviatoric stresses and initial moisture content, where the average decreased rates were 14.65% and 27.79% with the increase in deviatoric stresses from 60 kPa to 150 kPa and increase in the initial moisture content from 9.8% to 15.8%, respectively. Furthermore, the dynamic resilient modulus was positively related to confining stress and compaction degree, where the average increased rates were 23.25% and 27.48% with the increase in confining stress from 20 kPa to 60 kPa and increase in compaction degree from 0.91 to 0.95. To provide a better application, the two high-accuracy predicted methods were established through the empirical model and artificial neural network approach including the aforementioned variables. This study can provide useful guidelines for the effective and safe design of the heavy-haul railway subgrade filled with silty clay.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hao2023dynamic,
  author = {Jianwen Hao and Wang Hong-guo and Xiaoning Zhang and Tao Lin and Xiufeng Jiang and Congcong Liu and Xiangyang Li},
  title = {{Dynamic resilient modulus of subgrade silty clay for heavy-haul railway: an experimental investigation and the predicted method}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2023.1276116},
}
Figure