Development of a Low-Speed High-Efficiency PMSM and Its Drive System for Electric Windlass and Mooring Winch

Gui-Hou Zhou, Mingzhong Qiao, Xiao-Feng Zhang, Jin-Hui Xie, Qing-Liang Hao, Cong Wan, Yong ZhouIEEE Access 2022 · DOI

Introduction

Mooring winches and windlasses are critical for ship safety, yet traditional designs often present a compromise between efficiency and reliability. Hydraulic systems, while common, suffer from low efficiency, complex piping, and the risk of oil pollution. Conversely, existing electric alternatives frequently utilize older motor types—such as pole-changing or asynchronous motors—that are prone to noise, excessive vibration, and lack the sophisticated control required for modern "intelligent" vessels.

The primary engineering challenge lies in the specific operational requirements of deck machinery: they must provide high torque at very low speeds to pull heavy loads while maintaining a wide speed range for rapid line retraction. Developing a Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor (PMSM) that balances high efficiency at low speeds with robust flux-weakening capabilities for high-speed operation is a complex task, especially given the harsh maritime environment and high impact loads.

Methodology

To address these challenges, this research proposes a parameter matching design method that deviates from standard "off-the-shelf" motor design. This approach integrates three main pillars:

  1. Mathematical Optimization: The researchers derived estimation formulas for stator copper loss, identifying a specific geometric heuristic: motor efficiency is maximized when the length-to-inner-diameter ratio ($K_L$) is approximately twice the winding end ratio ($K_1$).
  2. Advanced Simulation: The team employed Finite Element Method (FEM) analysis for magnetic fields and "field-circuit coupling" to simulate the interaction between the motor and the drive circuitry.
  3. Co-Simulation: By linking MotorSolve and Simulink, the authors optimized control parameters (such as PI loops for constant tension) in tandem with the physical motor geometry.
Integrated design and optimization flowchart for the PMSM and drive system.

Hardware Implementation and Innovations

The physical implementation of the design resulted in a 110 kW prototype. The rotor utilizes an interior permanent magnet (IPM) configuration with a "V" and "Segmented" shape to enhance flux-weakening capability. This design allows the winch to retract an empty hook or light line up to three times faster than its rated loading speed.

3D structural cross-section of the developed PMSM highlighting the V-shaped permanent magnets and integrated components.

Key innovations in the hardware design include:

  • Signal Interference Mitigation: High-torque electromagnetic brakes often create magnetic interference that disrupts position sensors. This was resolved by implementing a non-magnetic transition plate and a large-gap reluctance rotary transformer, ensuring signal integrity during heavy braking.
  • Thermal Management: Despite the high power output, the motor utilizes natural cooling. Simulations of the "S2" (short-time) duty cycle typical of winches indicated a temperature rise of approximately 54 K, which remains well within safe operational limits.

Key Results and Performance

The performance of the 110 kW prototype was validated on a 45-ton Electric Windlass and Mooring Winch (EWMW) deep-sea test platform, with results verified against China Classification Society standards.

  • Efficiency: The PMSM achieved an efficiency of 94.3% at rated operation (75 r/min). When accounting for the gear and inverter, the total system efficiency reached 88.9%, a significant improvement over traditional drives.
  • Overload and Control: The system demonstrated a 2.3x short-time overload capacity, essential for breaking anchors free from the seabed. Furthermore, the control system restored target speeds within 0.02 seconds following a 14,000 N.m load disturbance.

Conclusion and Future Work

While the prototype successfully demonstrates the advantages of permanent magnetization for ship drive systems, the authors acknowledge that this is a large-scale system integration challenge. Future research will focus on enhancing "upper computer" communication and integrating more complex intelligent control algorithms. Additionally, long-term studies are needed to evaluate the mechanical wear of segmented rotors under continuous high-impact sea states and extreme tropical environments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhou2022development,
  author = {Gui-Hou Zhou and Mingzhong Qiao and Xiao-Feng Zhang and Jin-Hui Xie and Qing-Liang Hao and Cong Wan and Yong Zhou},
  title = {{Development of a Low-Speed High-Efficiency PMSM and Its Drive System for Electric Windlass and Mooring Winch}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2022.3149918},
}
Figure