Undrained instability and fluidization of soft subgrade soils under cyclic rail loading

Buddhima Indraratna, Thanh Trung Nguyen, Joseph Arivalagan, Mandeep Singh, Cholachat Rujikiatkamjorn, Tri Minh Doan, Tuan-Kiet DoanOpenalex Unknown 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

The rapidly increasing demand for rail infrastructure to transport passengers and freight has inevitably led to a need for more robust and sustainable track foundations. However, heavy haul rail tracks often run across unfavourable soil conditions (e.g., saturated soft estuarine soils), resulting in frequent track failures accompanied with high maintenance cost. Recent site investigations along the South Coast rail line (NSW, Australia) showed considerable track degradation induced by subgrade mud pumping, requiring urgent attention and studies. This paper thus presents extensive laboratory and numerical investigations on the mechanism and possible solutions for mud pumping. While the effects of mud pumping on track performance are investigated through large-scale permeability and shear tests using the collected fouled ballast, the subgrade soil is subjected to cyclic triaxial and large-scale cyclic testing to understand the soil fluidization and fine particle migration. Transducers are installed at different layers to observe the depth-dependent response of soil foundation under various conditions. The results show that when specimens are subjected to unfavourable cyclic stresses, the fine particles migrate from the lower toward the upper soil layers along with the redistribution of pore water. When the water content of the upper soil layer reaches the liquid limit, the top of the specimen transforms into a slurry. Micro-analysis based on CFD-DEM coupling indicates a serious degradation in soil fabric and strength, thus the formation of mud under rising excess pore water pressure (EPWP). The study indicates that adding reasonable mass of cohesive fines can enhance the resistance of subgrade soils to fluidization, while geotextiles and geocomposites can also be used to mitigate mud pumping. Prefabricated vertical drains (PVDs) can continually reduce the buildup of EPWPs over the time due to the substantial reduction in drainage path, suggesting the efficiency of using the combined PVD-geocomposite system to mitigate mud pumping.

The Challenge: Subgrade Fluidization and Mud Pumping

In coastal regions like New South Wales, Australia, rail tracks often traverse soft, saturated estuarine soils. The passage of heavy freight trains—frequently exceeding 30 tonnes per axle—subjects these foundations to intense cyclic loading. This repeated compression generates Excess Pore Water Pressure (EPWP) within the subgrade. If this pressure cannot dissipate quickly enough, the soil loses its effective stress and internal structure, eventually behaving like a liquid.

Figure 1: Site investigation along the South Coast rail line (NSW) showing mud-fouled ballast and excavation at a mud pumping site.

This phenomenon, known as "mud pumping," involves the upward migration of fine subgrade particles into the ballast layer. The resulting "slurry track" compromises the interlocking strength of the ballast, leading to track heave and significant maintenance costs.

Investigating the Mechanics

To understand this failure mode, researchers at the University of Technology Sydney (UTS) conducted multi-scale investigations. Reconstituted soil specimens from the South Coast line were subjected to cyclic triaxial testing to identify the "Critical Cyclic Stress Ratio" (CSRc).

Figure 3: Laboratory cyclic triaxial testing showing specimen preparation and the visual signs of fluidization, including bulging and slurry formation.

The experiments revealed a clear tipping point: below the CSRc, the soil remains stable; above it, EPWP and axial strains escalate rapidly. Post-test analysis confirmed that fines migrate from lower to upper regions, with fluidization occurring once the upper layer's water content reaches its liquid limit.

Micro-Scale Insights and Mitigation

Numerical modeling using CFD-DEM (Computational Fluid Dynamics - Discrete Element Method) coupling provided a granular view of the process. As internal hydraulic gradients rise, the particle-to-particle contact network degrades significantly—losing 20% to 35% of its contacts. This loss of fabric stability is the fundamental cause of the soil's transition to a fluid state.

To combat this, the study evaluated various geosynthetic solutions. While standard geotextiles provide a basic filter, they often struggle to dissipate high EPWP under heavy loads. The most effective solution identified was a combined system:

  • Geocomposites: Act as a robust separator and filter to prevent fine migration.
  • Prefabricated Vertical Drains (PVDs): Drastically shorten the drainage path, allowing EPWP to bleed off rapidly.

Key Findings

  • Pressure Reduction: The combined PVD-geocomposite system achieved approximately an 80% reduction in EPWP at 40mm below the interface compared to standard setups.
  • Deformation Control: In "free drainage" tests, axial strain exceeded 6% after only 500 cycles. With the geocomposite (T1), strain was controlled to roughly 3% even after 100,000 cycles.
  • Critical Thresholds: For a typical subgrade density (1790 kg/m³), the critical stress ratio was identified between 0.4 and 0.5.

This research underscores that while soft subgrades present significant engineering challenges, the strategic application of combined geosynthetic systems can effectively "tame the slurry," ensuring more resilient and sustainable rail infrastructure.

Summary updated

Abstract

The rapidly increasing demand for rail infrastructure to transport passengers and freight has inevitably led to a need for more robust and sustainable track foundations. However, heavy haul rail tracks often run across unfavourable soil conditions (e.g., saturated soft estuarine soils), resulting in frequent track failures accompanied with high maintenance cost. Recent site investigations along the South Coast rail line (NSW, Australia) showed considerable track degradation induced by subgrade mud pumping, requiring urgent attention and studies. This paper thus presents extensive laboratory and numerical investigations on the mechanism and possible solutions for mud pumping. While the effects of mud pumping on track performance are investigated through large-scale permeability and shear tests using the collected fouled ballast, the subgrade soil is subjected to cyclic triaxial and large-scale cyclic testing to understand the soil fluidization and fine particle migration. Transducers are installed at different layers to observe the depth-dependent response of soil foundation under various conditions. The results show that when specimens are subjected to unfavourable cyclic stresses, the fine particles migrate from the lower toward the upper soil layers along with the redistribution of pore water. When the water content of the upper soil layer reaches the liquid limit, the top of the specimen transforms into a slurry. Micro-analysis based on CFD-DEM coupling indicates a serious degradation in soil fabric and strength, thus the formation of mud under rising excess pore water pressure (EPWP). The study indicates that adding reasonable mass of cohesive fines can enhance the resistance of subgrade soils to fluidization, while geotextiles and geocomposites can also be used to mitigate mud pumping. Prefabricated vertical drains (PVDs) can continually reduce the buildup of EPWPs over the time due to the substantial reduction in drainage path, suggesting the efficiency of using the combined PVD-geocomposite system to mitigate mud pumping.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{indraratna2023undrained,
  author = {Buddhima Indraratna and Thanh Trung Nguyen and Joseph Arivalagan and Mandeep Singh and Cholachat Rujikiatkamjorn and Tri Minh Doan and Tuan-Kiet Doan},
  title = {{Undrained instability and fluidization of soft subgrade soils under cyclic rail loading}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1201/9781003299127-2},
}
Figure