Experimental Analysis on High-Rated High-Elastic Clutch Coupling

H Nakano, Yooichi Nakamura, Kooichi Yagi, Yoshiki Doi, Hiroshi Sawada, Tadaki SuzukiJOURNAL 1971 · DOI

Abstract: As marine propulsion plants shift toward multi-geared diesel systems using medium-speed, high-output engines, there is an increasing demand for high-performance, high-reliability clutch couplings. This research details the development of a pneumatic double-cone friction clutch integrated with high-elastic rubber elements. Initial testing was conducted on a 500 ps prototype using an inertial test rig to establish baseline performance and thermal characteristics. Subsequently, a full-scale 10,000 ps coupling was developed and tested alongside a Kawasaki-M.A.N V8V 40/54 diesel engine. Results confirmed the system's ability to handle rated torque, effectively damp torsional vibrations, and withstand the thermal stresses of repeated engagement, validating its readiness for large-scale marine applications.

TL;DR

This paper details the development and rigorous testing of a high-capacity, high-elasticity clutch coupling designed for modern multi-geared marine diesel plants. By integrating a pneumatic double-cone friction clutch with high-elastic rubber elements, the researchers successfully demonstrated a system capable of handling 10,000 ps while effectively damping vibrations and compensating for shaft misalignment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As marine propulsion shifts toward "multi-geared" diesel plants—where multiple medium-speed, high-output engines drive a single propeller shaft—the industry faces a significant mechanical challenge. These systems require highly reliable clutch couplings to connect and disconnect engines safely.

Standard couplings often struggle with three main issues:

  1. Vibration: Diesel engines produce significant torsional torque fluctuations that can damage gearboxes.
  2. Alignment: Large ships experience hull deformation, leading to shaft misalignment that rigid couplings cannot handle.
  3. Heat: Engaging a high-power clutch generates immense friction heat, which can lead to "thermal cracking" of the clutch drum or "fading" of the lining material.

The authors sought to create a high-capacity solution (scaling up to 10,000 ps) that addresses these mechanical and thermal hurdles at a reasonable manufacturing cost.

Methods

The research followed a two-stage experimental approach:

  1. Model Testing (500 ps): The team first built a medium-sized prototype to establish baseline technical data. They used an inertial braking test rig to evaluate vibration damping, alignment compensation, and the frictional characteristics of different lining materials.
  2. Full-Scale Prototype (10,000 ps): Based on the model data, they manufactured a large-scale version (Model KE44C). This was tested on a land-based rig connected to a Kawasaki-M.A.N V8V 40/54 diesel engine (8,690 ps at 400 rpm).
Figure 4: Schematic of the performance test rig used for the 500 ps prototype, featuring a 75kW induction motor and flywheel.
  1. Theoretical Correlation: The researchers developed mathematical models to calculate the temperature rise on the clutch sliding surfaces during engagement, validating these against experimental thermocouple data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integrated Design: The core innovation was the integration of the pneumatic double-cone clutch inside the high-elastic rubber coupling. This compact design allows the rubber elements to absorb shocks and compensate for mounting errors simultaneously.
Figure 3: Cross-sectional diagram of the integrated pneumatic double-cone friction clutch and high-elastic rubber coupling.
  • Material Superiority: The study found that semi-metallic clutch linings are significantly more stable than resin-molded ones for high-capacity marine applications, particularly regarding wear and friction consistency under heat.
  • Thermal Cracking Threshold: The researchers identified a specific limit for thermal cracking on the clutch drum surface. They found that maintaining a specific ratio between absorbed energy and sliding time prevents surface failure.
  • Automatic Control: The pneumatic system allows for easy remote or automatic operation, which is crucial for modern "crash-astern" (emergency stop/reverse) maneuvers.

Key Results

  • Capacity: The full-scale coupling successfully handled rated torque for a 10,000 ps system.
  • Vibration Damping: The coupling effectively "damped out" torsional vibrations across the entire operating range, protecting the reduction gears.
  • Durability: The system showed sufficient endurance for continuous load and repeated engagement/disengagement cycles.
  • Thermal Validation: Theoretical temperature calculations closely matched experimental results, confirming the validity of their heat-transfer models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Initial Wear: The authors noted that wear rates in the full-scale trials were higher than in the model tests, likely due to "initial wear" effects. Long-term wear characteristics in actual sea service remain to be documented.
  • Simulation Gaps: While the thermal models were strong, the authors acknowledged that more sophisticated computer simulations are needed to model the non-steady-state dynamics of the entire propulsion system.
  • Rubber Thermal Limits: There is a physical limit to how much the rubber elements can be thickened to increase elasticity, as internal heat generation from cyclic loading can eventually degrade the material.

Reference: Nakano, H., et al. (1971). Experimental Analysis on High-Rated High-Elastic Clutch Coupling. Journal of the Marine Engineering Society in Japan, 6(3).

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{nakano1971experimental,
  author = {H Nakano and Yooichi Nakamura and Kooichi Yagi and Yoshiki Doi and Hiroshi Sawada and Tadaki Suzuki},
  title = {{Experimental Analysis on High-Rated High-Elastic Clutch Coupling}},
  journal = {JOURNAL},
  year = {1971},
  doi = {10.5988/jime1966.6.3\_167},
}
Figure